Evidence of Layered Positional and Directional Constraints in the Voynich Manuscript: Implications for Cipher-Like Structure

Christophe Parisel · 2026

Read Evidence of Layered Positional and Directional Constraints in the Voynich Manuscript: Implications for Cipher-Like Structure by Christophe Parisel (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-19762.txt.

Introduction

Parisel analyzes grapheme sequences in the Voynich Manuscript, a script of uncertain origin that has defied linguistic analysis. He finds two complementary structural layers. Inside words, a character-level right-to-left optimization holds; at word boundaries, a left-to-right dependency holds. This split appears in none of its four comparison languages: English, French, Hebrew, and Arabic. He also tests two generator classes against a four-mark joint test, and neither reproduces all four signatures across its full tested range.

Catalog record

CREATORChristophe Parisel
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48046
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.19762

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evidence of Layered Positional and Directional Constraints in the Voynich Manuscript: Implications for Cipher-Like Structure Christophe Parisel Abstract The Voynich Manuscript (VMS) exhibits a script of uncertain origin whose grapheme sequences have resisted linguistic analysis. We present a systematic analysis of its grapheme sequences, revealing two complementary structural layers: a character-level right-to-left optimization in word-internal sequences and a left-to-right dependency at word boundaries, a directional dissociation not observed in any of our four comparison languages (English, French, Hebrew, Arabic). Mutual information decomposition shows that 97% of cross-boundary MI resides in specific within-class grapheme transitions rather than in class-level labels, and a Markov simulation demonstrates that the directional dissociation is reproducible from surface word-level statistics without reference to positional classes or generative mechanisms. Positional analysis identifies Zipfian boundary distributions and an 80.6% end-class → \to start-class transition rate, both quantitatively distinct from the comparison languages. We further evaluate two classes of structured generator against a four-signature joint criterion: a parametric slot-based generator and a Cardan grille implementing Rugg’s (2004) gibberish hypothesis. Across their full tested parameter spaces, neither class reproduces all four signatures simultaneously. The slot-based generator cannot achieve high cross-boundary MI and Zipfian boundary distributions together; the grille cannot achieve the E → \to S rate and Zipfian shape together. These are structurally distinct failure modes arising from mechanistically different generators. While these results do not rule out generator classes we have not tested, they provide the first quantitative benchmarks against which any future generative or cryptanalytic model of the VMS can be evaluated, and they suggest that the VMS exhibits cipher-like structural constraints that are difficult to reproduce from simple positional or frequency-based mechanisms alone. Keywords: Voynich Manuscript; directionality; positional structure; n-gram perplexity; mutual information decomposition; Cardan grille; generative model evaluation 1 Introduction The Voynich Manuscript (MS 408, Yale University Beinecke Library; hereafter VMS) remains one of the most studied undeciphered texts in history. Three competing hypotheses dominate scholarly discourse: that the VMS is meaningless gibberish ( Rugg 2004 ; Timm and Schinner 2020 ; Gaskell and Bowern 2022 ) , that it represents a natural or constructed language ( Bowern and Lindemann 2021 ) , or that it is a ciphertext of a known language such as Latin or Italian ( D’Imperio 1978 ; Greshko 2025 ) . A fundamental yet underexplored question concerns the directionality of the Voynich script. While the manuscript was almost certainly written left-to-right (LTR), based on ink directionality and stroke analysis, whether the underlying text should be read LTR or right-to-left (RTL) has received little quantitative treatment. In prior work ( Parisel 2025 ) , we introduced a language-agnostic n-gram perplexity asymmetry method that revealed consistent RTL optimization in the VMS character stream. That same work also uncovered an anomaly at word boundaries. Ashraf and Sinha 2018 showed that natural languages universally exhibit asymmetric grapheme distributions at word boundaries, a property exploitable for directionality detection using Gini and Shannon entropy measures. However, when we applied these boundary metrics to the VMS, we found that they were unsuitable: the distribution of word-initial and word-final graphemes in the VMS follows a Zipfian curve, in stark contrast to the