Investigating Targeting Strategies and Truncation in TMLE for the Average Treatment Effect under Practical Positivity Violations
Yichen Xu, Susan Gruber, Mark J. van der Laan · 2026
Read Investigating Targeting Strategies and Truncation in TMLE for the Average Treatment Effect under Practical Positivity Violations by Yichen Xu, Susan Gruber, Mark J. van der Laan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-20059.txt.
Introduction
Xu, Gruber, and van der Laan study TMLE targeting and truncation for average treatment effects under practical positivity violations. Loss-weighted targeting can bias results a lot versus clever-covariate targeting, while too little truncation inflates spread for the latter approach. Fixed truncation rules with constants 5 or 6 prove robust defaults, though the best choice varies with sample size and setting. A Lepski-type adaptive rule with a brake improves stability, and targeted bootstrap estimation stays stable across truncation levels.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yichen Xu, Susan Gruber, Mark J. van der Laan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50925 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.20059
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Investigating Targeting Strategies and Truncation in TMLE for the Average Treatment Effect under Practical Positivity Violations Yichen Xu, Susan Gruber, Mark J. van der Laan Abstract Estimating average treatment effects from observational data is challenging under practical violations of the positivity assumption. Targeted maximum likelihood estimators (TMLEs) are widely used because of their double robustness and efficiency, but their finite-sample performance can be sensitive to extreme inverse-probability factors in the targeting step. In standard TMLE implementations, these inverse-probability factors enter through the clever covariate used in the fluctuation regression; an alternative implementation removes these factors from the clever covariate and instead incorporates them as observation weights in the loss function, which we refer to as loss-weighted targeting. We conduct extensive simulation studies to examine how targeting strategy and truncation level affect TMLE performance under varying degrees of outcome-regression misspecification and practical positivity violations. We show that loss-weighted targeting can induce substantial systematic bias, whereas retaining the inverse-probability factor in the clever covariate, together with appropriate truncation, yields more stable performance. For clever-covariate-scaled targeting, insufficient truncation leads to inflated variance, indicating that the estimated propensity score must be bounded sufficiently far from zero to maintain estimator stability. We further find that the recommended settings c = 5 c=5 and c = 6 c=6 in the lower bound c / ( n ln n ) c/(\sqrt{n}\ln n) provide robust fixed truncation rules across many settings, although the optimal truncation level varies with sample size. Building on these findings, we identify limitations of standard Lepski’s method for truncation selection in this setting and propose a Lepski-type adaptive truncation procedure with a safe brake mechanism designed to avoid unstable low-truncation regions. We also evaluate variance estimation methods for clever-covariate-scaled targeting and find that targeted bootstrap variance estimation provides a stable alternative across truncation levels. 1 Introduction Observational studies are increasingly used to evaluate treatment and exposure effects in real-world settings, particularly as electronic health records, administrative databases, population-based surveys, and other large observational data sources have become more widely available [ 8 ] . In observational studies, investigators do not randomly assign treatment or exposure but instead analyze nonrandomized data, such as electronic health records, administrative databases, population-based surveys, or single-arm trials augmented with external controls. Treatment decisions are typically driven by patient characteristics, clinical practice, or system-level factors rather than experimental allocation. Although the absence of randomization introduces the possibility of confounding, OS offer important advantages: they often reflect real-world conditions, enhance external validity, and may be more feasible, ethical, and cost-effective than RCTs, particularly in complex or large-scale settings. Without the benefit of randomization as in randomized controlled trials, observational studies require statistical adjustment for confounding. Broadly, such adjustment can proceed either through outcome regression methods—such as BART [ 4 ] used with the G-computation formula [ 21 ] , which models the conditional mean of Y given treatment and covariates to estimate counterfactual outcomes—or through propensity score