Analyzing directional errors in spatial orientation using nonparametric circular regression with mixed covariates
Mario Francisco-Fernández, Andrea Meilán-Vila · 2026
Read Analyzing directional errors in spatial orientation using nonparametric circular regression with mixed covariates by Mario Francisco-Fernández, Andrea Meilán-Vila (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-21498.txt.
Introduction
Mario Francisco-Fernández and Andrea Meilán-Vila analyze heading errors with a circular regression method for mixed predictors using a product kernel. Blind, low-vision, and sighted people did spatial updating tasks under five conditions, scoring signed angular error. They derive bias and variance formulas and build a bootstrap bandwidth picker for cosine loss, compared with cross-validation and rule-of-thumb methods. On the data, it reveals nonlinear patterns that vary by condition, with bootstrap confidence bands, with a good bias-variance trade-off.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mario Francisco-Fernández, Andrea Meilán-Vila |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 108266 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21498
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Analyzing directional errors in spatial orientation using nonparametric circular regression with mixed covariates Mario Francisco-Fernández, Andrea Meilán-Vila Abstract Spatial orientation is a fundamental cognitive skill that relies on sensory information to update perceived direction. Understanding how sensory conditions influence directional accuracy is important for both cognitive science and the design of assistive technologies. We analyze experimental data in which blind, low-vision, and sighted participants performed spatial updating tasks under five sensory conditions, with signed angular error as the response. To model these data, we propose a nonparametric circular regression framework that accommodates both continuous and categorical predictors via a product-kernel estimator. Bandwidth selection is crucial in this setting, yet developing practical data-driven methods remains challenging. We derive asymptotic bias and variance expressions for the estimator, though these results do not directly lead to a feasible plug-in bandwidth selector. To address this, we develop a bootstrap bandwidth selection criterion tailored to the cosine loss and compare it with cross-validation and rule-of-thumb approaches in simulation studies. Applied to the spatial updating data, the proposed framework reveals nonlinear, condition-specific patterns and quantifies uncertainty via simultaneous bootstrap confidence bands. Across the scenarios considered, the proposed bootstrap selector achieves a favorable bias-variance trade-off and yields stable inference relative to the competing methods. An implementation is available in the R package circMixedReg . 1 1 footnotetext: Department of Mathematics, Universidade da Coruña (Spain). 2 2 footnotetext: Department of Statistics, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid (Spain). 3 3 footnotetext: Corresponding author. e-mail: [email protected] . Keywords: Kernel smoothing; Bootstrap methods; Bandwidth selection; Circular data analysis; Human orientation. 1 Introduction Spatial orientation enables humans to locate themselves in their environment and navigate effectively by integrating multiple sensory inputs while moving. Accurate estimation of direction (and distance) is crucial for everyday activities, from moving safely through familiar spaces to exploring novel ones. These processes can become particularly challenging for individuals with visual impairments or in situations where sensory cues are limited, degraded, or conflicting, leading to systematic directional biases and increased uncertainty. Quantifying how sensory conditions affect spatial updating is therefore relevant both for advancing our understanding of cognitive and neural mechanisms and for informing the design of accessible environments, assistive technologies, and rehabilitation strategies. A growing body of research suggests that spatial representations can be preserved and updated without vision, albeit with increased cognitive demands and modality-specific limitations. For instance, 14 showed that navigation without visual input imposes substantially greater cognitive demands, even in familiar settings. Complementarily, 9 provided evidence that spatial images derived from touch and vision can function equivalently in supporting spatial cognition. Non-visual modalities such as audition and proprioception may therefore partially compensate for the absence of vision: 23 highlighted the role of auditory spatial working memory and proprioception for navigation in blind individuals, and 26 reviewed findings indicating that congenitally blind individuals can navigate effectively using non-visual cues, although certain aspects of spatial learning may be limited without visual experience. At the same time, early visual input appears to contribute to the calibration and refinement of spatial representations; for example, 10 reported deficits in auditory spatial localization among congenitally blind individuals. Taken together, these results support a multimodal, experience-dependent view of spatial orientation and motivate statistical tools that can quantify condition-specific directional error patterns while accommodating heterogeneous participant groups. In the present paper, we analyze data from a spatial-updating experiment conducted by 16 . In that study, participants traversed predefined indoor routes composed of three straight segments with two turns and, at the end of each route, indicated the direction (and distance) to a previously viewed target (Figure 1 ). The design was intended to emulate indoor wayfinding demands under reduced sensory input. The dataset comprises 679 trials from 64 participants (32 sighted, 16 low-vision, and 16 blind), with each participant completing multiple trials under five sensory conditions that manipulate the availability of visual and/or auditory information: Control (full vision and hearing), Preview (a brief visual preview of the target followed by blindfolding during locomotion and estimation), Forward Facing (vision available during locomotion but restricted during the pointing/estimation phase), Auditory (blindfolded, relying primarily on self-generated auditory cues such as footsteps and echoes), and Deprivation (blindfolded with noise-canceling headphones). For each trial, the dataset records the true and reported target direction and distance, along with trial- and participant-level identifiers. This experiment is part of a broader line of work on indoor navigation under reduced sensory input ( 17 , see also) . Figure 1 : Spatial-updating task used by 16 . Participants are guided along a three-segment path with two turns to a final location. The target is a beanbag dropped at the first waypoint, and the start location is the doorway. After completing the path, participants reported distance and direction to both the start and the target. In our analysis, the primary outcome is the signed circular error, defined as the angular difference between the reported and true target directions, wrapped to (-\pi,\pi] . This choice contrasts with the absolute directional error summaries reported in 16 . Keeping the sign preserves information about systematic directional bias (clockwise vs. counterclockwise), which is essential for modeling the conditional mean direction in a circular regression framework. We examine how directional error varies with task demand and sensory restriction using sensory condition as a categorical predictor and target distance as a continuous covariate. In additional analyses, we also consider the distance-estimation error (reported minus true distance), a signed measure that distinguishes under- from overestimation either as an additional covariate or as an alternative continuous predictor. We use the signed version ( 16 , rather than the absolute summaries emphasized in) to retain information about systematic bias. Because each participant contributes multiple trials, we conduct the analysis at the trial level, with interest in the population-averaged relationship between directional error and the covariates across trials. We interpret the results accordingly. Modeling circular deviations presents unique challenges because the response lies on the circle, making standard linear regression inappropriate ( 6 ; 12 ) . Moreover, in the spatial-updating setting described above, the predictors naturally combine a continuous measure of task demand with a categorical sensory-condition factor, calling for regression methods that accommodate mixed covariates. Circular nonparametric regression provides a flexible alternative, enabling smooth estimation of the relationship between a circular response and covariates without restrictive parametric assumptions. In practice, local smoothing estimators such as Nadaraya–Watson (NW) and local linear (LL) methods have been studied for a single continuous covariate ( 4 ) and for multiple continuous covariates ( 22 ) , with extensions to functional predictors, time series, and spatially correlated errors ( 21 ; 3 ; 20 ) ; see 1 for an overview. However, to the best of our knowledge, practical methodology for circular regression with mixed covariates, particularly data-driven bandwidth selection and uncertainty quantification, remains largely unexplored. In this paper, we develop a nonparametric circular regression framework for mixed covariates, accommodating both continuous and categorical predictors via a product-kernel NW estimator, motivated by applications such as the spatial-updating data described above. The approach is inspired by mixed-covariate smoothing in Euclidean settings ( 25 ) and adapted to circular responses. Our main contributions are: (i) derivation of the asymptotic bias and variance of the proposed estimator under general