Dynamical heterogeneity reverses structural suppression of cooperation

Xiaochen Wang · 2026

Read Dynamical heterogeneity reverses structural suppression of cooperation by Xiaochen Wang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-19436.txt.

Introduction

Wang introduces a new update rule for evolutionary strategy dynamics based on each person's decision information, mixing personal and social inputs. Past work on such systems has focused mainly on structural differences between people, not on how update rules differ. The new rule lets each person vary the weight of personal input and the amount of social input used. Cooperation rises markedly when highly connected people lean more on social input.

Catalog record

CREATORXiaochen Wang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53130
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.19436

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dynamical heterogeneity reverses structural suppression of cooperation Xiaochen Wang Abstract Heterogeneity in individual characteristics and behaviour is a fundamental property of complex dynamical systems. While previous studies on evolutionary dynamics of strategies evolution in various systems have predominantly focused on the structural heterogeneity, dynamical heterogeneity in individuals’ strategy update has been largely neglected. Here, we introduce a novel dynamical update mechanism based on individuals’ decision-making information, comprising personal and social components. This update rule allows each individual to vary in the weight of personal information and the amount of social information, capturing the general scenario of dynamically heterogeneous populations. We find that cooperation, as a collective prosocial outcome, is significantly enhanced when highly connected individuals on interaction network rely more heavily on personal information and access more social information. This effect is notably absent in homogeneous networks, thereby overturning the prevailing consensus that structural heterogeneity inherently suppresses cooperation. This theoretical prediction is further validated by empirical evidence from GitHub collaboration networks. Furthermore, individuals preferentially linking to those who are well-informed and possess greater personal information further promotes collective cooperation. We additionally reveal that cooperators gain a decisive advantage when relying more on personal information compared to defectors, whereas social information affects cooperators and defectors equivalently. Our findings offer profound insights into how dynamical heterogeneity fundamentally shapes the evolution of collective cooperation in complex systems. Introduction Heterogeneity is a ubiquitous feature of many real-world systems, shaping the structure and interactions across diverse domains, from biological ecosystems to social and technological networks [ 19 , 31 , 5 ] . In many complex systems, individuals or components differ in their connectivity, behaviour, or local environment, leading to profound implications for collective dynamics and evolutionary outcomes. A prominent form of heterogeneity arises in the structure of interaction networks themselves [ 4 , 31 ] . Unlike regular lattices or fully connected graphs, real-world networks—such as social networks, neural networks, and ecological food webs—often exhibit heterogeneous degree distributions [ 30 , 26 , 12 , 5 ] , with some nodes being highly connected while others have only a few links. This structural heterogeneity has been shown to significantly influence dynamical processes such as disease spreading, opinion formation, and evolutionary dynamics [ 1 , 21 , 7 ] . Specifically, heterogeneous network structures can significantly influence the evolutionary dynamics of group game interactions, particularly the emergence of group-optimal strategies such as cooperation. In particular, heterogeneous networks have profound implications for evolutionary dynamics [ 25 , 2 , 18 ] , which explains how cooperation emerges in systems. Compared to regular networks, heterogeneous networks can either suppress cooperation [ 2 ] or enable the emergence of influential hubs and stable cooperative clusters [ 25 ] . However, despite numerous studies exploring the effects of heterogeneity on evolutionary dynamics, the existing literature predominantly focuses on network heterogeneity, largely neglecting another critical dimension: dynamical heterogeneity. This heterogeneity refers to the fact that each individual follows a distinct dynamical rule in strategy update. Specifically, in the context of evolutionary dynamics, this means that each individual follows their own unique update rule, which guides how they revise their strategy. Indeed, Most existing studies have focused on a single updating rule, such as death-birth or pairwise comparison [ 22 , 23 , 28 , 2 ] , assuming that differences in individuals’ decision-making processes arise solely from variations in their number of connections (Fig. 1 a). A smaller number of studies have explored systems involving two or three updating rules [ 9 , 27 , 32 ] , including scenarios where updating rules coevolve with strategies, or different update retes [ 20 ] . However, empirical systems are unlikely to be constrained to a limited set of updating mechanisms or variation in update rates. For example, in a celebrities social network [ 4 ] , different individuals have access to varying amounts of information, and their openness to changing strategies also differs, which leads to personalized update mechanisms. Previous studies have largely overlooked this highly prevalent phenomenon. In reality, each individual may possess a unique updating process, highlighting the necessity of considering broader dynamical heterogeneity. Building upon this understanding of individual heterogeneity, recent study on imitation dynamics with incomplete information have opened new avenues for exploring dynamical heterogeneity [ 28 ] . In this model, individuals base their decisions on a combination of personal information and external social information (i.e., information from their neighbors). Individuals can choose to utilize varying portions of social information and adjust the weighting between personal and social information in their decision-making processes. Past studies have mainly focused on homogeneous networks where each individual follows identical dynamical rules, which limits their applicability to a narrow set of scenarios. Here, we focus on scenarios with heterogeneous dynamics(Fig. 1 b), similar to those observed in real-world systems. By allowing individuals to differ in how they process and prioritize information, these models provide a more realistic representation of decision-making processes in complex systems. Here, we introduce an update rule called heterogeneous imitation (HIM), which allows individuals to differ both in the weighting of their personal information and in the amount of social information they utilise (Fig. 1 c). We demonstrate that cooperation is significantly promoted when high-degree nodes (hubs) access more social information and place greater emphasis on personal information—a discovery we empirically validate using GitHub collaboration networks. Moreover, our results reveal that during network formation, individuals preferentially connecting to those who are well-informed and possess greater personal information weights further promotes collective cooperation. Furthermore, when strategies and information coevolve, cooperation is greatly enhanced if cooperators rely more on personal information than defectors, whereas social information affects both types equivalently. Our study offers profound insights into how dynamical heterogeneity fundamentally shapes the evolution of collective cooperation in complex systems. Figure 1: Illustration on heterogeneous evolutionary dynamics. a , Under homogeneous evolutionary dynamics, each individual follows the same decision-making mechanism (illustrated as same coloured Peking opera masks). In the canonical death-birth updating, individual omit their personal information ( \theta=0 ) and take all the neighbours’ information into consideration ( s=d ). b , Under heterogeneous evolutionary dynamics, each individual may follow a distinct decision-making mechanism (illustrated as different coloured Peking opera masks). Owing to their unique characteristics, each individual possesses a specific personal information weight \theta and a particular amount of social information s . c , Under heterogeneous imitation with incomplete social information, each individual obtains information about their neighbours’ strategies and payoffs based on their own amount of social information s , and then makes a decision and thus imitates one of them by weighting this social information against their own experience, according to their personal information weight \theta . Each individual on the network can have its own distinct personal information weight and amount of social information. Model Game and payoff We consider a population of N individuals, where interaction relationships are represented by an undirected and unweighted network. At each time step, individual i interacts with its d_{i} neighbours on the network and receives payoffs from the game. We focus on the donation game, in which each individual chooses to either cooperate (C) or defect (D). Cooperators pay a cost c to provide a benefit b

Read the complete text