Comparison of model order reduction techniques with one-shot procedure for topology optimization for thermal applications
Luis Fernando Cusicanqui Lopez, Ramadan Krasniqi, Florian Feppon, Karl Meerbergen · 2026
Read Comparison of model order reduction techniques with one-shot procedure for topology optimization for thermal applications by Luis Fernando Cusicanqui Lopez, Ramadan Krasniqi, Florian Feppon, Karl Meerbergen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-19268.txt.
Introduction
Cusicanqui Lopez and colleagues compare model order reduction techniques with a one-shot procedure for speeding up thermal topology optimization. They project the governing and adjoint equations onto low-dimensional bases built from snapshots of earlier design iterations. Those snapshots come from high-fidelity solves or fast one-shot solves. Choosing the iterative solver stopping rule carefully proves crucial. In a 3D example, total time falls by up to a factor of 3 with high-fidelity solves and up to 16 with one-shot solves.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Luis Fernando Cusicanqui Lopez, Ramadan Krasniqi, Florian Feppon, Karl Meerbergen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53137 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.19268
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparison of model order reduction techniques with one-shot procedure for topology optimization for thermal applications Luis Fernando Cusicanqui Lopez, Ramadan Krasniqi, Florian Feppon, Karl Meerbergen Abstract Density-based topology optimization has become a powerful method for automatically generating optimized designs in a wide variety of applications. However, it comes with a large computational cost when solving the physical model requires large-scale simulations. Here, we investigate the use of model order reduction (MOR) techniques to accelerate the simulations in the context of thermal design applications. We project the governing and the adjoint equations onto a low-dimensional subspace by constructing two distinct reduced bases—one for the forward state and one for the adjoint system—using solution snapshots from previous design iterations. These snapshots are generated using either the high-fidelity solver or inaccurate fast solvers, such as the one-shot method ( 5 ) . Additionally, we demonstrate that properly selecting the stopping criterion for the iterative linear solver is crucial for the effective use of reduced models. In our 3D example, the proposed framework reduces the overall total simulation time relative to the high-fidelity workflow by a factor up to 3 3 when combined with high-fidelity solves and a factor up to 16 16 when combined with the one-shot method. Moreover, we find that the reduced order model approach is able to achieve a speed up of 1.54 1.54 with respect to the one-shot method. Keywords: Model order reduction, topology optimization, one-shot method 1 Introduction Topology Optimization (TO) is a powerful numerical method that enables the automatic generation of optimized designs for a given objective ( 8 ) . It is an iterative design process that involves solving equations that model the underlying physics at each iteration. However, this task is computationally expensive for three-dimensional, large-scale applications, as it requires solving large linear systems ( 3 ; 19 ; 2 ; 4 ) . Consequently, the solution process often becomes the bottleneck of the overall design cycle. Therefore, reducing the computational cost associated with simulating these large linear systems is critical to speeding up the entire design process. Several approaches have been explored to address this bottleneck. These include high performance parallel computing ( 2 ; 1 ) , reducing the number of design variables ( 14 ) and reducing the number of solver iterations by using an efficient preconditioner as in ( 3 ) or applying subspace recycling techniques ( 10 ; 21 ; 26 ) . The cost associated with the simulations is dominated by the cost of solving the resulting large linear systems during the design process. These linear systems are obtained by discretizing the governing equations, where the design variable is typically embedded in the material properties. As the optimization progresses, the change in these design variables becomes smaller, leading to small differences between consecutive linear systems. This can be exploited by numerical methods to reduce the computational costs incurred by solving large-scale linear systems. A promising approach is projection-based model order reduction that builds a reduced basis to project the large-scale linear system onto a low dimensional system and generate approximate solutions. This basis is typically built using solutions corresponding to previous optimization steps during the design process. In topology optimization, this approach has been initially followed by ( 13 ; 27 ) that used Gram-Schmidt and POD to build the basis and applied model order reduction to the forward equation for a minimal compliance structural problem, however the methodology is limited to self adjoint problems. ( 10 ) developed a model order reduction framework that can also be applied for non self-adjoint optimization problems. However, the incremental algorithm used to update the bases fails to correctly recover the desired subspace once the maximum number of basis vectors is reached. This incremental approach orthogonalizes new snapshots with respect to the present basis vectors from previous iterations. Once the maximum basis size is reached, the algorithm removes the oldest orthogonalized basis vector and orthogonalizes the new incoming snapshot against the remaining basis vectors. Subsequent basis vectors were originally orthogonalized against this discarded vector; therefore, information from the original snapshots that was present in the removed vector is permanently lost. Consequently, the remaining basis can no longer accurately reconstruct the desired subspace, i.e., the original snapshots. ( 22 ) applied a dual reduction, where the forward and the adjoint equations were reduced separately with a different basis, to speedup the design process for a time-dependent structural optimization problem. An alternative strategy to mitigate computational costs involves solving the state equations inaccurately to reduce the number of solver iterations needed at each optimization step. For instance, ( 4 ) solves the state equations inaccurately by dynamically adjusting the residual threshold of the iterative solver over the course of the optimization. More recently, in ( 5 ) , the authors used a one-shot procedure for a minimum compliance structural problem. In this context, one-shot means a single iteration of the conjugate gradient method. This resulted in large speedups without jeopardizing the quality of the final design. There is a conflict between computational speed and simulation accuracy achieved by these methods. This trade-off is governed by the linear solver’s stopping criterion. If the criterion is too soft, the result may be inaccurate and lead to bad results; if it is too stringent, speedup is lost. Furthermore, we identify that the standard choice of stopping criterion for conjugate gradient (CG) is too strict when applied to the adjoint equation leading to a large number of solver iterations or an inefficient use of the reduced model. To the best of our knowledge, alternative ways of computing the residual norms have not been studied before in the context of topology optimization. Therefore, based on results from ( 7 ; 6 ) , we propose an alternative residual norm as stopping criterion that leads to a more effective use of the reduced models. In this paper, we investigate the use of MOR to mitigate the computational cost of simulations in the context of topology optimization for heat conduction problems. More specifically, we reduce the forward and the adjoint equation separately with their own corresponding bases, which are constructed using converged solutions from high-fidelity solvers and inaccurate solutions from the one-shot method. First, we propose a Gram-Schmidt based incremental algorithm to correctly recover the desired subspace when removing ‘old’ vectors from the basis once its maximum dimension is reached. Second, we propose an alternative stopping criterion from ( 7 ; 6 ) which leads to a more uniform use of the forward and adjoint reduced models improving the overall performance. Finally, we notice that the computational cost of a full multigrid precondition step at every design iteration is still higher than one model order reduction (MOR) step. Therefore, we investigate whether MOR bases constructed from these inaccurate one-shot solutions are robust enough to achieve a qualitative design. This combination allows us to exploit the low computational cost of MOR and the efficiency of the one-shot method. The one-shot method ( 5 ) already gives a speedup of 10 for the problem considered. In combination with MOR, an additional speedup of 1.53 can be achieved. This article is organized as follows: Section 2 introduces the necessary background on topology optimization for