Navigating Order-(Dis)Order Family Trees via Group-Subgroup Transitions

Shuya Yamazaki, Yuyao Huang, Martin Hoffmann Petersen, Wei Nong, Kedar Hippalgaonkar · 2026

Read Navigating Order-(Dis)Order Family Trees via Group-Subgroup Transitions by Shuya Yamazaki, Yuyao Huang, Martin Hoffmann Petersen, Wei Nong, Kedar Hippalgaonkar (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-21386.txt.

Introduction

Shuya Yamazaki and four colleagues warn that novelty claims in materials discovery can be fooled when a predicted ordered crystal merely orders a known disordered phase. Their order-disorder family trees organize ordered and disordered structures through group-subgroup links, with a fast matcher finding disordered parents and ordered kin. Tests on A-Lab cases recover known parents, and wider checks show many seemingly novel structures belong to known families. Models blind to symmetry err most, while symmetry-aware ones are two to four times less prone to the trap.

Catalog record

CREATORShuya Yamazaki, Yuyao Huang, Martin Hoffmann Petersen, Wei Nong, Kedar Hippalgaonkar
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56273
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21386

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Navigating Order-(Dis)Order Family Trees via Group-Subgroup Transitions Shuya Yamazaki, Yuyao Huang, Martin Hoffmann Petersen, Wei Nong, Kedar Hippalgaonkar Abstract As closed-loop materials discovery systems scale to produce millions of candidate compounds, the credibility of the novelty they reward becomes a critical concern. Novelty is commonly assessed against databases of ordered crystal structures, in which atomic sites are fully occupied. Yet, a predicted ordered structure may simply correspond to a particular ordering of a known disordered phase, whose sites are occupied by multiple species in the statistical average structure; we refer to such a structure as an ordered child of a disordered parent. Here, we introduce order-(dis)order family trees, a symmetry-based framework that organizes ordered and disordered structures through group-subgroup relations and enables novelty to be explicitly evaluated. We develop a high-throughput family matching procedure, to identify possible disordered parents and symmetry-related ordered relatives for a given ordered structure. As validation, we test our framework on synthesis-facing case studies (A-Lab), where it correctly recovers existing disordered parents for the targeted ordered structures. Extending this family-tree-based benchmark to experimental structure databases (ICSD), computational datasets (MP-20, Alex-MP-20, and GNoME), and crystal generative models further reveals that many ordered structures that appear novel as individual entries are, in fact, better understood as members of experimentally known order-(dis)order family trees. We also show that this is particularly evident in symmetry-agnostic all-atom generative models, which more frequently produce ordered structures derived from known disordered parents, whereas symmetry-constrained models are 2 2 – 4 × 4\times less prone to this behavior. Our results establish order-(dis)order family trees as a key requirement for achieving genuine novelty in data-driven materials discovery. K eywords Order-Disorder \cdot Group-Subgroup Transitions \cdot Space Group \cdot Materials Discovery 1 Introduction Materials discovery systems are pushing the field toward a closed loop between computational prediction and experimental synthesis. Agentic workflows now produce millions of candidate compounds at a rate that far outpaces experimental characterization, as they scale from proposing structures to directing robotic synthesis 33 ; 24 . Consequently, the central question is no longer simply whether we can predict stable structures beyond the training distribution, but whether the structures we predict are genuinely new to synthesis 4 ; 21 . In current practice, novelty is typically defined by absence from reference databases of ordered crystal structures 37 ; 41 ; 3 . Defining novelty in these systems has become a critical concern: a system that rediscovers known phases dressed as new compounds wastes synthesis cycles and corrupts its own reward. Yet, answering whether a predicted structure is genuinely novel is more subtle than it first appears. Novelty is not an intrinsic property of a compound, but one defined relative to a reference: a structure is novel only with respect to the space against which it is compared, and the choice of that reference therefore shapes what counts as discovery. Although ordered structure databases are a natural reference given the data on which many discovery systems are trained, relying on them alone introduces a systematic blind spot. Experimentally synthesized materials frequently exhibit occupational disorder, in which the same crystallographic lattice sites are occupied by multiple species in the statistical average structure 31 ; hereafter, disordered phase refers to this average crystallographic structure unless otherwise noted. In this setting, a predicted ordered structure may not correspond to a genuinely new compound, but instead to a specific ordering of a known disordered phase. Such a structure corresponds to one of many possible ordered configurations consistent with the same underlying disordered framework. We refer to such predictions as ordered children of disordered parents 4 ; 21 . When disordered phases are not included in the reference space, these ordered children are routinely labeled as novel, leading to a systematic overestimation of discovery rates relative to experimental reality. Recent experimental efforts highlight this exact failure mode. In the A-Lab study 33 , over 65\% of the "successful" syntheses of GNoME compounds 24 were later found to lack the predicted cation ordering, and were instead more plausibly interpreted as already-known disordered parent phases 21 . An example is \text{MgTi}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{NiO}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{6}}} : although the predicted structure was ordered, the synthesized product was more consistent with the known disordered ilmenite-type parent phase at the same composition. The same pattern has emerged in generative-model-driven discovery. In MatterGen 41 , the experimentally synthesized product was not the predicted ordered phase but its disordered parent, subsequently identified as a known phase differing only slightly in site occupancy from previously reported structures 17 . These cases are unlikely to be isolated failures. Rather, they point to a structural gap in how computational predictions are interpreted. Ordered and disordered phases are often not unrelated alternatives, but members of the same crystallographic lineage 2 . This connection arises because atomic ordering directly governs crystal symmetry: a disordered phase, in which no specific arrangement of species over atomic sites is enforced, preserves the full symmetry of the underlying lattice, whereas the onset of ordering breaks that symmetry and produces a lower-symmetry structure. These symmetry reductions are not arbitrary but are constrained by group-subgroup relations in crystallography 2 ; 12 ; 9 , governing the ordered structures that can descend from a given disordered parent. Multiple ordered structures can descend from the same parent through distinct symmetry-breaking pathways, forming a family of ordered siblings. When these relations are ignored, a structure can then be erroneously counted as a new compound even though it already occupies a position within a known order-disorder family. Such relations are rarely available in a systematic, high-throughput form, and most reported examples have been uncovered only through detailed manual analysis of a small number of predicted structures subjected to experimental validation 4 ; 21 ; 17 . In principle, one could attempt exhaustive mapping by enumerating all symmetry-inequivalent ordered configurations of known disordered phases, for example using methods such as POCC 38 , and then matching a query ordered structure against the resulting lookup space. In practice, however, extending such enumeration across the full set of known disordered compounds is computationally prohibitive and unsuitable for large-scale analysis. More fundamentally, this still does not provide a general framework for answering: (i) for a given ordered structure, what disordered parents it may derive from, (ii) what ordered siblings share the same parents, and, most importantly, (iii) whether its apparent novelty reflects a genuinely new family or merely a new member within an existing one. To address this gap, we develop a symmetry-based framework that organizes ordered and disordered phases through group-subgroup transitions in space-group hierarchy: order-(dis)order family trees . In this view, a disordered parent is not only a possible precursor or competing interpretation of a predicted ordered phase, but also the root of a broader family tree whose branches include symmetry-lowered ordered descendants and related sibling structures. Group-subgroup transitions provide the natural language for navigating these trees, tracing how structural order emerges, splits, and reconnects across different levels of symmetry. This family-tree perspective changes how computational discovery should be interpreted. Rather than treating each predicted structure as an isolated point, we view it as an element embedded in a manifold of related ordered and disordered phases. What is discovered computationally is therefore often not a standalone structure, but

Read the complete text