Geometry, Not Calorimetry, Drives the Radio/Infrared/ γ \gamma -ray Correlation

T. A. Porter, I. V. Moskalenko, G. Jóhannesson · 2026

Read Geometry, Not Calorimetry, Drives the Radio/Infrared/ γ \gamma -ray Correlation by T. A. Porter, I. V. Moskalenko, G. Jóhannesson (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-21224.txt.

Introduction

Troy Porter, Igor Moskalenko, and Gudlaugur Johannesson ask whether the radio-infrared-gamma-ray link in star-forming galaxies reflects geometry rather than local cosmic-ray trapping. Synthetic views from 3D Milky Way models show a tight, near-linear correlation emerging from line-of-sight integration through the structured disc, even with no local calorimetry. The pattern survives moderate tilt but breaks edge-on. That makes scatter in the relation a diagnostic of galactic structure and cosmic-ray escape.

Catalog record

CREATORT. A. Porter, I. V. Moskalenko, G. Jóhannesson
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54965
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21224

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Geometry, Not Calorimetry, Drives the Radio/Infrared/ γ \gamma -ray Correlation T. A. Porter, I. V. Moskalenko, G. Jóhannesson Abstract We investigate whether the observed radio-infrared- γ \gamma -ray correlation in star-forming galaxies is a geometric effect rather than a signature of local cosmic-ray (CR) calorimetry. Using the GALPROP framework, we generate synthetic observations for external viewers from a grid of 3D Milky Way models with varied CR source, gas, interstellar radiation, and magnetic field distributions, all normalised to reproduce local CR data. We find that a tight, quasi-linear correlation arises naturally from line-of-sight integration through the extended, radially-structured disc, even when local calorimetry is absent. The correlation’s properties depend strongly on viewing geometry, preserving its form under moderate inclination but breaking down in edge-on views where galactic components are stratified. We conclude that the correlation is primarily an emergent property of geometric projection, not local physics. This implies that its scatter is likely not random noise but a diagnostic of underlying galactic structure and viewing angle. I Introduction The tight, linear correlation between a galaxy’s infrared (IR) and radio continuum (RC) luminosities is one of the most robust and ubiquitous scaling relations in extragalactic astronomy. Established over three decades ago ( de Jong et al. 1985 ; Helou et al. 1985 ) , this relation holds with remarkable consistency across several orders of magnitude in luminosity, spanning quiescent spirals, irregulars, and intense starburst galaxies ( Condon 1992 ; Yun et al. 2001 ) . The canonical explanation invokes a shared energetic origin in massive star formation: ultraviolet radiation from young, hot stars is absorbed by interstellar dust and re-radiated in the IR, while the same stellar population ends in core-collapse supernovae that accelerate the cosmic-ray (CR) electrons responsible for synchrotron emission in the galaxy’s magnetic fields. The remarkable tightness of the RC-IR correlation, however, belies the complexity of the underlying physics. The classic “electron calorimeter” model posits that in optically thick starburst environments, CR electrons lose all their energy via synchrotron and inverse Compton (IC) radiation before they can escape, naturally tying their total emission to the star formation rate (SFR) ( Voelk 1989 ) . Yet, the correlation persists even in low-density, CR-transparent galaxies where electrons are expected to escape, suggesting that a simple calorimetric argument is insufficient. This has led to the proposal of conspiracy-like scenarios where various factors, including CR injection and transport, magnetic field amplification, and gas density, are coupled in a self-regulating manner to maintain the correlation across diverse galactic environments ( Lacki et al. 2010 ; Crocker et al. 2021 , e.g.,) . High-energy \gamma -ray observations provide an additional and independent probe of these processes. The expectation of detectable \gamma -ray flux from extragalactic star-forming regions ( Voelk et al. 1989 , e.g.,) was first confirmed by EGRET’s detection of the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) ( Sreekumar et al. 1992 ) . However, the instrument’s limited sensitivity yielded only upper limits for more distant starbursts like NGC 253 and M82, as well as M31 ( Blom et al. 1999 ) . The