An Update on the Isospin-Breaking Effects in the Pion Decay Constant with Staggered Quarks

Davide Giusti · 2026

Read An Update on the Isospin-Breaking Effects in the Pion Decay Constant with Staggered Quarks by Davide Giusti (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-19430.txt.

Introduction

Cotellucci and Giusti present an update from the BMW Collaboration on isospin-breaking effects in the pion decay constant. The computation uses staggered quarks with a near-physical pion mass and a finite-volume quantum electrodynamics setup. The paper updates the isosymmetric value and the current determination used for the gradient-flow scale. It also gives preliminary results for the valence-valence part of the axial-pseudoscalar correlator across volumes and lattice spacings, and discusses next steps.

Catalog record

CREATORDavide Giusti
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE205021
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.19430

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An Update on the Isospin-Breaking Effects in the Pion Decay Constant with Staggered Quarks Davide Giusti Abstract We present an update on the ongoing computation of the isospin-breaking effects in the Pion Decay Constant from the BMW Collaboration. The calculation is carried out with N f =2+1+1 staggered quarks with a near-physical pion mass and QED L {}_{\text{L}} . We give an update on the isosymmetric value and the current determination used to compute the gradient-flow scale w 0 w_{0} , then we present some preliminary results of the valence-valence contribution to the axial-pseudoscalar correlator for different volumes and lattice spacings. We also discuss the next steps and plans. [a]Alessandro Cotellucci 1 Motivations The unitarity of the first row of the CKM matrix is an open problem in precision flavour physics, as shown in Figure 1 from [ 2 ] . At a current level of precision, isospin-breaking effects become relevant. Figure 1: Status of the determination of the V_{ud} and V_{us} elements of the CKM matrix as reported by the Flavour Lattice Averaging Group [ 2 ] . In Isosymmetric QCD the pion decay constant f_{\pi} is defined by the hadronic matrix element: \bra{0}\bar{u}\gamma_{4}\gamma_{5}d\ket{\pi(\vec{0})}=M_{\pi}f_{\pi}. (1) To compute the pion decay constant in QCD+QED F_{\pi} one needs to consider the leptonic decay rate \pi^{+}\rightarrow l^{+}\nu_{l}(\gamma) , in the PDG parametrization it is: F_{\pi}^{2}=\frac{\Gamma_{\pi^{+}\rightarrow l^{+}\nu_{l}(\gamma)}}{\frac{G_{\text{F}}^{2}}{8\pi}|V_{ud}|^{2}M_{\pi}m_{l}^{2}\left(1-\frac{m_{l}^{2}}{M_{\pi}^{2}}\right)^{2}}=f_{\pi}^{2}\left[1+\delta R_{\pi}\right] (2) with \delta R_{\pi} the isospin-breaking correction to the decay constant. The full computation of \delta R_{\pi} requires the renormalization of the electroweak hamiltonian: \mathcal{H}_{W}=\frac{G_{\text{F}}}{\sqrt{2}}V_{ud}^{*}\left[\bar{d}\gamma^{\mu}\left(1-\gamma_{5}\right)u\right]\left[\bar{\nu_{l}}\gamma_{\mu}\left(1-\gamma_{5}\right)l\right]. (3) There is one lattice computation of the isospin-breaking corrections in the pion and kaon decay constants by the RM123-Southampton collaboration [ 7 ] . In the ratio f_{K}/f_{\pi} the renormalization constant cancel (in a massless scheme) so there are more lattice computations of the correction to the latter, from the RM123-Southampton collaboration [ 9 ] , from RBC-UKQCD [ 5 ] and a more recent from RBC-UKQCD with QED ∞ [ 6 ] . The pion decay constant F_{\pi} is used for the scale setting in the BMW/DMZ determination of the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon [ 14 ] . 2 Mixed Determination The isospin-breaking effects in the pion decay constant are computed by combining the work from the RM123-Southampton collaboration [ 7 ] and the BMW results for isosymmetric QCD and the sea quark IBE. The dependency of the pion decay constant in units of w_{0} on the quark electric charge and bare quark masses is parametrized as follows (up to higher order effects): \displaystyle w_{0}F_{\pi}= \displaystyle A+BF_{\pi}^{-2}M_{\pi^{+}}^{2}+CF_{\pi}^{-2}\left(M_{K^{\pm}}^{2}+M_{K^{0}}^{2}-M_{\pi^{\pm}}^{2}\right)/2 (4) \displaystyle+Ee_{v}^{2}+Fe_{v}e_{s}+Ge_{s}^{2} where e_{v} and e_{s} are, respectively, the valence and sea quark charges. The coefficients B and C are mass derivatives and are computed in QCD. The coefficients E , F and G are the valence-valence, sea-valence and sea-sea derivatives. Once all the coefficients in Eq. ( 4 ) are determined, the parametrization can be split into the QCD+seaQED and the valQED part: \left[w_{0}F_{\pi}\right]_{\text{QCD+QED}}=\left[w_{0}F_{\pi}\right]_{\text{QCD+seaQED}}+\left[w_{0}F_{\pi}\right]_{\text{valQED}}, (5) both of the terms on the right-hand side are dependent on the scheme used to define QCD. It is fundamental to remember that w_{0} has not valence quak isopsin-breaking effects so \left[w_{0}F_{\pi}\right]_{\text{valQED}} includes only the valence quark IBE on F_{\pi} . The quantity \left[w_{0}F_{\pi}\right]_{\text{QCD+seaQED}} is determined with the BMW data, but the valence contribution is computed from the RM123-Southampton result 1 1 1 The valence QED contribution to the pion decay rate from Ref. [ 7 ] is given in a GRS scheme in which the quark masses, renormalized at \mu=2 GeV in \overline{\text{MS}} , remain constant as the electromagnetic coupling is turned on or off and the overall lattice scale is fixed using f_{\pi} . In the electroquenched approximation adopted there valence QED corrections do not affect the renormalization of the strong coupling – i.e. the GRS condition [\widehat{g_{s}}]_{\text{QCD}}(\mu)=[\widehat{g_{s}}]_{\text{QCD+valQED}}(\mu) (\ast) , where \ \widehat{}\ indicates the quantities renormalized in the respective theories, holds trivially – and thus do not change the lattice spacing from its pure QCD value at fixed \beta . We stress that in the full QCD+QED calculation presented here the lattice scale is consistently set using F_{\pi} and, since the purely gluonic quantity w_{0} is free of valence QED contributions – viz. a relation similar to (\ast) occurs for w_{0} as well –, it is justified to use the value of \delta R_{\pi} from Ref. [ 7 ] as input in our computation to evaluate the term [w_{0}F_{\pi}]_{\text{QCD+valQED}}/[w_{0}F_{\pi}]_{\text{QCD}} and Eq. ( 8 ) without introducing scheme ambiguities. . To combine the two results, the same scheme has to be employed. The work [ 7 ] is defined in the GRS scheme by the quantities [ 10 ] : \displaystyle\left[M_{\pi}\right]^{\text{GRS}}= \displaystyle 135.0(2)\ \text{MeV} (6) \displaystyle\left[\frac{1}{2}\left(M_{K^{\pm}}+M_{K^{0}}\right)\right]^{\text{GRS}}= \displaystyle 494.6(1)\ \text{MeV} \displaystyle\left[f_{\pi}\right]^{\text{GRS}}= \displaystyle 130.65(12)\ \text{MeV} \displaystyle\left[\delta R_{\pi}\right]^{\text{GRS}}= \displaystyle 0.0153(19). Since they were working in the electroquenched approximation, which neglects the sea quark IBE, the QCD result includes the sea quark isospin-breaking effects following: \left[*\right]^{\text{GRS}}=\left[*\right]_{\text{QCD+QED}}^{\text{phys}}-\left[*\right]_{\text{valQED}}^{\text{GRS}}=\left[*\right]^{\text{GRS}}_{\text{QCD+seaQED}}. (7) Using the parametrization ( 4 ), the identity ( 7 ) can be used to evaluate \left[w_{0}F_{\pi}\right]^{\text{GRS}}_{\text{QCD+seaQED}} which can then be combined with the RM123S results using the relation, up to negligible O\left(\alpha_{\text{em}}^{2}\right) corrections: \left[w_{0}F_{\pi}\right]_{\text{QCD+QED}}=\left[w_{0}F_{\pi}\right]_{\text{QCD+seaQED}}^{\text{GRS}}\sqrt{1+\left[\delta R_{\pi}\right]^{\text{GRS}}}. (8) 3 Isosymmetric QCD value in the FLAG scheme The isosymmetric QCD value of w_{0}f_{\pi} is computed using the ensembles of the BMW collaboration shown in Figure 2 with QCD tree-level Symanzik action for the gauge field and N f =2+1+1 Staggered fermions coupled with 4 levels of stout smearing with radius \rho=0.125 . The decay constant is computed from the pseudoscalar two-point function through the chiral WTI. Figure 2: Landscape of the ensembles used for the isoQCD determination of w_{0}f_{\pi} around the physical point from [ 14 ] . The analysis follows the strategy presented in [ 3 ] . To have a better control over the continuum extrapolation we add the determination of w_{0} using the Zeuthen-flow [ 13 ] in addition to the Wilson-flow [ 12 ] , Figure 3 shows the continum extrapolation of w_{0}f_{\pi} in the lattice spacing and in the taste-breaking term and the relative probability distribution function of both the statistical and sistematic effect. The result is presented in the FLAG scheme [ 1 ] . Figure 3: Continuum limit extrapolation of the iso QCD value of w_{0}f_{\pi} . The upper plot represents the continuum extrapolation both in the lattice spacing and in the taste-symmetry breaking terms \Delta_{KS} (computed by comparing the masses of different meson tastes on our ensembles); in the lower plot the probability distribution function (PDF) including both statistical and systematic variations is shown in red. Table 1 shows the breakdown of the total error on w_{0}f_{\pi} . The uncertainty is dominated by the systematic error and, in particular, the biggest contribution is represented by the continuum extrapolation under the entries: Type of gradient flow , Lattice spacing cuts and Order of fit polynomials . To improve the determination, we are generating data at a finer value of the lattice spacing. Other sources of systematic error listed are: Pseudoscalar fits (effects of the fit range of the effective pion decay constant) and Finite volume \chi PT order (the difference in the finite volume effects between NLO and NNLO \chi PT). Median 0.11438 Total error 0.00026 0.22736 % Statistical error 0.00012 0.10786 %

Read the complete text