Light, heavy, primordial: exploring the diversity of black hole seeding and growth mechanisms in the JWST era
Pratika Dayal · 2026
Read Light, heavy, primordial: exploring the diversity of black hole seeding and growth mechanisms in the JWST era by Pratika Dayal (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-20966.txt.
Introduction
Dayal compares two stories for massive black holes the James Webb Space Telescope finds in the first billion years. Many are overweight for their hosts and poor in metals. One story grows light or heavy astrophysical seeds through mergers and accretion, in the DELPHI model. The other grows primordial black holes by accretion alone in the PHANES model. Only Eddington-limited growth on light seeds is ruled out. Primordial holes and Eddington-limited heavy seeds both match the masses and tiny metallicities seen.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pratika Dayal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74054 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.20966
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Light, heavy, primordial: exploring the diversity of black hole seeding and growth mechanisms in the JWST era Pratika Dayal Abstract The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has revealed a puzzling population of massive black holes in the first billion years, many of which are over-massive compared to their hosts (obese black holes), and reside in metal-poor hosts, posing a challenge for theoretical models at these early epochs. In this work, we compare the observational properties of astrophysically-seeded black holes using the delphi semi-analytic model and cosmologically-seeded primordial black holes (PBHs) using the phanes analytic model. We explore the growth of light ( ∼ 100 M ⊙ \sim 100\mathrm{M}_{\odot} ) and heavy ( ∼ 10 3 − 5 M ⊙ \sim 10^{3-5}\mathrm{M}_{\odot} ) seeds through mergers and accretion (both Eddington-limited and at super-Eddington rates) in the astrophysical scenario; PBHs (seeded between 10 0.5 − 6 M ⊙ 10^{0.5-6}\mathrm{M}_{\odot} ) only grow through accretion at sub-Eddington rates. Comparing to observables at z ∼ 5 − 10 z\sim 5-10 , the only model that can be ruled out is the one where we allow Eddington-limited accretion onto light seeds, given their inability of growing to the massive masses observed at these early epochs. The observed high values of the black hole mass-stellar mass relation ( 0.3 − 1 0.3-1 ) can be reproduced by both PBHs and heavy seeds accreting at super-Eddington rates. However, only the PBH and Eddington-limited heavy seeding models can simultaneously reproduce the observed black hole masses ( M B H \mathrm{M}_{BH} ), stellar masses ( M ∗ M_{*} ), and extremely low host metallicities ( Z ≤ 0.01 Z ⊙ Z\leq 0.01\mathrm{Z}_{\odot} ) inferred at z ∼ 7 − 10 z\sim 7-10 . Crucially, we find PBHs show decrease in the black hole mass-stellar mass ratio with increasing halo mass at all redshifts, contrary to any astrophysical black hole model, in addition to inhabiting lower-mass halos. Quantitatively, selecting systems at z ∼ 7 z\sim 7 with M B H / M ∗ > 0.1 \mathrm{M}_{BH}/M_{*}>0.1 and bolometric luminosities ∼ 10 44 − 46 e r g s − 1 \sim 10^{44-46}\mathrm{e}rg\penalty\ s^{-1} that show a negative black hole to stellar mass ratio and reside in 10 9 − 11 M ⊙ 10^{9-11}\mathrm{M}_{\odot} halos offer a promising clustering-based discriminant of PBH seeding models. keywords Galaxies: high-redshift – quasars: supermassive black holes – cosmology: theory – cosmology: early Universe – Black hole physics 1 Introduction The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has been revolutionary in shedding light on the emergence of black holes in the first billion years of the Universe. These incredible observations have given rise to a number of puzzles, including: (i) the existence of black holes as massive as 10^{8}\mathrm{M}_{\odot} within the first billion years, at redshifts z\sim 8-10 ( Kokorev et al. 2023 ; Bogdán et al. 2024 ; Kovács et al. 2024 ) ; (ii) black holes that are inferred to be over-massive