Architectures for Robust Self-Organizing Energy Systems under Information and Control Constraints

Emilie Frost, Astrid Nieße · 2026

Read Architectures for Robust Self-Organizing Energy Systems under Information and Control Constraints by Emilie Frost, Astrid Nieße (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-21529.txt.

Introduction

Emilie Frost and Astrid Nieße present observer/controller variants for controlled self-organization in agent-based energy systems, where self-organization plus intervention handles disturbances such as cyber attacks. Observer and controller roles must respect limits on information and action from local resource privacy, regulation, and data exchange needs. The paper offers variants honoring limits on information access and action, and evaluates controller actions across architectures. Results stress that observer/controller choices matter for real-world robustness of agent-based energy systems.

Catalog record

CREATOREmilie Frost, Astrid Nieße
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33000
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21529

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Architectures for Robust Self-Organizing Energy Systems under Information and Control Constraints Emilie Frost, Astrid Nieße Abstract Applying the concept of controlled self-organization in agent-based Cyber-Physical Energy Systems (CPES) is a promising approach to ensure system robustness. By introducing an observer/controller architecture to the system, this concept allows for self-organization while still enabling intervention when disturbances occur. Thus, it is possible to respond to effects of cyber attacks, a major threat to current energy systems. However, when implementing an observer to monitor the system and a controller to execute actions for controlled self-organization in CPES, it is essential to take into account restrictions on information and actions resulting from the privacy of local distributed energy resources, regulatory constraints, and data exchange requirements. For this reason, this paper presents architecture variants for the observer and controller that take into account restrictions on access to information and limited actions. In addition, it evaluates possible controller actions in various architectures. The results underscore the importance of considering observer/controller architectures when designing agent-based systems to ensure their robustness for real-world applications. 1 Introduction Current energy systems are evolving into Cyber-Physical Energy Systems (CPES) 1 1 1 CPES as cyber-physical energy systems is a term that should stress the cyber-physical character of current energy systems. Correctly spoken, CPES are cyber-physical systems of systems (CPESoS). For reasons of brevity, this is shortened to CPES . , fully integrating physical energy system infrastructures with digital technologies. This brings new vulnerabilities, particularly in the form of cyber attacks that pose significant threats to the stability and security of these systems [ 17 , 2 ] . Due to the distributed nature of CPES , Multi-Agent Systems (MAS) are well suited for various use cases, as system management and control [ 19 ] . To ensure robustness against potential threats, these systems can incorporate principles of controlled self-organization [ 4 ] . Controlled self-organization comes from the field of Organic Computing and allows for self-organization of the system while still having the ability to take actions in case of unexpected events, such as cyber attacks [ 20 , 4 ] . To achieve this, an observer/controller architecture is introduced [ 20 ] . The observer monitors the system and performs tasks such as anomaly detection. The controller receives observations and performs actions in response, such as implementing mitigation strategies. CPES often operate under constraints such as limited access to information and control actions, driven by privacy concerns, regulatory limitations or even requirements for data exchange minimization [ 11 ] . It is essential to consider these constraints when implementing a suitable observer/controller architecture, as access to information impacts the performance of anomaly detection, while limited actions influence the effectiveness of possible controller implementations. To consider a robust self-organizing system, a suitable observer/controller architecture must be designed considering access to information, actions. It is essential to find a suitable architecture taking these constraints into account, in order to ensure the functionality and robustness of the existing system, even when disturbances occur. In this context, previous research has focused on evaluating different observer architectures for anomaly detection, considering limited access to information [ 11 ] . The contribution of this work is to add and develop the controller perspective. An evaluation of different controller actions and architectures is done for an agent-based control use case. The evaluation’s outcomes improve existing reaction strategies, thereby enhancing the system’s overall robustness in the presence of disturbances or attacks. The paper is organized as follows. In section 2 , related work regarding different design variants of the observer/controller architecture for CPES is presented. Afterwards, section 3 discusses relevant architectures for the observer, followed by the presentation of controller actions and architectures in section 4 . In section 5 , multiple architecture variants are evaluated, focusing on the controller but taking into account previous observer results. The paper concludes with the discussion in section 6 and the conclusion in section 7 . 2 Related Work In this section, design variants for the observer/controller architecture are discussed mutually, considering concepts from Organic Computing and for controller architectures for CPES in general 2 2 2 This section extends the related work presented in [ 11 ] (focusing on observer architectures) for controller architectures. . Centralized architectures In centralized architectures for observer and controller, a single observer and a single controller regulate various components of the entire system and intervene with all entities [ 24 ] . A centralized observer has access to global information knowledge from all control units [ 23 , 24 , 8 ] , while the controller takes action on the entire system [ 5 ] . Decentralized architectures This type of architecture considers one controller and one observer separately for each component [ 24 ] , without any information about other parts of the system [ 23 ] . Using a decentralized architecture for the observer and controller, the operation process of the system is decoupled into smaller steps [ 5 ] . This might be the case to parallelize steps for efficiency [ 5 ] . In this architecture, no communication between the decentralized controllers is assumed [ 5 ] . Distributed architectures Distributed architectures are similar to decentralized ones, however, communication between the controllers is possible [ 5 ] . Information about local measurements can be communicated among neighboring controllers [ 23 ] . Multi-Leveled / hierarchical architectures Furthermore, it is also possible to combine the previous architectures into multi-leveled or hierarchical architectures [ 24 ] . In hierarchical architectures, one observer and one controller per component exists, but an additional secondary level of observer and controller is added, responsible for the complete system [ 23 , 24 ] . Even though these architectural models have been theorized and discussed, only very few have been implemented and compared to investigate the effects, particularly under constraints as limited information or control access. Chaaban et al. combine a centralized controller with a decentralized system, presenting a hybrid approach [ 3 ] . However, access to information or control actions is not discussed. In previous work, different anomaly detection architectures are evaluated, considering information availability from the observer perspective only [ 9 , 11 ] . This paper thus fills the gap in the joint consideration of architectures for the observer and the controller for application in agent-based CPES , taking into account access to information and control measures. 3 Observer Architectures in CPES This paper summarizes the outcomes regarding observer architectures for anomaly detection, as presented in previous work [ 11 ] . At first, the agent-based control use case is presented, depicting the implementation setup. The entire section refers to the previous work [ 11 ] . 3.1 Use Case Description The use case is self-consumption optimization, considering redispatch requests from a grid operator, according to the system concepts presented in [ 15 , 18 ] . The agent system represents a neighborhood grid (energy community), performing the self-consumption optimization. The agents manage Distributed Energy Resources (DER) in this neighborhood grid, such as wind turbines, photovoltaic (PV) systems or battery storage systems. Additionally, agents are integrated to control households [ 11 ] . The setup enables evaluation of how cyber attacks, particularly false data

Read the complete text