Viability of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis in Some Generalized Horizon Entropies
Kajal Phukan, Rajdeep Mazumdar, Kalyan Malakar, Kalyan Bhuyan · 2026
Read Viability of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis in Some Generalized Horizon Entropies by Kajal Phukan, Rajdeep Mazumdar, Kalyan Malakar, Kalyan Bhuyan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-19545.txt.
Introduction
Phukan and colleagues test Big Bang Nucleosynthesis in cosmological models from generalized horizon entropies. Studying shifts in the growth rate, they derive model bounds from freeze-out temperature and helium and deuterium abundances. The freeze-out rule gives the most stringent constraint. Helium and deuterium limits stay steady across all models. Lithium constraints fail, a gap blamed on the well-known lithium problem.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kajal Phukan, Rajdeep Mazumdar, Kalyan Malakar, Kalyan Bhuyan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39620 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.19545
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Viability of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis in Some Generalized Horizon Entropies Kajal Phukan, Rajdeep Mazumdar, Kalyan Malakar, Kalyan Bhuyan Abstract In this work, we investigate the viability of some cosmological models derived from generalized horizon entropies, using Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) constraints. By analyzing the deviations in the expansion rate, we derive bounds on the model parameters from freeze-out temperature, helium, and deuterium abundances. Our results show that the freeze-out condition provides the most stringent constraint, while helium and deuterium bounds remain consistent across all models. Although lithium constraints are not satisfied, this discrepancy is attributed to the well-known cosmological lithium problem. Furthermore, the parameter values required for late-time cosmic acceleration are found to lie well within the BBN bounds, demonstrating consistency between early- and late-Universe behavior. These results establish the viability of the considered models within the framework of BBN. Keywords: Big-Bang Nucleosynthesis, gravity-thermodynamics conjecture, modified entropy theories, entropy modified cosmology I Introduction Ever since the formulation of the laws of black hole mechanics by Bardeen et al. and the subsequent understanding of the Bekenstein–Hawking entropy, a deep and nontrivial connection between gravity and entropy has been recognized bardeen1973 ; bekenstein1973 ; hawking1975 . This connection has been further strengthened by developments such as the holographic principle, black hole complementarity, gauge/gravity duality, and the firewall puzzle, all of which strongly suggest that spacetime dynamics, quantum information, and entropy are intimately related and may play a central role in a comprehensive quantum gravity theory. tHooft1993 ; susskind1995 ; maldacena1999 ; almheiri2013 . Broadly speaking, gravity theories inspired by entanglement and information can be classified into two complementary approaches: holographic gravity and thermodynamic gravity. In the thermodynamic approach, the seminal work of Jacobson demonstrated that the first law of thermodynamics applied to local Rindler horizons can be used to generate Einstein’s field equations, suggesting that fundamental thermodynamic principles may give rise to gravitational dynamics. jacobson1995 . This idea has since been extended in various directions, leading to alternative derivations of gravitational and cosmological field equations based on horizon thermodynamics padmanabhan2005 ; verlinde2011 . An important consequence of the gravity & thermodynamics correspondence is the application of the first rule of thermodynamics to the apparent horizon of Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) spacetime to derive cosmological equations. In this framework, the apparent horizon acts as a causal boundary endowed with temperature and entropy, and the Friedmann equations naturally follow from thermodynamic relations cai2005 ; akbar2006 . This approach has been successfully applied not only within general relativity but also in a wide class of modified gravity theories, providing a unified thermodynamic interpretation of cosmological dynamics sheykhi2018 ; nojiri2017 . On cosmological scales, observations indicate that the homogeneous and isotropic nature of the Universe at greater distances and is currently undergoing an accelerated expansion phase. In the standard cosmological model, this acceleration is attributed to a positive cosmological constant, which acts as dark energy and leads asymptotically to a de Sitter spacetime. An alternative and conceptually appealing description of cosmic acceleration emerges from the thermodynamics of horizons, where modifications to horizon entropy give rise to effective energy components capable of driving both early- and late-time