Learning AI Without a STEM Background: Mixed-Methods Evidence from a Diverse, Mixed-Cohort AIED Program
Valentina Kuskova, Dmitry Zaytsev, Richard Patrick Johnson · 2026
Read Learning AI Without a STEM Background: Mixed-Methods Evidence from a Diverse, Mixed-Cohort AIED Program by Valentina Kuskova, Dmitry Zaytsev, Richard Patrick Johnson (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-20870.txt.
Introduction
Kuskova, Zaytsev, and Johnson present an NSF-funded AI education model that mixes non-STEM undergraduates and adult learners in one class. It centers on ethics, socio-technical judgment, and hands-on AI literacy rather than technical skill alone. Drawing on course surveys, open-ended reflections, and educator reports, they examine learners' agency, confidence with AI concepts, and critical engagement with ethical tradeoffs. Results show big gains in confidence and perceived relevance of AI, with a steady emphasis on responsibility, judgment, and reasoning in context over technical mastery.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Valentina Kuskova, Dmitry Zaytsev, Richard Patrick Johnson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32067 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.20870
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Learning AI Without a STEM Background: Mixed-Methods Evidence from a Diverse, Mixed-Cohort AIED Program Valentina Kuskova, Dmitry Zaytsev, Richard Patrick Johnson Abstract Despite growing interest in AI education, most AIED initiatives remain narrowly targeted toward STEM-prepared students, limiting participation by non-STEM learners and adults seeking to engage with AI in public-interest, policy, or workforce contexts. This paper presents and evaluates an NSF-funded, innovative mixed-cohort AI education model that intentionally integrates non-STEM undergraduates and adult learners into a shared learning environment centered on ethical reasoning, socio-technical judgment, and applied AI literacy rather than technical proficiency alone. Drawing on mixed-methods data from course surveys, open-ended reflections, and educator reports, we examine learners’ academic agency, confidence navigating AI concepts, critical engagement with ethical tradeoffs, and perceived expansion of postsecondary and career trajectories. Quantitative results indicate significant gains in confidence and perceived relevance of AI across cohorts’ participants, while qualitative analyses reveal a consistent emphasis on responsibility, judgment, and contextual reasoning over technical mastery. Instructors and near-peer mentors corroborated high levels of engagement and productive challenge, particularly in dialogic and scenario-based learning activities. Our findings suggest that human-centered instructional supports, such as ethical scaffolding, mentorship, and structured discussion, are essential components of equitable AI education, especially in heterogeneous and non-traditional learner populations. We argue that ethical judgment should be treated as a core learning outcome in AIED alongside AI literacy, and we offer design implications for expanding access to AI education in policy-relevant and workforce-adjacent contexts. 1 Introduction: The Access Problem in AI Education Artificial intelligence is increasingly embedded across work, governance, and everyday life, reshaping how decisions are made, resources are allocated, and opportunities are distributed [ 9 ] . As a result, AI literacy is now widely recognized not merely as a technical skill, but as a form of civic, professional, and ethical competence [ 21 ] . Yet access to AI education remains uneven [ 1 ] . Most formal AI learning opportunities are designed for STEM-prepared students [ 25 ] , rely heavily on coding proficiency [ 2 ] , or target early-career learners [ 29 ] , systematically excluding non-STEM students and adults seeking to engage with AI in policy, public-interest, or workforce contexts. These access barriers have consequences beyond pedagogy. Restricting AI education to technically trained populations reinforces existing inequities [ 19 ] in technological participation and decision-making. Individuals without accessible AI education are less equipped to critically evaluate automated systems [ 11 ] , participate in AI-mediated organizational processes [ 12 ] , or adapt to labor markets increasingly shaped by data-driven tools [ 16 ] . For adult learners embedded in professional roles [ 18 ] , the absence of rigorous, accessible AI education pathways limits opportunities for upskilling, mobility, and ethical leadership. Prevailing AI education models often intensify these challenges. Coding-centric curricula [ 20 ] could prioritize implementation over judgment, degree-bound programs impose time and financial constraints [ 27 ] , and youth-focused initiatives may overlook the learning needs of experienced professionals [ 30 ] . While valuable in their own right, these approaches leave unresolved how AI education might expand access without sacrificing rigor, ethical depth, or real-world relevance. This paper addresses that gap by examining a mixed-cohort AI education model that brings together non-STEM undergraduates and adult learners in a shared learning environment. The study is guided by two research questions: (1) How can AI education be designed to expand access while maintaining rigor? and (2) What learning outcomes emerge in mixed-cohort, non-traditional AI classrooms? The program under study—referred to here as Data Crossings ---was supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF). 