Causal Discovery in Multivariate Extremes via Tail Asymmetry
Mengran Li, Daniela Castro-Camilo · 2026
Read Causal Discovery in Multivariate Extremes via Tail Asymmetry by Mengran Li, Daniela Castro-Camilo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-21620.txt.
Introduction
Mengran Li and Daniela Castro-Camilo use tail asymmetry to find causal direction among extremes, where a forward guess from cause to effect beats the reverse guess time after time. Their two-stage system for structure learning, S3ME, first finds a thin candidate web of links while allowing for hidden shared shocks. It then points each link by cutting tail guess risk with max-linear envelope models. Tests and uses on river webs and financial tail-risk webs show tough, clear spread patterns with no preset graph.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mengran Li, Daniela Castro-Camilo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89803 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21620
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Causal Discovery in Multivariate Extremes via Tail Asymmetry Mengran Li, Daniela Castro-Camilo Abstract Causal discovery in multivariate extremes is challenging because extreme observations are sparse, dependent, and often affected by latent common shocks. Existing approaches focus on undirected extremal dependence, require prior graph restriction, and do not scale beyond small systems. We introduce tail-induced asymmetry as a principle for causal directionality in heavy-tailed systems, where extreme events propagate asymmetrically so that forward tail prediction is systematically easier than backward prediction. We show that this asymmetry yields identifiable causal direction under a canonical max-linear model and provides a basis for score-based structure learning in the tail regime. Building on this, we propose Sparse Structure diScovery in Multivariate Extremes (S3ME), a two-stage data-driven framework for causal discovery. The first stage performs proxy-adjusted penalized neighbourhood selection to recover a sparse candidate skeleton under latent confounding. The second stage orients edges by minimizing tail prediction risk based on max-linear envelope models, exploiting directional asymmetry. We establish high-dimensional guarantees for skeleton screening and consistency of the score-based estimator under population separation conditions. Simulations demonstrate robustness to latent confounding and favourable scaling relative to existing extremal methods. Applications to river network data and financial tail-risk networks show that the approach recovers sparse, interpretable propagation structures without prespecified graph structure. Keywords: Extremal dependence graphs, Latent confounding adjustment, Score-based structure learning. 1 Introduction Extreme events often propagate through interconnected systems, making directional inference central to risk assessment and intervention. In environmental, financial, and infrastructural settings, the key question is not merely whether variables co-exceed in the tail, but whether an extreme at one variable helps generate an extreme at another ( 1 ; 10 ) . This question is especially difficult in the tail regime, where extreme observations are sparse, tail dependence can differ sharply from bulk behaviour, and latent common drivers can simultaneously push many variables into the tail, inducing strong and largely symmetric co-exceedance that swamps the directional signatures of local propagation and makes both skeleton screening and edge orientation unreliable without explicit adjustment ( 15 ) . Classical causal discovery procedures such as the PC algorithm ( 17 ) , LiNGAM (Linear Non-Gaussian Acyclic Model; 16 ), and NOTEARS ( 20 ) are therefore poorly matched to this setting. Their inferential logic is calibrated to bulk-level conditional independence, likelihood structure, or non-Gaussian variation rather than to tail events. Extreme-value statistics has led to substantial progress in graphical modelling for tail dependence. Along the undirected line , extremal graphical models show that sparse tail dependence can be represented through graphical structure, making extremal graph learning substantially more tractable ( 5 ) . Subsequent work develops structure learning for extremal tree models and related extensions of this line ( 6 ) . Along the directed line , approaches have emerged under recursive max-linear or related heavy-tailed structural equation model formulations. Early work formulates Bayesian-network structure for max-linear systems ( 12 ) . Subsequent contributions study identifiability, estimation, and causal discovery in recursive max-linear or heavy-tailed models ( 9 ; 11 ; 14 ) . Taken together, these developments show that directional learning in extremes is possible, but not yet in the form needed for fully data-driven causal discovery in larger