Sub-Neptunes Show a Stronger Correlation with Cold Jupiters than Super-Earths Especially in Metal-rich Systems
Di-Chang Chen, Fei Dai, Bo Ma, Shang-Fei Liu, Cong Yu · 2026
Read Sub-Neptunes Show a Stronger Correlation with Cold Jupiters than Super-Earths Especially in Metal-rich Systems by Di-Chang Chen, Fei Dai, Bo Ma, Shang-Fei Liu, Cong Yu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-20203.txt.
Introduction
Chen and four colleagues compare how inner small planets relate to outer cold Jupiters on either side of the radius valley. Around metal-rich stars, cold Jupiters accompany sub-Neptunes 42.6 percent of the time but super-Earths under 15 percent, against a field rate near 14 percent. The sub-Neptune correlation is significant at over 99 percent confidence, while no such link appears for super-Earths. Kepler-Keck and radial velocity samples agree, fitting metal-rich disks that form outer giants and larger inner planets more efficiently.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Di-Chang Chen, Fei Dai, Bo Ma, Shang-Fei Liu, Cong Yu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30448 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.20203
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Sub-Neptunes Show a Stronger Correlation with Cold Jupiters than Super-Earths Especially in Metal-rich Systems Di-Chang Chen, Fei Dai, Bo Ma, Shang-Fei Liu, Cong Yu Abstract Correlations between the inner small planets and cold giants encodes the formation and evolution of planetary systems. It remains unclear if the correlation differs on the two sides of the radius valley. In this work, we compute the conditional frequency of cold Jupiters in systems with only inner sub-Neptunes P ( CJ | SN ) P(\rm CJ|SN) and those with only inner super-Earths P ( CJ | SE ) P(\rm CJ|SE) . We find that, around transiting sample around metal-rich stars, P ( CJ | SN , [ Fe / H ] > 0 ) P(\rm CJ|SN,[Fe/H]>0) and P ( CJ | SE , [ Fe / H ] > 0 ) P(\rm CJ|SE,[Fe/H]>0) are 42.6 − 9.9 + 10.6 % 42.6^{+10.6}_{-9.9}\% and 14.5 − 6.9 + 12.7 % 14.5^{+12.7}_{-6.9}\% . Comparing with the field giant frequency ( 14.3 − 1.8 + 2.0 % 14.3^{+2.0}_{-1.8}\% ), we show that inner sub-Neptunes and cold Jupiters exhibit a significant positive correlation for metal-rich systems with a confidence level of 99.95%, whereas this correlation is absent for systems with super-Earths. We also consider a homogeneous Kepler-Keck subsample and derive similar results, with P ( CJ | SN , [ Fe / H ] > 0 ) P(\rm CJ|SN,[Fe/H]>0) of 45.8 − 16.3 + 18.6 % 45.8^{+18.6}_{-16.3}\% and P ( CJ | SE , [ Fe / H ] > 0 ) P(\rm CJ|SE,[Fe/H]>0) of 13.3 − 6.8 + 17.0 % 13.3^{+17.0}_{-6.8}\% . Radial velocity sample shows consistent results, with metal-rich systems hosting massive inner planets exhibiting a strong positive correlation (confidence level of 99.11%) with outer cold Jupiters ( P ( CJ | M p > 10 M ⊕ , [ Fe / H ] > 0 ) = 34.6 − 9.1 + 11.0 % P(\rm CJ|M_{p}>10M_{\oplus},[Fe/H]>0)=34.6^{+11.0}_{-9.1}\% ). These results can be naturally understood since metal-rich disks are expected to more efficiently produce both outer cold Jupiters and inner planets with larger radii and masses. Our findings highlight the critical role of stellar metallicity in shaping planetary architectures, particularly for large/massive planets. I Introduction Over the past two decades, exoplanet surveys have revealed that planets with sizes between those of Earth and Neptune are abundant in the Galaxy. Statistical studies based on radial velocity and transit observations suggest that \sim 30\%-50\% Sun-like stars host at least one such planets in inner orbits ( 28 ; 30 ; 41 , e.g.,) . Understanding how they form and interact with other planetary systems, particularly outer gas giants, is therefore essential for developing a comprehensive theory of planet formation and evolution. The correlation between inner small planets and outer cold Jupiters has been considered a useful test. Using carefully constructed samples of radial velocity and transiting systems, 42 reported that cold Jupiters occur in approximately one-third of systems with inner small planets, which is about three times higher than that around field stars. This excess of cold Jupiters in systems hosting inner small planets was later confirmed by several independent studies ( 5 ; 36 , e.g.,) . However, more recent analyses have suggested a weaker or even negative correlation between the two populations ( 3 , e.g.,) . A possible resolution to this discrepancy was proposed by 45 , who argued that stellar metallicity is a key parameter governing the observed correlation. Indeed, by analyzing the largest sample to date of systems hosting both inner small planets and outer gas giants, 6 demonstrated that the correlation is pronounced among metal-rich stars ( \rm[Fe/H]>0 ) but statistically insignificant for metal-poor systems, lending strong support to this interpretation. Statistical studies have revealed another key feature of close-in exoplanets, radius valley, a deficit of planets around \sim 1.9R_{\oplus} that separates compact, rocky super-Earths from lower-density sub-Neptunes ( 32 ; 16 ) . Several theoretical models have been proposed to explain its origin. Some studies suggested that sub-Neptunes are born with a H/He dominated gas envelope and the radius valley is a result of atmospheric loss driven by photoevaporation ( 32 ; 33 ; 22 ) or core-powered mass loss ( 18 ; 19 ) . Alternatively, other studies have suggested that sub-Neptunes are intrinsically volatile-rich, and the radius valley arises naturally from planet formation and migration processes ( 40 ; 38 ; 25 ; 8 ) . Plenty of studies have investigated the the dependence of the radius valley on planetary and stellar properties ( 37 ; 31 ; 1 ; 12 , e.g., orbital period, stellar mass, metallicity, age;) . However, current observational constraints remain insufficient to conclusively distinguish among these competing theoretical scenarios. In this work, we thus divide the inner planets into two categories (i.e., sub-Neptune, valley planet and super-Earth) and investigate their correlations with cold Jupiters based on the planetary sample in 6 , aiming to help constrain the formation and migration histories. In section II , we describe how we categorize the planetary systems. In section III , we calculated the conditional frequency of cold Jupiters in different type of systems around metal-rich and metal-poor systems. Finally, section IV summarizes our findings and discusses their implications. II Sample 6 collects a sample of 184 systems with publicly available radial velocity data and detected outer gas giants. Since most small planets discovered by the radial velocity (RV) method lack radius measurements, and the subsequent classification relies on planetary radii, we therefore focus on systems with the 109 transiting small planets (i.e., 1R_{\oplus}\leq R_{\rm P}\leq 4R_{\oplus} ). Among these systems, 16 systems host one or more cold Jupiters, with masses of 0.5-20M_{\rm J} and semi-major axes of 1-10 AU. Previous studies have found that the radius valley is located at R_{\rm Valley}^{0}\sim 1.9\pm 0.2R_{\oplus} ( 33 ; 16 ) and is dependent on stellar mass M_{*} ( 1 ) and planetary orbital period P ( 37 ) , which can be characterized as: R^{\rm valley}=R_{\rm valley}^{0}\left(\frac{M_{*}}{M_{\odot}}\right)^{h}\left(\frac{P}{\rm 10days}\right)^{g}, (1) where h and g are are the corresponding slopes, which are adopted as 0.21^{+0.06}_{-0.07} and -0.09^{+0.02}_{-0.03} ( 21 ; 20 ) , respectively. We then classify planets into two categories based on whether their radii lie above or below the planetary radius valley: sub-Neptunes and super-Earths. Based on the planet categories of the small planets in each planetary system, we further divide the systems into three types: 1. Sub-Neptune systems, i.e., systems with only sub-Neptunes: 52 systems, 10 of which hosting cold Jupiters. 2. Super-Earth systems, i.e., systems with only super-Earths: 28 systems, 3 of which hosting cold Jupiters. 3. Mixed systems, i.e., systems with both Sub-Neptunes and super-Earths. 29 systems, 3 of which hosting cold Jupiters. Figure 1: Orbital architectures of the 59 metal-rich (Left) and 53 metal-poor (Right) transiting planetary systems. Super-Earths, sub-Neptunes and cold Jupiters are plotted in green, orange and blue, respectively. The three types (i.e., sub-Neptune, mixed and super-Earth) of systems are arranged from top to bottom. Within each type, the systems are sorted by the radius of the largest planet in the system. The symbol sizes of Super-Earths and sub-Neptunes are proportional to the planetary cross-sectional areas, while