Operational criterion for Wigner function negativity

Paolo Solinas, Beatrice Donelli, Stefano Gherardini · 2026

Read Operational criterion for Wigner function negativity by Paolo Solinas, Beatrice Donelli, Stefano Gherardini (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-20303.txt.

Introduction

Solinas, Donelli, and Gherardini give an operational test for Wigner function negativity in any state, using quantum non-demolition measurement. Their schemes measure the Wigner function directly and single out the coherent-state basis for judging negative regions. No coherent superpositions in that basis signals a positive Wigner function, a sufficient condition. It also proves necessary for Schrödinger-cat states. For higher-order cat states on a circle it holds for many densely packed states, though general necessity stays unproven.

Catalog record

CREATORPaolo Solinas, Beatrice Donelli, Stefano Gherardini
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56409
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.20303

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Operational criterion for Wigner function negativity Paolo Solinas, Beatrice Donelli, Stefano Gherardini Abstract We introduce an operational criterion to identify Wigner function (WF) negativity for an arbitrary quantum state within the framework of quantum non-demolition measurements. This criterion corresponds to experimentally accessible schemes that enable a direct measurement of the WF, and establishes the coherent-state basis as a privileged basis for determining when the WF exhibits negative regions. We show that the absence (presence) of coherent superpositions in the coherent-state basis provides direct information about the positivity (negativity) of the WF. In particular, the absence of such superpositions constitutes a sufficient condition for WF positivity. Although a general proof of necessity remains elusive, we demonstrate that this condition is also necessary in two relevant cases: Schrödinger-cat states and higher-order cat states on a circle. More precisely, for Schrödinger-cat states we establish a necessary and sufficient condition for the positivity of the WF in full generality, whereas for high-order cat states on a circle we derive an analogous condition in the limit of a large number of densely packed coherent states. Discriminating whether a system behaves classically or exhibits quantum features is of paramount importance, both for the foundations of quantum mechanics and for quantum technologies. From a foundational perspective, identifying when quantum behavior in a system vanishes allows us to understand whether it undergoes a quantum-to-classical transition Arndt et al. 1999 , Gerlich et al. 2011 , Aspelmeyer 2022 , Fuchs et al. 2024 , Pedalino et al. 2026 . From a technological point of view, quantum properties are essential for performing cryptographic and computational tasks that are not possible with classical systems Nielsen and Chuang 2010 . The boundary between the quantum and classical worlds is defined by the emergence of non-classical behaviors. While inequalities such as those by Bell Bell 1964 and Leggett-Garg Leggett and Garg 1985 , Emary et al. 2013 are routinely used to identify nonlocality and violations of macrorealism, respectively, a primary hallmark of quantumness for a state is served by the negativity of the corresponding Wigner function (WF) Wigner 1932 , Hillery et al. 1984 . The negativity of the WF derives from the attempt to infer the system’s state using non-commuting observables—namely, position and momentum—that cannot be measured simultaneously Gherardini and De Chiara 2024 . A foundational result in determining when the WF presents negative regions was obtained by Hudson in 1974 Hudson 1974 . He showed that the WF of a pure quantum state is positive if and only if the quantum state is a coherent state, i.e., it is represented with a Gaussian wave function Glauber 1963 , Sudarshan 1963 , Klauder and Skagerstam 1985 . In contrast, for more general (i.e., mixed) states, apart from partial results Mandilara et al. 2009 , a clear framework to establish when the WF is negative is still missing. In this article, we propose a new and operational approach to the problem based on Quantum Non-Demolition Measurements (QNDM) Thorne et al. 1978 , Braginsky et al. 1980 , Braginski et al. 1992 , Caves 1980 , Caves et al. 1980 , Guerlin et al. 2007 , Deléglise et al. 2008 , Solinas and Gasparinetti 2015 , Solinas et al. 2021 , Solinas et al. 2022 , Solinas and Gherardini 2025 , Solinas and Gherardini 2026 . Within this framework, we show that the WF can be experimentally measured using two ancillary detectors at a single time, or by performing a sequential measurement of the position and momentum. Building on earlier Hudson 1974 and more recent results Diósi and Kiefer 2000 , Diósi and Kiefer 2002 , Brody et al. 2025 , Solinas and Gherardini 2025 , we identify coherent states as a