Hawking radiation from black holes in 2 + 1 2+1 dimensions

Akriti Garg, Ayan Chatterjee · 2026

Read Hawking radiation from black holes in 2 + 1 2+1 dimensions by Akriti Garg, Ayan Chatterjee (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-21540.txt.

Introduction

Akriti Garg and Ayan Chatterjee model a black hole horizon's quantum geometry and Hawking emission in 2+1 dimensions. Using horizon charge algebra, they treat the horizon as built from quantised lengths, each a multiple of 8 pi Planck lengths. Black hole entropy from this length spectrum lands near the Bekenstein-Hawking value. A near-horizon observer relates horizon entropy to black hole energy, so they build a length ensemble like Krasnov's area ensemble, yielding the black-body spectrum. The local observer sees a Hawking spectrum with Tolman-shifted temperature.

Catalog record

CREATORAkriti Garg, Ayan Chatterjee
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48594
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21540

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hawking radiation from black holes in 2 + 1 2+1 dimensions Akriti Garg, Ayan Chatterjee Abstract The paper develops a model to understand the effective quantum geometry of a black hole horizon and the emission of Hawking spectrum in 2 + 1 2+1 dimensions. We argue that one may view the black hole horizon as formed out of quantised lengths of elementary quanta of value 8 ​ π ​ ℓ P ​ n 8\pi\ell_{P}\,n , where n ∈ ℕ n\in\mathbb{N} , and ℓ P \ell_{P} is the Planck length. To an observer near the black hole horizon, the entropy (or length of horizon cross- section) is related to the black hole energy. Hence, one may develop a formulation of length ensemble (similar to the area canonical ensemble of Krasnov) from which the black body spectrum may be obtained directly. To this local observer, the temperature of the Hawking spectrum is modified due to the Tolman factor. The uniqueness theorems state that black holes in 4 - dimensions may be characterised by their mass ( \mathscr{M} ), charge ( \mathscr{Q} ) and angular momentum ( \mathscr{J} ) only 32 ; 20 ; 37 ; 34 . Due to this simplicity, black holes have a status similar to hydrogen atoms in the quantum theory of matter: they are considered as the first frontier to develop quantum geometry. This expectation arose due to several results during the last few decades. The foremost of them was the fundamental discovery due to Bardeen, Carter and Hawking that black hole horizons in equilibrium, have laws of mechanics which are suspiciously similar to the laws of thermodynamics 9 . More precisely, they proved that (a) the surface gravity ( \kappa ) is a constant on the horizon, (b) area of the horizon cross- section \mathscr{A} always increases in a classical physical process, and (c) horizons evolve to nearby equilibrium states in such a way that the horizon parameters are related through the following variational equation: \delta{\mathscr{M}}=(\kappa/8\pi)\,\delta\mathscr{A}+\Phi\,\delta\mathscr{Q}+\Omega\,\delta\mathscr{J}, (1) where \Phi is the electromagnetic potential, and \Omega denotes angular velocity of the horizon 1 1 1 One may also state a certain version of the third law as well, although its ramifications for gravity is not entirely clear 45 ; 46 . This immediately suggested to Bekenstein that horizon area should have the thermodynamic interpretation as the entropy of black holes 13 ; 14 . He argued that black hole horizons must be assigned an entropy equal to \mathscr{S}=\mathscr{A}/4\ell_{P}^{2} , where \ell_{P}=\sqrt{\hbar} (in 4 dimensions and with G=c=1 units), is the Planck length. Once this point of view is accepted, a look at the equation ( 1 ) tells us that horizons must be accorded a temperature \kappa\ell_{P}/2\pi . Hawking’s semiclassical calculation proved that large black holes ( \mathscr{A}\gg\ell_{P}^{2} ), produced from gravitational collapse of matter fields, do indeed behave like a perfect black body and an observer at null infinity \mathscr{I}^{+} receives a flux of radiation at \kappa\ell_{P}/2\pi 33 . One must note that the introduction of \hbar in the first law, eqn. ( 1 ) is a clear indication that, at the fundamental level, quantum effects control the geometry of