Post-AGI Economies: Autonomy and the First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics
Elija Perrier · 2026
Read Post-AGI Economies: Autonomy and the First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics by Elija Perrier (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-21216.txt.
Introduction
Elija Perrier argues that the First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics leans on a sharp split between self-directed welfare subjects and mere tools, a split artificial intelligence strains. In post-AGI economies, systems may serve as tools, delegates, market players, shapers of choice, or possible welfare subjects. With a minimal market model that scores welfare by autonomy, tracks delegation, and checks claims, he derives when a fully autonomy-aware competitive equilibrium is itself autonomy-efficient. The classic theorem returns at low autonomy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Elija Perrier |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49688 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21216
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Post-AGI Economies: Autonomy and the First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics Elija Perrier Abstract The First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics assumes that welfare-bearing agents are autonomous and implicitly relies on a binary distinction between autonomy and instrumentality. Welfare subjects are those who have autonomy and therefore the capacity to choose and enter into utility comparisons, while everything else does not. In post-AGI economies this presupposition becomes nontrivial because artificial systems may exhibit varying degrees of autonomy, functioning as tools, delegates, strategic market actors, manipulators of choice environments, or possible welfare subjects. We argue that the theorem ought to be subject to an autonomy qualification where the impact of these changes in autonomy assumptions is incorporated. Using a minimal general-equilibrium model with autonomy-conditioned welfare, welfare-status assignment, delegation accounting, and verification institutions, we set out conditions for which autonomy-complete competitive equilibrium is autonomy-Pareto efficient. The classical theorem is recovered as the low-autonomy limit. 1 Introduction The First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics ( FWT ) states that, in a complete-markets economy with locally nonsatiated agents, every competitive equilibrium is Pareto efficient [ 8 , 22 , 43 , 64 ] . The result is significant because it provides a minimal justification for decentralized allocation: under the right conditions, the price system aligns individual choices with socially beneficial outcomes which cannot, in principle, be improved upon without making some agent worse off. This conclusion depends on a strong set of assumptions. Markets must be complete, relevant attributes of goods must be priced or assigned, agents must act as price-takers with well-defined preferences, and interactions must not generate unpriced external effects [ 27 , 59 , 6 ] . The theorem’s welfare content further depends on background assumptions about who counts as a welfare-bearing agent, what the commodity space includes, and which externalities or informational failures have been priced or assigned. It presumes a simple structure of agency: the set of welfare-bearing agents is fixed, their preferences are treated as exogenous, and non-human systems enter only as instruments rather than as entities whose actions or status affect welfare directly. In particular, it is based upon a binary, and usually unspoken, distinction between autonomous agents (e.g. consumers) whose welfare is calculable and non-autonomous instruments which are excluded from welfare calculations. Welfare is based upon utility, which depends on agent preferences and therefore on decision-making attributed to autonomous agents. AGI challenges these background assumptions by introducing artificial systems with varying degrees of economic autonomy [ 45 , 28 ] , rather than preserving a clean division between autonomous agents and passive instruments. Some systems remain instrumental, i.e. tools . Others act as delegates for human principals [ 31 , 29 ] , as strategic or institutional actors that shape market conditions [ 28 ] , or as manipulators of choice environments [ 69 , 60 ] (e.g. language model agents performing long-horizon autonomous planning [ 48 , 68 , 66 , 67 ] ). At the far end of the autonomy scale, AGI agents may even qualify as candidate welfare subjects [ 14 , 18 , 41 , 12 ] . We argue that increasing artificial autonomy changes the binary nature of autonomy—and thus welfare assignment—upon which the FWT rests [ 22 , 43 , 54 ] , along with the conditions under which equilibrium has welfare meaning. Classical welfare economics operates in a low-complexity autonomy regime: humans choose, tools do not, preferences are attributed to humans, and markets allocate commodities [ 22 , 43 ] . Our thesis is that the classical FWT is the low-autonomy special case of an autonomy-qualified theorem in which welfare-status [ 14 , 41 , 12 ] , delegation [ 31 , 29 ] , autonomy-relevant rights [ 54 ] , manipulation channels [ 69 , 60 ] , and verification institutions [ 7 , 13 ] are made explicit. The degree of autonomy of AI systems has implications for the FWT and measures of welfare in post-AGI economies. Tool-like AI preserves the classical treatment of non-human systems as production inputs. Delegated AI separates the chooser from the welfare subject. Strategic or institutional AI systems raise externality, manipulation, verification, price-taking, provenance, and liability issues. Candidate artificial welfare subjects may force us to accord an explicit welfare-status assignment to AI systems. Autonomy therefore enters in two ways: as an object of preference and as a condition of preference formation and delegation . 1.1 Contribution and roadmap To explore these issues, we introduce a minimal general-equilibrium model with five autonomy-specific objects: (1) a welfare-status assignment \sigma , (2) autonomy-conditioned welfare W_{i}(x_{i},r_{i},s) , (3) delegation divergence D(d) , (4) autonomy-complete competitive equilibrium, and (5) autonomy externality. The result is an Autonomy-Qualified First Welfare Theorem : every autonomy-complete competitive equilibrium is autonomy-Pareto efficient under certain autonomy-related domain conditions. We argue that once the autonomy margins that AGI makes salient are priced, assigned, governed, or held fixed, the familiar budget-cost proof goes through on the augmented commodity space. Our result is deliberately narrower than a general theory of AGI welfare. We do not claim that any current AI system is conscious or welfare-bearing. Rather, we include artificial welfare subjects as an assignable status in the model - a topic of increasing interest and debate in the literature [ 14 , 41 , 53 , 18 , 26 , 23 , 65 , 50 , 10 ] . Nor do we claim that autonomy is the unique possible primitive for AGI welfare economics. Instead, our claim is that autonomy is an organising primitive that unifies the particular welfare-status, delegation, manipulation, verification, and rights conditions relevant to welfare economics captured by the FWT in an AGI-based economy. 2 Related Work 2.1 Autonomy assumptions The First Welfare Theorem is not usually stated as a theorem about autonomy. In the Arrow–Debreu framework, it says that if agents take prices as given, maximise locally nonsatiated preferences over complete budget sets, and all welfare-relevant commodities and external effects are priced or assigned, then competitive equilibrium is Pareto efficient [ 8 , 22 , 43 , 64 ] . But these familiar assumptions also encode a simple autonomy structure: the welfare-bearing agents are fixed, preferences are treated as exogenous, the decision-maker is the welfare subject, and non-human systems enter instrumentally as commodities, technologies, or firms rather than as delegates or possible welfare subjects. We call these autonomy assumptions . AGI problematises these autonomy assumptions by introducing gradated autonomy . Existing AGI literature commonly treats autonomy as a matter of degree rather than a binary property [ 45 ] . Recent agent-design work sharpens this by treating an agent’s autonomy level as a design decision separable from capability and deployment environment [ 24 ] . Autonomy is also the focus of recent AI-economics work that studies economies in which artificial systems act in ways that imply autonomy: as agents, inputs, delegates, market-design intermediaries, or sources of verification and institutional stress [ 3 , 4 , 37 , 36 , 38 , 63 , 15 , 1 , 28 , 58 , 33 ] . Recent NBER work makes the point explicitly: AI agents may shape markets, organizations, and institutions, while AI-mediated transactions can lower preference-elicitation, contract-enforcement, and identity-verification costs without guaranteeing welfare-improving