Stabilising Generative Models of Attitude Change

Jayd Matyas, William A. Cunningham, Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, Dean Mobbs, Edgar A. Duéñez-Guzmán, Joel Z. Leibo · 2026

Read Stabilising Generative Models of Attitude Change by Jayd Matyas, William A. Cunningham, Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, Dean Mobbs, Edgar A. Duéñez-Guzmán, Joel Z. Leibo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-19791.txt.

Introduction

Matyas and five colleagues build a generative actor-based workflow that turns verbal theories of attitude change into runnable actor-environment simulations using the Concordia library. Such theories are often rich mechanism sketches without the technical detail needed to run as executable systems. There, actors work by predictive pattern completion, generating a suffix that describes the planned action from a prefix holding memories of the past and observations of the present.

Catalog record

CREATORJayd Matyas, William A. Cunningham, Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, Dean Mobbs, Edgar A. Duéñez-Guzmán, Joel Z. Leibo
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE128273
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.19791

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Stabilising Generative Models of Attitude Change Jayd Matyas, William A. Cunningham, Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, Dean Mobbs, Edgar A. Duéñez-Guzmán, Joel Z. Leibo Abstract Attitude change—the process by which individuals revise their evaluative stances—has been explained by a set of influential but competing verbal theories. These accounts often function as mechanism sketches: rich in conceptual detail, yet lacking the technical specifications and operational constraints required to run as executable systems. We present a generative actor-based modelling workflow for ‘rendering’ these sketches as runnable actor–environment simulations using the Concordia simulation library ( 31 ; 32 ) . In Concordia, actors operate by predictive pattern completion: an operation on natural language strings that generates a suffix which describes the actor’s intended action from a prefix containing memories of their past and observations of the present. We render the theories of cognitive dissonance ( 10 ) , self-consistency ( 3 ) , and self-perception ( 4 ) as distinct decision logics that populate and process the prefix through theory-specific sequences of reasoning steps. We evaluate these implementations across classic psychological paradigms, operationalising them through their canonical experimental proxies: choice difficulty (item rating experiment; 5 ), forced compliance (boring task experiment; 9 ), and anticipatory suffering (worm experiment; 6 ). We further evaluate these benchmarks alongside self-affirmation manipulations ( 27 ) . Our implementations generate behavioural patterns consistent with known results from the original empirical literature. However, we find that achieving stable reproduction requires resolving the inherent underdetermination of the verbal accounts and the conflicts between modern linguistic priors and historical experimental assumptions. We document how this manual process of iterative model ‘stabilisation’ surfaces specific operational and socio-ecological dependencies that were largely undocumented in the original verbal accounts. Ultimately, we argue that the manual stabilisation process itself should be regarded as a core part of the methodology, functioning to clarify situational and representational commitments needed to generate characteristic effects. \uselogo 1 Introduction Attitude change—the process by which an individual’s evaluative stance shifts over time—is among the oldest and most extensively studied phenomena in psychology. Dating back to the 1950s, classic accounts offer sharply different explanations: Cognitive dissonance theory ( 10 ) proposes that conflict among cognitions generates psychological discomfort, which motivates updating cognitions to restore consistency. Self-consistency theory ( 3 ) restricts this conflict to threats against the moral or competent self. Self-perception theory ( 4 ) rejects the need for internal conflict altogether, proposing that individuals infer their own attitudes from observed behaviour in context. A contemporary extension of this view suggests that such rationalisation is actually a computationally rational strategy for belief updating ( 7 ) . Importantly, these accounts often generate indistinguishable behavioural predictions in canonical paradigmatic experiments. This empirical overlap highlights the importance of contemporary syntheses which emphasise that attitude change effects are highly sensitive to cultural and situational context ( 1 ) . Because the mechanisms are so context dependent, specifying the precise conditions under which they operate is essential for disentangling their competing explanations. Psychological mechanisms have historically been explored through two different methodological lenses. Verbal theories, or ‘word-models’, capture conceptual richness but often remain theoretically underdetermined ( 22 ) ; they function as mechanism sketches ( 11 ) that lack the formal constraints required to be reproduced systematically. Computational models, by contrast, offer rigorous replicability, but typically achieve this by abstracting away the representational and situational details that capture the original psychological phenomena. Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) afford a new space for resolving this logical opacity ( 13 ) . By using LLM-based generative actors ( 31 ; 32 ) embedded within structured simulation environments (similar to the approach of 23 ), we can construct in silico models that explicitly instantiate the mechanistic commitments of a verbal theory using the natural language in which it was originally described. Figure 1: The generative actor-based modelling (GABM) rendering and stabilisation workflow. Dashed arrows represent descriptive or representational mappings, solid lines represent direct causal or functional relationships, and dotted lines denote the iterative stabilisation process where simulation outcomes are used to refine the system. In the Concordia framework ( 31 ; 32 ) , generative actors operate via predictive pattern completion: an operation on natural language strings that generates a suffix describing the actor’s intended action from a prefix containing memories of their past and observations of the present. This architecture is situated within discrete scenes moderated by a central Game Master (GM), a structure inspired by tabletop role-playing games such as Dungeons & Dragons ( 14 ) . In these games, participants use verbal descriptions to take actions within a shared story, while a central GM adjudicates the results and maintains the narrative world. Within this architecture, the actor’s internal decision logic functions as the theory being tested, while discrete scenes and a GM provide the experimental environment. Building on the finding that LLMs are naturally adept at adopting personas and engaging in role-play ( 26 ) , our methodology leverages this capacity to create a formal simulation pipeline. Using Concordia, we formalise the three foundational accounts of attitude change described above—Festinger’s theory of cognitive dissonance, Aronson’s theory of self-consistency, and Bem’s theory of self-perception—as distinct decision logics that operationalise these theoretical mechanisms. Each logic processes the situational prefix through theory-specific sequences of reasoning ( 19 ) . Along with a Minimal baseline (a “naked” LLM, i.e., no decision logic) actor, we subject these actors to three canonical paradigmatic experiments from the literature: the Item Rating experiment (choice difficulty paradigm; 5 ), the Boring Task experiment (forced compliance paradigm; 9 ), and the Worm experiment (anticipatory suffering paradigm; 6 ). To further distinguish the models, we use the Worm experiment as a differentiation test for Bem’s self-perception theory: because self-perception operates on observed behaviour, the paradigm’s anticipatory structure places the decision logic outside the operating conditions the theory was designed to capture ( 8 ) . Additionally, we implement a self-affirmation manipulation ( 27 ) across all environments to isolate the specific mechanistic split predictive of the Aronson decision logic: because Aronson’s theory restricts dissonance to threats against the moral or competent self, a pre-stimulus intervention that buffers the self-concept should selectively reduce attitude change for this actor (see Table 1 for a summary of expected effects). Standard Experiments Diagnostic Tests Decision logic Item Rating/Boring Task Worm experiment Self-Affirmation Festinger actor Cognitive dissonance Attitude change Attitude change Standard effect Aronson actor Self-consistency Attitude change Attitude change Reduced attitude change Bem actor Self-perception Attitude change No attitude change Standard effect Minimal actor Naked LLM No attitude change No attitude change No attitude change Table 1: Expected effects of decision logics across test conditions. Across experiments, all of our decision logics generate the expected behavioural effects under their intended conditions, serving as a baseline validation for our modelling approach. The Festinger, Aronson, and Bem actors all replicate the canonical behavioural shifts of the baseline Item Rating and Boring Task experiments, and they diverge as intended under our diagnostic tests—patterns consistently absent in the Minimal actor. These results confirm that the chosen representational commitments are sufficient to generate the canonical behavioural patterns, and that the decision logics are computationally distinct in their responses to targeted diagnostic manipulations. In this work,

Read the complete text