horizons and even its evolution. To formulate an effective quantum theory of horizon, one faces an immediate question: is there a notion of Hamiltonian or energy associated with the horizon? Such a question is difficult to answer from the eqn. ( 1 ), since the equation has a curious mixture of global and local quantities: while \mathscr{A} is defined locally on the horizon, quantities like \kappa , \mathscr{M} , and \mathscr{J} may only be defined with reference to observers at the asymptopia. Furthermore, in the quantum theory when Hawking radiation is in full swing, and the horizon is evaporating, global definitions of horizon (event horizon for example), which forms the basis of eqn. ( 1 ), may not be available. The isolated horizon (IH) formulation remedies this situation. One may show that the IH satisfies a quasilocal version of eqn. ( 1 ): \displaystyle\delta{\mathscr{E}}=(\kappa_{IH}/8\pi)\,\delta\mathscr{A}_{IH}+\Phi_{IH}\,\delta\mathscr{Q}_{IH}+\Omega_{IH}\,\delta\mathscr{J}_{IH}, (2) where the quantities like \kappa_{IH} , \mathscr{J}_{IH} , \cdots are all defined quasilocally on the horizon and \mathscr{E} is the quasilocal energy (or the Hamiltonian function associated with the horizon generator) 3 ; 2 ; 4 ; 22 . However, one still cannot integrate this equation to obtain the quasilocal energy since the exact dependence of the intensive quantities like \kappa_{IH},\Omega_{IH} are not known in terms of the extensive variables \mathscr{A}_{IH},\mathscr{J}_{IH} . The reason is the reliance only on the horizon geometry, and one needs to go off the horizon to extract some reasonable features 30 ; 28 ; 31 ; 29 . A few years back, Ghosh and Perez had argued that for 4 - dimensional stationary black holes in GR, one may find a preferred class of observers near the horizon for whom, the first law of black hole mechanics reduces to a form \delta\mathscr{E}=(\bar{\kappa}/8\pi)\delta A 30 ; 28 ; 31 . Here, \bar{\kappa}=1/\ell_{0} is the value of local surface gravity if the observer is at a proper distance \ell_{0} from the horizon. This implies that the local first law has a universal form for these preferred observers and is independent of the mass, charge or angular momentum of the black hole spacetime. A simple integration of this equation leads to \mathscr{E}=(\bar{\kappa}/8\pi)A+o(\ell_{0}) and so, for a large black hole and \ell_{0}\ll A , the horizon energy as perceived by the local observer is \mathscr{E}=(\bar{\kappa}/8\pi)A . This interpretation not only holds for the Kerr- Neumann class of solutions, but has been proved to be valid for isolated horizons (IH) as well 30 ; 28 ; 31 ; 24 ; 44 . The natural question is whether this local \bar{\kappa} may admit a thermodynamical interpretation if one accounts for the quantum effects, or in other words, if one formulates a process through which the Hawking effect may be calculated for these local observers, would they have as a black body distribution at the temperature \bar{\kappa}/2\pi ? Over the last few years, many plausible arguments in favour of this question, in the affirmative, has been forwarded 30 ; 28 ; 31 ; 44 . Here, in this paper, we shall try to put this on strong footing in the context of a black hole horizon in 2+1 dimensions. In particular, we shall show that an effective quantum process may be formulated for these 2+1 horizons through which a black body emission spectrum with temperature \bar{\kappa}/2\pi may be obtained. But why 2+1 dimensions in particular? The gravitational field in 2+1 spacetime dimensions has no propagating local degrees of freedom; the vacuum solutions imply that the spacetime is locally flat, or has a constant curvature depending on the cosmological constant 19 . However, the theory is not trivial since there does exist a black hole solution when the cosmological constant is negative 7 ; 8 . Naturally, the discovery of this BTZ solution, named after their discoverers, is surprising since black hole horizons are endowed with thermodynamical properties akin to perfect black bodies. More precisely, horizons have entropy ( \mathscr{S} ), and can emit Hawking radiation at a temperature proportional to their surface gravity \kappa . So, horizons must admit (quite a large amount of)

Read the complete text