privileged set, determining that the off-diagonal elements of the system’s density-matrix expressed in the coherent-state basis (CSB) provide direct information about the negativity of the WF. We prove that the absence of such off-diagonal elements, representing quantum coherence terms in the CSB, implies that the WF is positive. For two relevant cases in the literature, i.e., the Schrödinger-cat state Deléglise et al. 2008 and higher-order cat states on a circle Sedov et al. 2020 , Serafini et al. 2004 , Vlastakis et al. 2013 , we also prove the necessity condition for the WF negativity. As a result, we can accurately predict the critical residual coherence between coherent states above which the WF has negative regions. Our criterion provides a predictive tool for current experimental platforms, such as cavity QED Guerlin et al. 2007 , Deléglise et al. 2008 and mesoscopic systems Maisi et al. 2014 , Lebedev et al. 2016 , while clarifying the fundamental constraints that non-commutativity imposes on phase-space measurements. Wigner function via QNDM scheme— The WF Wigner 1932 , Hillery et al. 1984 , Hudson 1974 for a one-dimensional quantum system is defined as W(X,P)=\frac{1}{4\pi^{2}}\int d\lambda~d\eta~e^{-i\lambda X}e^{-i\eta P}\mathcal{G}_{\lambda,\eta}\,, (1) where \hbar is set to 1 and \mathcal{G}_{\lambda,\eta}=\Tr[e^{i(\lambda\hat{x}+\eta\hat{p})}\hat{\rho}] is the quasi-characteristic function associated with W(X,P) Hudson 1974 . Our first result is that the quasi-characteristic function \mathcal{G}_{\lambda,\eta} and, thus, the WF, can be obtained by performing a QNDM scheme Solinas and Gasparinetti 2015 , Solinas et al. 2021 , Solinas et al. 2022 , Solinas and Gherardini 2025 , Solinas and Gherardini 2026 that uses two ancillary systems. To show this, consider a tripartite system composed of a quantum system \mathcal{S} and two detectors \mathcal{D}_{1} and \mathcal{D}_{2} such that \mathcal{S}_{\rm tot}=\mathcal{S}\otimes\mathcal{D}_{1}\otimes\mathcal{D}_{2} . We denote by \hat{\lambda} and \hat{\eta} the operators acting on the degrees of freedom of \mathcal{D}_{1} and \mathcal{D}_{2} respectively, while \hat{x} and \hat{p} are the position and momentum operators of \mathcal{S} . The system-detector coupling is generated through the unitary operator \hat{\mathcal{U}}_{\lambda,\eta}=\exp{ i (\hx\otimes\hlambda+ \hp\otimes\heta) } where \hat{x}\otimes\hat{\lambda}\equiv\hat{x}\otimes\hat{\lambda}\otimes\mathbb{I} and \hat{p}\otimes\hat{\eta}\equiv\hat{p}\otimes\mathbb{I}\otimes\hat{\eta} . We consider an arbitrary initial state \hat{\rho} for \mathcal{S} , \hat{\rho}_{1}=(1/\sqrt{M_{1}})\sum_{\lambda,\lambda^{\prime}}\outerproduct{\lambda}{\lambda'} for \mathcal{D}_{1} and \hat{\rho}_{2}=(1/\sqrt{M_{2}})\sum_{\eta,\eta^{\prime}}\outerproduct{\eta}{\eta'} for \mathcal{D}_{2} , where M_{1} and M_{2} are appropriate normalization constants. The total density matrix after the coupling is given by \hat{R}_{f}=\hat{\mathcal{U}}_{\lambda,\eta}\hat{R}_{0}\hat{\mathcal{U}}^{\dagger}_{\lambda,\eta} , where \hat{R}_{0}=\hat{\rho}\otimes\hat{\rho}_{1}\otimes\hat{\rho}_{2} . As in the QNDM scheme Solinas and Gasparinetti 2015 , Solinas et al. 2021 , Solinas et al. 2022 , Solinas and Gherardini 2025 , Solinas and Gherardini 2026 , the quasi-characteristic function \mathcal{G}_{\lambda,\eta} in Eq. ( 1 ) can be obtained from the phases accumulated in the two detectors between the states \mathinner{|{\pm\lambda/2}\rangle} and \mathinner{|{\pm\eta/2}\rangle} [see also the Appendix]. This fact becomes apparent by introducing the non-commuting, annihilation and creation operators \hat{a}=(\hat{x}/\sigma+i\sigma\hat{p})/\sqrt{2} and \hat{a}^{\dagger}=(\hat{x}/\sigma-i\sigma\hat{p})/\sqrt{2} with real \sigma , and, using the canonical commutation relation [\hat{x},\hat{p}]=i , we obtain: \displaystyle\mathcal{G}_{\lambda,\eta}=\Tr[e^{\frac{i\lambda}{2}\hat{x}}e^{\frac{i\eta}{2}\hat{p}}\hat{\rho}\,e^{\frac{i\eta}{2}\ \hat{p}}e^{\frac{i\lambda}{2}\hat{x}}]=e^{-\frac{|\alpha|^{2}}{2}}\Tr\left[e^{-\alpha^{*}\hat{a}}\hat{\rho}\,e^{\alpha\hat{a}^{\dagger}}\right], (2) where \alpha=\frac{i\lambda\sigma^{2}-\eta}{\sqrt{2}\sigma} . The separation of \hat{p} and \hat{x} in the exponential allows us to interpret Eq. ( 2 ) as given by two sequential non-demolition measurements within the QNDM scheme. This link with QNDM suggests the following experimental protocol: the system is sequentially coupled in time to the two detectors \mathcal{D}_{1},\mathcal{D}_{2} so that information about the system’s position and momentum is encoded in the detectors’ phases. By varying the coupling strength \lambda and \eta , the quasi-characteristic function \mathcal{G}_{\lambda,\eta} can be reconstructed through standard interferometric measurements of the detector states. The Wigner function is then obtained via the inverse Fourier transform of \mathcal{G}_{\lambda,\eta} . In this framework Solinas and Gasparinetti 2015 ,

Read the complete text