compared to the stellar masses of their hosts, with black hole to stellar mass ratios at high as 30-100\% at z\sim 5-10 ( Übler et al. 2023 ; Kokorev et al. 2023 ; Harikane et al. 2023 ; Kovács et al. 2024 ; Bogdán et al. 2024 ; Maiolino et al. 2024 ; Kocevski et al. 2025 ; Juodžbalis et al. 2025a ; Napolitano et al. 2025 ) ; (iii) black holes hosted in galaxies that are inferred to be metal poor with metallicity values Z\lower 2.15277pt\hbox{$\;\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\sim}\limits^{<}}\;$}0.1-0.01\mathrm{Z}_{\odot} ( Maiolino et al. 2025a ; Tripodi et al. 2025 ) ; and (iv) the X-ray weakness of such early black holes ( Yue et al. 2024 ; Ananna et al. 2024 ; Maiolino et al. 2025b ; Tortosa et al. 2026 ; Comastri et al. 2026 ; Mazzolari et al. 2026 ) . Observationally a number of caveats remain which concern the inferred black hole masses, bolometric luminosities and stellar masses. For example, black hole masses are typically inferred by applying local calibrations to single-epoch measurements of emission lines at high-redshifts. A number of works note that the high velocities indicated by Balmer line broadening could arise due to outflows ( Baggen et al. 2024 ; Matthee et al. 2024 ) and single-epoch local calibrators could over-estimate black hole masses by as much as an order of magnitude ( Lupi et al. 2024 ; King 2024 ) . On the other hand, dynamical mass measurements yield black hole masses very similar to those inferred from virial estimates, although as of now, these are limited to one lensed black hole at z=7.04 ( Juodžbalis et al. 2025b ) . Further black hole bolometric luminosities are typically inferred from the H {\alpha} luminosity after applying dust corrections. This has been a particularly challenging issue for the class of black holes called “little red dots” that are selected on the basis of their “V-shaped” spectral energy distribution (blue in the ultraviolet and red in the optical), and compact morphology ( Kocevski et al. 2023 ; Greene et al. 2024 ; Setton et al. 2025 ) . Spectroscopy of two such little red dots at redshifts of z=3.1 and 4.46 have been used to infer bolometric luminosities that are lower by a factor of ten compared to those from local relations ( Greene et al. 2026 ) . The stellar mass, too, remains a matter of the debate, especially so in systems that host black holes. Stellar masses are inferred by fitting spectral energy distributions (SEDs) to photometry - assumptions on the initial mass function (IMF), burstiness, and the relative contribution from the black hole and stellar components all play a role in the final inferred stellar mass. For example, changing the slope of the IMF alone is sufficient to change the inferred stellar mass by an order of magnitude ( Wang et al. 2024 , e.g.) . Further confusing the picture, clustering estimates of 5 faint broad line H {\alpha} emitters have been used to infer host stellar masses that are about 40 times lower than those inferred from galaxy-only SED fits ( Matthee et al. 2025 ) . With such observational caveats in mind, if one proceeds to take the observations at face value, the prevalence of massive and “obese” early black holes (with respect to the host stellar masses) pose a crucial challenge to theoretical models. A number of theoretical approaches have been involved to explain such observations which range from: (i) episodic super-Eddington accretion on to light- or heavy-seeds ( Schneider et al. 2023 ; Maiolino et al. 2024 ; Volonteri et al. 2025 ; Hu et al. 2025 ) although other works seem to rule out super-Eddington accretion as a solution, at least for little red dots ( Sacchi and Bogdán 2025 ) ; (ii) extremely efficient accretion- and merger-driven growth of intermediate-to-heavy seeds ( Prole et al. 2024 ; Cáceres-Burgos et al. 2026 ) ; (iii) such systems being the initial phases in the growth of heavy seeds ( Natarajan et al. 2024 ; Pacucci et al. 2026 ) ; (iv) selection biases resulting in observations preferentially selecting systems where the black hole outshines the host ( Volonteri et al. 2023