methods [ 29 ] , which model the treatment assignment mechanism to reweight or match subjects and thereby emulate randomization [ 14 ] . The propensity score represents the probability that an individual will be assigned to a particular treatment group, conditional on observed covariates. Methods that use the propensity score in estimation, such as inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPTW) [ 3 ] and targeted maximum likelihood estimation (TMLE) [ 25 ] , rely on the positivity assumption to ensure identification and stable estimation of causal effects [ 30 ] . This assumption, in theory, requires 0<\text{PS}<1 , meaning that the conditional probability of receiving any treatment cannot be zero or one within any confounder subgroup. A theoretical violation occurs when it is impossible for any subject in the subgroup to receive a certain treatment, and increasing the sample size cannot resolve this. In contrast, practical violation arises when a subject has a non-zero probability of treatment assignment, but the assignment does not occur in the observed data or is extremely rare. With sufficiently large sample sizes, practical violations can be mitigated, but with limited data, the estimated inverse PS, \frac{1}{P(A=1|W)} , can become extreme, leading to bias or inflated variance in the final estimators [ 6 , 7 ] . To mitigate and diagnose the practical positivity issues in IPTW-based estimators, many works [ 29 , 15 , 9 , 5 ] truncate the extreme PS or filter out samples with extreme fitted PS. Other methods use overlap weights [ 2 , 18 ] to upweight samples with higher overlapping scores. [ 19 ] proposes to use bootstrapping as a method to identify positivity issues. Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimators (TMLE) [ 27 , 25 , 26 , 10 ] are widely used for estimating causal parameters due to their desirable properties, including bias reduction, double robustness, and semiparametric efficiency [ 22 ] . However, TMLE can be unstable under practical positivity violations. For example, [ 20 ] reports degraded performance when outcomes are rare and sample sizes are small. To improve stability, [ 24 , 28 ] propose adaptive TMLE procedures that project the average treatment effect onto a working model defined by a relaxed highly adaptive lasso [ 1 ] , and [ 11 ] recommends truncating inverse probability weights at the level \frac{5}{\sqrt{n}\ln n} to control mean squared error. Regarding variance estimation, [ 23 ] develops plug-in and targeted bootstrap approaches to address underestimation of the efficient influence function based variance estimator in longitudinal counterfactual mean settings. Despite these advances, systematic comparisons of loss-weighted and clever-covariate–scaled targeting across varying degrees of practical positivity violations remain limited. In addition, the stability of fixed truncation rules is not fully understood, data-adaptive truncation strategies remain underexplored, and the interaction between variance estimation and data-adaptive truncation procedures, such as Lepski-type selection, has received limited attention for the point-treatment average treatment effect. In this article, we focus on continuous outcomes, following [ 12 ] , as they present more nuanced challenges than binary outcomes. We conduct extensive simulation studies across multiple scenarios, including varying degrees of outcome regression misspecification (from highly misspecified to nearly correctly specified), the severity of practical positivity violations, a comparison of loss-weighted targeting and clever-covariate-scaled targeting in the TMLE update step [ 13 ] , and different truncation levels c in the inverse-weight bound \frac{c}{\sqrt{n}\ln n} . Here, loss-weighted targeting ( gWt ) refers to a TMLE fluctuation that incorporates inverse-probability factors directly into the loss function, whereas clever-covariate-scaled targeting ( gH ) keeps the loss unweighted and instead incorporates the inverse-probability factors through the clever covariate in the fluctuation submodel. We demonstrate that loss-weighted targeting can induce substantial systematic bias under practical positivity violations, whereas retaining the inverse-probability factor in the clever covariate and applying appropriate truncation yields more stable performance. For clever-covariate-scaled targeting , minimal truncation leads to increased variance, indicating that a sufficiently large truncation level is necessary to maintain estimator stability. Building on these findings, we identify limitations of standard Lepski’s method for truncation selection in this context and propose a Lepski-type adaptive truncation mechanism with a brake rule that preserves stability when the Lepski selection is unreliable, enabling robust data-adaptive truncation in practice. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. In Section