acceleration. Motivated by the long-range nature of gravity and possible quantum gravity effects, several generalized entropy formalisms have been proposed as extensions of the Bekenstein–Hawking entropy. These include Tsallis, Rényi, Barrow, Kaniadakis, Sharma–Mittal entropies, as well as entropy corrections arising from loop quantum gravity tsallis1988 ; renyi1961 ; barrow2020 ; kaniadakis2002 ; sharma1975 ; rovelli1996 . In appropriate limits, these generalized entropies reduce to the standard Bekenstein–Hawking form, while remaining monotonic functions of it. When implemented within horizon thermodynamics, they naturally lead to modified Friedmann equations and entropy-induced dark energy densities. In this context, Tsallis entropy tsallis1988 provides an effective description of non-extensive thermodynamic systems characterized by long-range interactions. Barrow entropy barrow2020 , which is closely related to Tsallis entropy, finds natural applications in quantum gravity scenarios. Rényi entropy is commonly associated with the information-theoretic description of physical systems, while Kaniadakis entropy kaniadakis2002 emerges from relativistic statistical mechanics. The Sharma–Mittal entropy sharma1975 represents a two-parameter generalization that unifies the Rényi and Tsallis entropies. Entropy formulations inspired by loop quantum gravity have also been applied successfully in black hole physics and cosmology. Moreover, recently proposed entropy models have been employed in entropic cosmology and are free from singular behavior at vanishing Hubble rate H=0 kruglov2025a ; kruglov2025b . Other studies of entropies and holographic dark energy models were considered in Refs. jahromi2018 ; ren2021 ; mejrhit2019 ; majhi2017 ; sekhmani2024 ; noorigashti2025 ; sadeghi2014 ; pourhassan2018 . Entropy-modified cosmological models have been widely explored in the context of late-time cosmic acceleration and inflationary dynamics. However, the viability of such models crucially depends on their consistency with early-Universe physics. Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) bbn11 ; bbn12 is one of the most potent and model independent probes of early-Universe physics. The creation of light elements in the early Universe, which took place soon after the Big Bang when the universe was incredibly hot and dense, is known as Big-Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) bbn13 . This epoch spans roughly from about 0.01 seconds to a few hundred seconds (of the order of minutes) after the Big Bang. During this period, the excessive temperatures allowed nuclear reactions to take place, leading to the production of light nuclei such as Helium {}^{4}\mathrm{He} , Deuterium \mathrm{D} , and Lithium {}^{7}\mathrm{Li} . As the Universe expanded and chilled down, these nuclear reactions progressively became inefficient and eventually stopped, leaving behind the primordial abundances of these elements observed today. Both BBN and the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) radiation provide compelling evidence that the early Universe was in a hot and dense state. Following BBN, the Universe underwent several key evolutionary phases, including the radiation-dominated era, the matter-dominated era, and the subsequent formation of large-scale structures. Since even tiny variations in the expansion rate during this period might drastically change the expected abundances of light elements, a cosmological model is considered valid if and only if it meets the strict requirements set by primordial nucleosynthesis. Consequently, Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) has been extensively employed to constrain the parameters of modified gravity and non-standard cosmological models bbna1 ; bbna2 ; bbna3 ; bbna4 ; bbna5 . For instance, Ghoshal and Lambiase bbn14 studied Tsallis cosmology, finding that the Tsallis parameter is tightly constrained ( \beta<2 ) by BBN data, allowing only small deviations from General Relativity. Similarly, Barrow et al. bbn54 used BBN data to constrain the exponent in Barrow entropy models. Different f(T,L_{m}) models were examined in Ref. s1 , and constraints on their free parameters were derived using observational bounds from the freeze-out temperature with the primordial abundances of light elements. In Ref. s2 , Big Bang Nucleosynthesis constraints were studied for dual Kaniadakis cosmology. Furthermore, Ref. s3 investigated constraints on Weyl-type f(Q,T) gravity using Big Bang Nucleosynthesis. In particular, modified cosmological scenarios can alter the predicted primordial abundances of light elements. Although the standard BBN model successfully explains the observed abundances of helium and hydrogen, it encounters difficulties in accounting for lithium, giving rise to the well-known cosmological lithium problem. This discrepancy remains an important issue in contemporary cosmology, motivating investigations into whether modified cosmological models can provide a viable resolution.