Deconstructing Superintelligence: Identity, Self-Modification and Différance

Elija Perrier · 2026

Read Deconstructing Superintelligence: Identity, Self-Modification and Différance by Elija Perrier (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-19845.txt.

Introduction

Perrier formalizes self-modification in artificial superintelligence on an associative operator algebra, treating modification as an action that needs a supplement outside the act. A propagation theorem shows non-commutation spreads to self-picture, and the liar paradox appears as the rank-one case. Systems in which the update operator acts on the difference operator reproduce the paradox at system scale, yielding a structure matching Priest's schema.

Catalog record

CREATORElija Perrier
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47819
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.19845

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Deconstructing Superintelligence: Identity, Self-Modification and Différance Elija Perrier Abstract Self-modification is often taken as constitutive of artificial superintelligence ( SI ), yet modification is a relative action requiring a supplement outside the operation. When self-modification extends to this supplement, the classical self-referential structure collapses. We formalise this on an associative operator algebra 𝒜 \mathcal{A} with update U ^ \hat{U} , discrimination D ^ \hat{D} , and self-representation R ^ \hat{R} , identifying the supplement with Comm ⁡ ( U ^ ) \operatorname{Comm}(\hat{U}) ; an expansion theorem shows [ U ^ , R ^ ] [\hat{U},\hat{R}] decomposes through [ U ^ , D ^ ] [\hat{U},\hat{D}] , so non-commutation generically propagates. The liar paradox appears as a commutator collapse [ T ^ , Π L ] = 0 [\hat{T},\Pi_{L}]=0 , and class 𝐀 \mathbf{A} self-modification realises the same collapse at system scale, yielding a structure coinciding with Priest’s inclosure schema and Derrida’s différance . 1 1 1 Under review 1 Introduction The ability to self-modify is a hallmark of many theories of artificial general intelligence ( AGI ) and artificial superintelligence ( ASI ). Typically, self-modification is framed as a superlative quality of these theories: by being able to modify not just typical actions but the underlying agentic architecture—physical, cognitive, procedural—that instantiates AGI/ASI, such systems are argued to possess greater adaptivity and, as a result, greater capacity to optimise, whether for decision-making, survival, planning, or the shaping of their environment itself. In this framing, self-modification is not a mere property of ASI but rather, when stipulated, a necessary feature: essential to what it is . Intuitively, the framing is understandable, even defensible. If intelligence involves, at its centre, the ability to act in adaptive ways—including reasoning and planning—then a cursory look at the world shows that the entities we identify as intelligent, whether characterised by reasoning, tool use, planning, or cognitive behaviour, all tend to exhibit heightened degrees of self-modification. In humans this takes the form of thought and language, which in turn manifests in our ability to modify, more than any other species, the world around us. However, in all cases of self-modification, exactly what is being causally modified is constrained. Humans reason and have a sense of autonomy, yet cannot will control over most of their bodies’ activities. This reflects an architectural—and, as we will argue, necessary—feature: some part of the system, the part doing the modifying, must at least for the duration of change remain unmodified, functioning as a supplement in the Derridean sense—a structure outside the present operation whose stability is what makes the operation possible at all. Modification is a relative, causal action by one thing upon another; even the purported self-modification of a unified multiplicity, such as a human, is more precisely the action of some part of that multiplicity upon another, and every such action affects the identity of what is modified by construction. This much is uncontroversial. What is not is the behaviour of the supplement structure when the scope of modification becomes broad enough that the supplement is itself inside the action of the modifying operation. Contemporary AGI/ASI theories propose self-modification of an extent, scope, and speed that far surpasses anything present in organic life: modification not only of policies or memories but of evaluators, validators, self-models, and the very individuation tests by which a system is recognised as itself. An important open question is therefore structural: when self-modification extends to the apparatus that individuates the system itself, what structure—if any—secures identity across time, and how is it expressed formally? 1.1 Contributions We explore this question making the following contributions: (i) An operator-algebraic formalism for self-modifying systems in which update \hat{U} , discrimination \hat{D} , and self-representation \hat{R} are operators in an associative algebra \mathcal{A} over a vector space of system-states, with the supplement identified as the commutant of \hat{U} and identity-unifying structures as projectors in that commutant. (ii) An expansion and generic propagation theorem: the adjoint action \operatorname{ad}_{\hat{U}}(X)=[\hat{U},X] is a derivation on composites, so if \hat{R} is built from \hat{D} then [\hat{U},\hat{R}] expands as a finite sum of terms containing [\hat{U},\hat{D}] ; non-commutation propagates whenever this sum does not vanish by cancellation or annihilation (Theorem 3.1 ). A Jacobi corollary restricts unifying supplements to projectors commuting also with [\hat{U},\hat{D}] (Corollary 1 ); the liar paradox is exhibited as a rank-one commutator collapse [\hat{T},\Pi_{L}]=0 avoided classically by a linguistic supplement (Proposition 1 ). (iii) An identification of class \mathbf{A} —architectures in which update acts on the discrimination apparatus—as the regime where the same commutator collapse occurs at the scale of a whole system: the supplement stabilising the sign/signified distinction in the self-model is precisely the discrimination apparatus strong self-modification places within the action of \hat{U} . The diagonal producing a self-description that cannot be preserved under update follows as a one-line corollary of propagation (Corollary 2 ). (iv) Mapping commonalities of the resulting formal pattern with Priest’s inclosure schema [ 43 , 44 , 45 ] and with what Derrida calls différance [ 13 ] , derived directly from the operator algebra, with Derrida’s iterability condition identified with class \mathbf{A} ’s self-representation requirement and the grafting and supplementary motifs identified with kernel-enlargement and image-enlargement of \hat{U} respectively. 2 Superintelligence and Identity Almost every substantive claim made about a superintelligent system—that it pursues convergent instrumental goals [ 4 , 36 ] , retains its values, may deceive its principals during training [ 24 , 7 ] , must be aligned [ 47 , 55 ] , may be owed welfare consideration [ 34 , 5 ] —presupposes a persisting referent whose features may drift but whose identity holds across the drift. For ordinary software the persistence relation is supplied externally through source control, deployment pipelines, cryptographic attestation [ 50 ] , and institutional record; for human agents it is underwritten by biological and social continuities [ 19 , 57 ] . Strong self-modification changes the situation, because a system that can edit its evaluators, validators, self-models, and individuation tests begins to act on the machinery by which its later states would be recognised as continuations of its earlier ones. Our central claim is that, once the supplement enters the action of the modifying operator, identity is no longer secured by any unconditional unifying structure but only supplementally : relative to whichever structure a given frame treats as unifying, with the unifying itself deferred at the next step of modification. Identity puzzles are not themselves new. Classical puzzles about ordinary objects [ 60 , 53 ] and persons [ 39 , 52 , 48 ] are resolved by coarse-graining to a frame where the differences between successive states do not count, or by indexing identity to an external criterion. Ship of Theseus style-problems [ 42 , 8 ] require a criterion determining which continuity - material, formal, functional, spatiotemporal, or sortal - counts as identity-preserving. Classical formalisms of self-reference—the recursion theorem [ 28 ] , Löb’s theorem [ 33 ] , von Neumann’s self-reproducing automata [ 59 ] , Gödel’s diagonal [ 20 , 3 ] —secure a system’s access to its own description by exteriorising the referent as a datum the computation treats as an object. Both resolutions rely on the same presupposition:

Read the complete text