Quantum–HPC Software Stacks and the openQSE Reference Architecture: A Survey

Amir Shehata, Brian Austin, Tom Beck, Lukas Burgholzer, Alex Chernoguzov, Spencer Churchill, Andrea Delgado, Yasuko Eckert, Jeffery Heckey, Kevin Kissell, Katherine Klymko, Josh Moles, Thomas Naughton, Lee James O’Riordan, Christian Ortiz Pauyac, Guen Prawiroatmodjo, Ermal Rrapaj, Jiri Schindler, Laura Schulz, Sebastian Stern, Tyler Takeshita, Miwako Tsuji, Aleksander Wennersteen, Travis Humble, Martin Schulz · 2026

Read Quantum–HPC Software Stacks and the openQSE Reference Architecture: A Survey by Amir Shehata, Brian Austin, Tom Beck, Lukas Burgholzer, Alex Chernoguzov, Spencer Churchill, Andrea Delgado, Yasuko Eckert, Jeffery Heckey, Kevin Kissell, Katherine Klymko, Josh Moles, Thomas Naughton, Lee James O’Riordan, Christian Ortiz Pauyac, Guen Prawiroatmodjo, Ermal Rrapaj, Jiri Schindler, Laura Schulz, Sebastian Stern, Tyler Takeshita, Miwako Tsuji, Aleksander Wennersteen, Travis Humble, Martin Schulz (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-20912.txt.

Introduction

Shehata and colleagues survey nine quantum-HPC software stacks now in production use. Today each stack stands alone, with no shared links across its runtime, resource, and execution layers. From patterns the survey finds, the team puts forward openQSE, a reference design whose layer lines let varied tools work together. It aims to run both noisy machines of today and fault-tolerant machines of the future, with no change to the top layers that apps use.

Catalog record

CREATORAmir Shehata, Brian Austin, Tom Beck, Lukas Burgholzer, Alex Chernoguzov, Spencer Churchill, Andrea Delgado, Yasuko Eckert, Jeffery Heckey, Kevin Kissell, Katherine Klymko, Josh Moles, Thomas Naughton, Lee James O’Riordan, Christian Ortiz Pauyac, Guen Prawiroatmodjo, Ermal Rrapaj, Jiri Schindler, Laura Schulz, Sebastian Stern, Tyler Takeshita, Miwako Tsuji, Aleksander Wennersteen, Travis Humble, Martin Schulz
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58328
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.20912