greatly enhanced sensitivity of the Fermi Large Area Telescope ( Fermi -LAT) expanded the sample of detected star-forming galaxies sufficiently to permit statistical studies for the first time. Analysis of Fermi -LAT data for a sample of 64 galaxies, selected on the basis of their molecular gas content along with the \gamma -ray detected Local Group members, demonstrated a quasi-linear scaling between the \gamma -ray luminosity and the SFR ( Ackermann et al. 2012 ) . The extension to include \gamma -rays is significant because it traces both CR electrons and, uniquely, the dominant CR nuclei population via hadronic interactions. The radio-IR- \gamma -ray correlation therefore links the total CR energy budget to the multi-wavelength properties of the host galaxy. The study of nearby galaxies, whose large angular sizes permit resolved multi-wavelength analysis, allows the focus to shift from galaxy-integrated properties to sub-galactic scales. In these systems, such as the M31, M33, and the Magellanic Clouds, the RC-IR correlation has been shown to persist down to scales of \sim 100 pc, albeit with increased scatter and local variations in the correlation slope ( Murphy 2006 ; Hughes et al. 2006 ; Tabatabaei et al. 2013 ) . The inclusion of \gamma -rays, however, introduces a fundamental scale ambiguity. While a few key systems, the LMC, SMC, and M31, are spatially resolved in \gamma -rays the angular resolution is significantly poorer than in the radio and IR bands, probing physical scales closer to a kiloparsec than 100 pc. Beyond these few cases, the broader sample of star-forming galaxies remains unresolved in \gamma -rays. This leaves a critical gap in our understanding: the well-established local ( \sim 100 pc) RC-IR correlation exists in a regime where the \gamma -ray emission is either poorly resolved or completely unresolved. It is therefore unclear whether the local RC-IR correlation reflects a direct physical coupling (i.e., calorimetry) that would extend to \gamma -rays if we had sufficient resolution, or if it is simply a higher-resolution manifestation of the same geometric projection effects that govern the global scaling relations. The distinction is critical, as the answer determines whether these emissions can be used as reliable, local tracers of star formation or are instead smoothed by CR propagation over kiloparsec scales. In this paper, we argue that geometry, not local calorimetry, is the principal driver of the apparent universality of the radio-IR- \gamma -ray correlation on sub-galactic scales. We hypothesise that the observed tight scaling is largely a consequence of line-of-sight (LOS) integration through extended, but fundamentally correlated, large-scale distributions of CRs and their interstellar medium (ISM) target densities (gas, radiation, and magnetic fields). To test this, we employ the GalProp CR propagation framework ( Porter et al. 2022 ) to construct a suite of three-dimensional (3D), physically-motivated models of the Milky Way (MW). By systematically varying the spatial distributions of CR sources, interstellar gas, radiation fields, and magnetic field configurations, we self-consistently compute the resulting synchrotron, IR, and \gamma -ray emission. We then generate synthetic, resolved maps as seen from a range of observer locations, distances, and viewing inclinations. This approach allows us to disentangle the effects of intrinsic physical coupling from those of observational geometry, revealing how the act of observation itself can forge tight correlations from spatially complex and imperfectly coupled components. Our work underscores the need to account for geometric projection effects when interpreting these multi-wavelength correlations, with direct implications for their use as star formation tracers and as probes of CR physics in the MW and beyond. II GALPROP Framework The GALPROP framework is a widely used, publicly available numerical tool for modeling Galactic CR transport and the associated diffuse non-thermal emission. The central idea in GalProp is that many different observables trace the same underlying CR populations and Galactic environment, and should therefore be modelled together. These include direct measurements of CR nuclei, \bar{p} , and e^{\pm} , as well as diffuse \gamma -ray emission and synchrotron radiation. Its range of physical validity extends from sub-keV – PeV energies for particles and from 10^{-6} eV ( \mu eV) – PeV for photons. The aim is to build models that are as realistic as

Read the complete text