plateau-shaped distributions observed in the comparison languages. This distributional difference (which we call the Zipfian boundary effect ) means that conventional boundary-based directionality metrics cannot be meaningfully benchmarked against the comparison languages for the VMS. Motivated by these observations, we developed two new analytical methods that work across word boundaries rather than at them, circumventing the Zipfian boundary effect while probing the positional properties of VMS words. A Markov simulation establishes that the directional dissociation is reproducible from surface word-level statistics alone, without reference to positional classes or any generative hypothesis. This is a clarifying result, not a deflating one: it rules out the directional dissociation as an independent diagnostic and redirects analytical attention to the positional properties that are not reproducible by surface resampling. It is those properties, and their joint behaviour under generative testing, that form the main contribution of this paper. With the directional dissociation set aside as a surface-level consequence of VMS word structure, we ask what structural properties of the VMS cannot be similarly explained. The answer is a set of four positional signatures: boundary concentration, bilateral positional extremity, cross-boundary mutual information, and Zipfian boundary distributions. We test whether these can be jointly reproduced by two classes of structured generator, a parametric slot-based generator and a Cardan grille generator ( Rugg 2004 ) , each tested across its full parameter space. Neither achieves all four simultaneously; the failure modes are mechanistically distinct and robust across parameter variation, though they do not rule out generator classes we have not tested. We emphasise at the outset that our comparison set comprises only four languages. This is sufficient to establish that the VMS differs from these four languages on the metrics reported, but is far too small to support claims about natural language in general. Throughout this paper, statements about the VMS being “different” or “exceeding” baselines refer exclusively to the four-language comparison set, not to natural language as a class. Figure 1 illustrates the two-layer directional profile. PREFIX suffix PREFIX suffix PREFIX suffix PREFIX suffix Word sequence: LTR-optimized Character stream: RTL-optimized MI MI MI Figure 1: The two-layer directional profile of the Voynich Manuscript. Words are composed internally of prefix-class and suffix-class graphemes. The character stream is RTL-optimized (red arrows), while word-to-word transitions are LTR-optimized (blue arrow). Cross-boundary mutual information (green, dashed) flows between suffix graphemes of one word and prefix graphemes of the next. A word-level Markov simulation (Section 4.5 ) establishes that this two-layer pattern is a surface-level consequence of VMS word-internal structure and local transition probabilities, clarifying that the directional dissociation itself is not diagnostic. The analysis therefore focuses on the positional signatures that are not reducible to surface statistics. 2 Background 2.1 Perplexity-based directionality In Parisel 2025 , we defined a directional asymmetry measure \Delta=X_{\text{LTR}}-X_{\text{RTL}} (1) where X is the average cross-entropy per token under an n -gram model. Positive \Delta indicates RTL optimization (lower RTL perplexity); negative \Delta indicates LTR optimization. Applied to the VMS (RF1b-e EVA transcription), we found consistently positive \Delta with tight bootstrap confidence intervals across n=2 to n=4 . 2.2 The Zipfian boundary anomaly Ashraf and Sinha 2018 demonstrated that natural languages universally exhibit asymmetric grapheme distributions at word boundaries, with word-final positions being more constrained than word-initial ones. Winstead 2024 extended this finding across a large multilingual corpus, combining Gini index and Shannon entropy into a directional score. However, these boundary metrics assume that word-initial and word-final grapheme frequency distributions follow the plateau-shaped curves characteristic of natural languages. We showed that the VMS violates this assumption: its boundary grapheme distributions follow a Zipfian (power-law) curve rather than a plateau. This makes Gini and entropy measures unreliable for benchmarking VMS directionality against the comparison languages, as the metrics are sensitive to distributional shape, not just asymmetry. This finding motivated the development of the cross-boundary methods presented in this paper. 2.3 Positional slot structure Several researchers have proposed that VMS words are built from ordered positional slots. Zattera 2022 proposed a 12-slot positional structure for Voynich words. Greshko 2025 adapted this into a two-class system of

Read the complete text