Distinguishing and Separating In-Plane Hall Responses
Soumya Sankar, Xingkai Cheng, Junwei Liu, Berthold Jäck · 2026
Read Distinguishing and Separating In-Plane Hall Responses by Soumya Sankar, Xingkai Cheng, Junwei Liu, Berthold Jäck (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-20227.txt.
Introduction
Sankar and three colleagues untangle in-plane Hall signals, where the measured voltage mixes several effects at once. Their shared framework splits the mix by field-reversal symmetries and angle patterns, using a 12-terminal Hall bar that steers electric and magnetic field lines on their own. They test it on Fe3Sn, a ferromagnetic Weyl semimetal, in an in-plane set-up, tracking its transverse voltage. The standard approach should guide later work on such Hall signals in magnetic and topological matter.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Soumya Sankar, Xingkai Cheng, Junwei Liu, Berthold Jäck |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22796 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.20227
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Distinguishing and Separating In-Plane Hall Responses Soumya Sankar, Xingkai Cheng, Junwei Liu, Berthold Jäck Abstract Electric Hall effects generated by an in-plane magnetic field have recently gained attention owing to their intrinsic origin in topological electronic states and potential application in magnetic field sensing. In pratice, the measured transverse electric voltage typically combines contributions from multiple phenomena, such as anisotropy and Berry curvature effects, leading to interpretative ambiguities of the measurement signal. Here, we introduce a universal framework that disentangles these contributions via their distinct field‑reversal symmetries and angular dependencies. Leveraging a 12‑terminal Hall bar for independent control of the electric and in-plane magnetic field directions, we exemplify this method by analyzing the transverse electric voltage recorded on the the ferromagnetic Weyl semimetal Fe 3 Sn in an in-plane geometry. The standardized approach presented in this work will guide future studies of in-plane Hall responses in magnetic and topological materials. Introduction .–Topological electronic wavefunctions with finite Berry curvature can give rise to novel electric Hall effects, such as the anomalous Hall (AHE) 11 ; 26 ; 2 ; 15 ; 27 ; 23 and nonlinear anomalous Hall effect (NLAHE) 19 ; 7 ; 3 ; 25 . These responses are of great interest for fundamental condensed matter physics and their potential applications in magnetic field sensing 13 , broadband communication networks 17 , and energy harvesting 14 , motivating research into topological and magnetic quantum materials. Conventionally, the electric Hall effect is associated with a transverse voltage generated within the sample xy -plane, either by ferromagnetism or by an external magnetic field applied along the out-of-plane z -direction. These well-known anomalous (AHEs) and ordinary Hall (OHEs) effects only require breaking of time-reversal symmetry \mathcal{T} and are typically isotropic within the xy -plane, meaning are independent of specific device configurations, i.e., the directions of current injection and voltage detection. Recent attention has been drawn to particularly interesting scenarios in which the electric field \bf E , the in‑plane magnetic field \bf B_{\parallel} , and the sample magnetization \bf M_{\parallel} all lie within the sample plane, giving rise to in‑plane Hall responses 8 ; 24 ; 12 ; 18 ; 29 ; 4 . In such configurations, the three external knobs ( \bf E , {\bf B}_{\parallel} , and {\bf M}_{\parallel} ) are no longer independent but engage in multiple complex couplings, making the resulting transverse voltage a sum of several coexisting phenomena. The measured signal is thus generally anisotropic within the xy -plane and depends intricately on the relative angles among E , B_{\parallel} , and M_{\parallel} . For example, the breaking of the three-fold out-of-plane rotation symmetry ( C_{3z} ) by {\bf M}_{\parallel}\neq 0 generally causes the appearance of the symmetric transverse resistance (STR) effect, an anisotropy effect due to intrinsic magnetization 8 , which depends on the relative angle \phi_{E} between \bf M_{\parallel} and \mathbf{E} 20 , as defined in Fig. 1 (a). Moreover, the presence of \mathbf{B_{\parallel}} can cause the planar Hall effect (PHE) 24 ; 1 through magnetic field-induced anisotropic magnetoresistance 28 , which depends on the relative angle \phi_{B}-\phi_{E} between \mathbf{B_{\parallel}} and \mathbf{E} . Because both STR and PHE are anisotropy effects, they are even under magnetization/magnetic field reversal. On the other hand, when both \mathcal{T} and specific crystalline symmetries, such as out-of-plane mirror and rotation symmetries, are broken by \bf M_{\parallel} , the anomalous in-plane Hall effect (AIPHE) can be detected under the application of {\bf B}_{\parallel} 12 ; 18 ; 29 ; 4 . This effect depends only on the relative angle \phi_{B} between \bf M_{\parallel} and \mathbf{B_{\parallel}} [Fig. 1 (a)] and is odd under \phi_{B}\rightarrow\phi_{B}+\pi . The AIPHE has attracted considerable recent attention because it is intimately connected to the intrinsic quantum properties of the electronic band structure such as the Berry curvature, quantum metric, and the chirality of Weyl points 8 ; 20 ; 6 ; 22 ; 18 . In particular, the presence of Weyl points, which act as monopoles of Berry curvature in momentum space, can give rise to a large AIPHE signal which can be effectively tuned by the in-plane magnetic field 18 . As a consequence, these different phenomena (STR, PHE, and IPHE) jointly contribute to the measured transverse voltage signal V_{xy} under commonly occurring experimental conditions. Yet, separating these effects has remained challenging for two primary reasons. First, commonly used device geometries, such as the van der Pauw and conventional Hall bar [Fig. 1 (b)] geometries used in the study of bulk crystals and thin film devices, respectively, do not offer the required angle resolution with respect to \phi_{E} . Second, a universal symmetry‑based framework to disentangle these contributions has not been developed and validated. This causes interpretative ambiguities of V_{xy} , limiting the use of in-plane Hall measurements for the study of topological quantum materials and the associated transport phenomena. In this Letter, we overcome these limitation by introducing a symmetry‑guided experimental protocol that simultaneously achieves two goals: (i) it unambiguously disentangles the PHE, STR, and AIPHE contributions using their different field‑reversal symmetries and angular dependencies; (ii) it employs the direction of the in‑plane magnetic field as a clean, continuously tunable parameter to modulate the AIPHE signal, a true Hall effect. This paradigm opens new opportunities for exploiting in‑plane Hall effects in functional devices, including magnetic field sensors, spin‑orbitronics, and energy‑efficient signal processing. Figure 1: (a) Shown is the in-plane component of the sample magnetization M_{x} defined to be parallel to the +x direction. The azimuthal angles \phi_{E} and \phi_{B} are defined as the angles between the direction of the electric field \mathbf{E} and the x -axis, and the direction of the in-plane magnetic field \mathbf{B}_{\parallel} and the x -axis, respectively. (b) Shown is a schematic of a regular Hall bar geometry with current ( I ) sourced from left to right while measuring the Hall voltage ( V_{H} ) across the top and bottom contacts, providing access to only four values of azimuthal angle \phi_{E} . (c) Shown is a schematic of a circular Hall bar with 12 legs. Current I is sourced from left to right while the Hall voltage V_{H} is measured across the top and bottom contacts, providing access to twelve discrete values of the azimuthal angle \phi_{E} . Theoretical Background .–The transverse linear current response J_{\mu} to an electric field E_{\nu} applied along the longitudinal direction is governed by the conductivity tensor \sigma_{\mu\nu} . For simplicity, we define the longitudinal and transverse directions being along the x- and y- direction, respectively, such that J_{y}=\sigma_{yx}E_{x} . In the case of dissipation-less transport, the antisymmetric component of this tensor, \sigma_{yx}^{\text{A}} , is of particular interest. It is intimately connected to the Berry curvature of the occupied Bloch states and underpins the intrinsic AHEs 10 . For practical purposes, it is often instructive to consider the transverse resistivity \rho_{yx}\approx\sigma_{yx}^{-1} , because it is directly proportional to V_{yx} . In a realistic experimental setting, V_{yx} measured under the application of an in-plane magnetic field {\bf B}_{\parallel} can comprise contributions from various phenomena, such as the STR, the PHE, and the AIPHE. As we discuss in the following, each of these phenomena is characterized by a specific dependence on \phi_{B} and \phi_{E} . It is this