multivariate systems. The undirected line yields sparse tail structure without causal orientation, whereas the directed line typically relies on stronger structural restrictions, narrower graph classes, or a prespecified candidate graph before orientation can begin. In practice, existing directed approaches are largely confined to small or pre-structured systems. Graph learning typically requires a candidate skeleton or partial ordering as input, and empirical studies rarely exceed 30 nodes. Learning the graph entirely from tail data, without prior structural knowledge, in systems with hundreds of variables and latent confounding, remains out of reach for existing methods. We address this gap through a structural insight. Extreme-value processes driven by regularly varying innovations obey the single big jump principle ( 15 ) , under which tail events are typically generated by one dominant shock rather than by the accumulation of many moderate contributions. In recursive extremal systems, this creates a directional imbalance. Conditioning on an extreme at a cause sharply constrains the corresponding effect; conditioning on an extreme at an effect does not identify its source, since the exceedance may have arisen through propagation from another variable or through a local innovation. Predicting forward is therefore systematically easier than predicting backward in the tail regime. We call this phenomenon tail-induced asymmetry . Building on this insight, we propose Sparse Structure Discovery in Multivariate Extremes (S3ME), a two-stage framework for causal discovery in multivariate extremes. The first stage screens for a sparse candidate skeleton via proxy-adjusted penalized regression, where the proxy adjustment attenuates symmetric dependence induced by latent common shocks. The second stage orients edges by exploiting tail-induced asymmetry through a score-based procedure. The framework is supported by an identifiability result for the canonical bivariate case, high-dimensional consistency guarantees for both stages, and a robustness analysis showing that proxy adjustment suppresses confounding-induced false positives where existing directed methods deteriorate. We apply the method to 31 gauging stations locations in the upper Danube river network and a tail-risk network of 103 S&P 500 constituents spanning all eleven GICS sectors, settings substantially larger than those in existing directed extremal work. Our method recovers sparse, interpretable propagation structures without any prior graph specification. The paper makes three contributions. First, we identify tail-induced asymmetry as an exploitable source of causal directionality in heavy-tailed systems, a mechanism that has not previously been exploited for graph orientation in high-dimensional, fully data-driven settings. Second, we show that this asymmetry supports consistent edge orientation in high-dimensional settings without a prespecified graph, extending the reach of causal discovery in extremes well beyond existing methods. Third, we develop a proxy-adjustment procedure that remains stable under latent confounding at a scale where competing directed approaches accumulate large numbers of spurious edges. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 establishes the core identifiability result based on tail-induced asymmetry. Section 3 presents the two-stage methodology. Section 4 provides theoretical guarantees for high-dimensional consistency and robustness to latent confounding. Section 5 evaluates finite-sample performance through simulations, Section 6 applies the method to hydrological and financial data and Section 7 concludes the paper. Reproducible code is available at https://github.com/MengranLi-git/S3ME . 2 Identifiability via Tail Asymmetry 2.1 Recursive Extremal SEMs and Tail Prediction Risk In complex systems, tail events may propagate along directed pathways. To represent this mechanism, we consider a recursive extremal structural equation model. Assumption 1 (Recursive Extremal SEM) . Let X=(X_{1},\dots,X_{p})^{\top} be a strictly positive random vector. There exists a directed acyclic graph (DAG) \mathcal{G}=(V,E) with parent sets \text{pa}(j) such that, for j=1,\dots,p , X_{j}=f_{j}\!\big(\{X_{i}:i\in\text{pa}(j)\}\big)+\epsilon_{j}, (1) where: (i) f_{j}(\cdot) is non-decreasing in each argument and homogeneous of order 1 , i.e., f_{j}(cx)=cf_{j}(x) for all c>0 ; (ii) \epsilon_{1},\dots,\epsilon_{p} are mutually independent, strictly positive, and regularly varying with common tail index \alpha>0 . Assumption 1 includes standard recursive extremal SEMs, including max-linear and extremal additive constructions, and implies multivariate regular variation for X . The single big jump principle then creates a characteristic directional imbalance in the tail, whereby conditioning on an extreme at a parent can substantially reduce uncertainty about its descendants,