1 1 1 The full NSF project title is withheld for peer review to avoid author identification. Drawing on empirical evidence from this year-long program, we examine how learners develop academic agency, confidence engaging with AI concepts, and the capacity to reason about ethical and socio-technical tradeoffs. The paper makes three contributions. First, it introduces a mixed-cohort AIED design that integrates learners across disciplines, ages, and career stages. Second, it presents mixed-methods evidence from a sustained, evaluated program rather than a short-term intervention. Third, it reframes ethical judgment and academic agency, rather than technical mastery alone, as core outcomes of AI education, with implications for AIED research and policy-oriented program design. 2 Related Work AI Education and Participation Gaps. Research in AI education and computing education has consistently documented disparities in participation across gender [ 7 ] , socioeconomic status [ 1 ] , disciplinary background [ 35 ] , and educational stage [ 31 ] . While many initiatives aim to broaden participation, they often focus on pre-college pipelines [ 33 ] or undergraduate STEM majors [ 15 ] , leaving non-STEM students and adult learners underrepresented. These gaps are particularly pronounced in advanced or applied AI learning contexts [ 5 ] , where prerequisites and assumptions about prior knowledge function as de facto exclusion mechanisms. As AI systems increasingly influence public policy, healthcare, education, and civic life, these participation gaps raise concerns about who is equipped to understand, question, and govern AI technologies. AI Literacy vs. Technical Proficiency. A growing body of literature distinguishes between AI literacy and technical proficiency, arguing that meaningful engagement with AI does not require deep expertise in programming or model development [ 23 ] . AI literacy frameworks emphasize conceptual understanding [ 37 ] , critical interpretation of AI outputs [ 6 ] , awareness of limitations and biases [ 28 ] , and the ability to situate AI systems within social and organizational contexts [ 22 ] . However, many AI education programs continue to conflate literacy with technical skill acquisition, privileging coding fluency over interpretive and ethical capacities. This conflation disproportionately disadvantages learners whose goals involve policy analysis, management, communication, or domain-specific application rather than technical implementation. Adult Learning and Workforce-Adjacent AI Education. Adult learning research highlights that adults bring prior knowledge, professional identity, and goal-oriented motivations that differ substantially from traditional students [ 17 ] . Workforce-adjacent AI education programs have emerged in response to rapid technological change, yet many rely on self-paced online formats or narrowly defined upskilling modules [ 26 ] . These approaches often struggle with retention, depth of learning, and ethical engagement. Moreover, adult learners are rarely studied as participants in AI education research, particularly in environments that position them as co-learners rather than remedial or peripheral participants. Ethics, Responsibility, and Judgment in AIED. Ethical considerations are increasingly recognized as central to AI education, with scholars advocating for the integration of fairness, accountability, transparency, and social impact into AI curricula. However, ethical AI education is frequently treated as an add-on [ 13 ] : isolated modules or discussions appended to otherwise technical courses. Less attention has been paid to how ethical judgment develops through sustained practice, dialogue, and exposure to real-world tradeoffs, particularly among learners without technical backgrounds. Understanding ethics as a form of reasoning and judgment, rather than rule-following, remains an underexplored dimension of AIED. Mixed-Cohort and Peer-Learning Models: What’s Missing. Peer learning and cohort-based models are well established in STEM education and professional training [ 32 ] , with evidence that collaboration and social belonging support retention and learning. Existing mixed-cohort studies, however, primarily focus