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum–HPC Software Stacks and the openQSE Reference Architecture: A Survey Amir Shehata, Brian Austin, Tom Beck, Lukas Burgholzer, Alex Chernoguzov, Spencer Churchill, Andrea Delgado, Yasuko Eckert, Jeffery Heckey, Kevin Kissell, Katherine Klymko, Josh Moles, Thomas Naughton, Lee James O’Riordan, Christian Ortiz Pauyac, Guen Prawiroatmodjo, Ermal Rrapaj, Jiri Schindler, Laura Schulz, Sebastian Stern, Tyler Takeshita, Miwako Tsuji, Aleksander Wennersteen, Travis Humble, Martin Schulz Abstract Quantum resources are increasingly integrated into HPC ( HPC ) and cloud environments, but QHPC ( QHPC ) software stacks remain isolated, often proprietary, full-stack solutions lacking common interfaces across runtime, resource management, orchestration, and execution layers. This paper analyzes nine production QHPC stacks and identifies common design patterns and emerging requirements, covering deployment models, application interaction patterns, SDK support, and readiness for fault-tolerant operation. The survey exposes consistent needs in runtime abstraction, resource management, interconnect semantics, and observability. Based on these findings, we propose the openQSE ( openQSE ) reference architecture as a first step toward unifying the state-of-the-practice. openQSE defines a set of layer boundaries that allow different implementations to interoperate while preserving deployment flexibility, and is structured to support both current NISQ ( NISQ ) workloads and future FTQC ( FTQC ) systems without changes to upper-layer application interfaces. ATD application time domain AWS Amazon Web Services DTD deterministic timing domain FTEE fault-tolerant execution engine FTQC fault-tolerant quantum computing GRES generic resource HAPI hardware-provider API HECC hierarchical error correction code HPC high-performance computing IR intermediate representation ISA instruction set architecture JWT JSON web tokens LCL logical control layer MLIR multi-level intermediate representation MQT Munich Quantum Toolkit NISQ noisy intermediate-scale quantum openQSE open quantum-HPC software ecosystem PBS portable batch system PCS parallel computing service PTD physical timing domain QCSC Quantum-Centric Supercomputing QDK quantum development kit QDMI quantum device management interface QEC quantum error correction QHPC quantum high-performance computing QIR quantum intermediate representation QoS quality of service QPU quantum processing unit QRI quantum runtime interface QRMI quantum resource management interface QTIL queue utility RMS resource management system RTD real-time domain Slurm simple Linux utility for resource management SPANK Slurm plug-in architecture for node and job kontrol SQC supercomputer quantum computer computation VQE variational quantum eigensolver 1 Overview Quantum computers do not operate in isolation. Practical quantum execution depends on classical software and hardware for compilation, orchestration, control, scheduling, data movement, and error-management functions. As a result, integrating quantum resources into HPC environments is an end-to-end systems problem, not only a device-access problem. HPC centers are already deploying and evaluating these systems across multiple providers and deployment models [ 61 , 48 , 7 , 38 ] . While large strides have been made in this area over the last few years, it has led to a situation where this integration currently occurs through many independent, fragmented software paths. Many interfaces remain provider-specific, assumptions vary between cloud and on-premises environments, and sites often rebuild similar integration logic for job submission, resource description, runtime interaction, and security handling. This fragmentation increases maintenance cost, slows comparative evaluations, and weakens portability for applications and operations teams. In this paper we review the current state-of-the-practice in this area, analyzing the most prominent examples of QHPC software stacks. We compare their architectures and design decisions, review key interfaces and user accesss modes, and characterize their current state. Based on that, we gather a comprehensive picture of the current QHPC approaches and offer a first-of-a-kind mapping into a single blueprint, which can then be used to drive a common community architecture. This forms the input for the openQSE initiative recently formed by major contributors, including HPC centers, vendors, and users of QHPC systems. Within that context, this paper analyzes nine representative QHPC stacks, developed by industry and research. They span all major deployment options, i.e., managed cloud services, scheduler-centric datacenter integration, and brokered-offload designs. In particular, we include the QHPC stacks from AWS, IBM, IonQ, JHPC-Quantum, MQSS, Pasqal, Quantinuum, Quantum Brilliance, and Xanadu, and compare them based on their key properties. We explore convergence points and areas for future development in runtime boundaries, resource management, and interconnect/control assumptions. We then form a common reference architecture that is powerful enough to map all identified properties and mechanisms into a single architecture blueprint. In summary, our paper makes three main contributions: • Quantum-HPC Stack Analysis : We review the state-of-the-practice in QHPC software stacks by examining nine widely used representative frameworks. We identify common architectural patterns and important differences across current approaches and synthesize them into an interface convergence matrix ( Table 1 ) that maps where the field is converging and where it is not. • Quantum-HPC Requirements Framework : We introduce a requirements framework that spans deployment environments, hardware modalities, application patterns, and quantum-computing eras, providing a structured design space to consider current and future QHPC software systems. • openQSE Reference Architecture : We propose the community-driven openQSE architecture as a vendor-neutral layered reference architecture that provides a holistic view of the integrated QHPC system without assigning ownership of specific layers to vendors or HPC centers. It preserves implementation flexibility, while stabilizing interfaces for portable, interoperable, and future-ready integration. 2 Problem Statement Quantum computers are expected to become useful in hybrid scientific workflows for problem classes, such as Hamiltonian simulation, optimization, and quantum machine learning, with broader application areas including electronic structure and related chemistry, materials, and data-analysis workloads [ 20 , 34 ] . In order for those workflows to become practical for scientists and facilities, though, quantum computers must be integrated with HPC resources in an intelligent and efficient manner. This integration will avoid repeatedly adapting to different provider-specific interfaces, runtime assumptions, and deployment models. Furthermore, it will remove operational overhead for data centers that need to compare evolving quantum platforms on a common basis and for scientists who need to evaluate multiple technologies. Many groups and projects are working on this kind of integration, creating a broad field of individually grown solutions. As we mature the field, it will be critical to track the state-of-the-practice of current approaches, to gather differences and similarities, and to track the specific needs and requirements that drove individual design decisions. For such a state-of-the-practice survey, we must first establish a needed framework to understand the fundamentally different scaling models and allocation semantics that drive the use of quantum resources. HPC capacity scales by adding comparatively modular and independently scalable resources such as racks, nodes, cores, memory, and GPUs, which can be allocated incrementally or fractionally to users. By contrast, the capacity of QPU scales through the addition and improvement of qubits, which remain scarce and tightly coupled. They cannot be scheduled efficiently as fractional resources. Quantum information cannot be copied, meaning that they also cannot be pre-empively scheduled or checkpointed. These distinctions are architecturally significant, as they shape scheduling, fairness, utilization, and the design of hybrid workflows. 3 Classification Axes Any practical QHPC architecture must, therefore, account for both sides of the scaling asymmetry as well as handle a broad range of requirements in order to use classical and quantum resources efficiently. To enable a fair comparison in our analysis of the state-of-the-practice, we group requirements and solutions along four distinct axes of classification: where the system is deployed, which quantum-hardware modality is being

Read the complete text