Diffusion Synthetic Acceleration for polytopal discretisations of Boltzmann transport

Ansar Calloo 1 , Matthew Evans 2∗ , François Madiot 3 , Tristan Pryer 2,4 · 2026

Read Diffusion Synthetic Acceleration for polytopal discretisations of Boltzmann transport by Ansar Calloo 1 , Matthew Evans 2∗ , François Madiot 3 , Tristan Pryer 2,4 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-18771.txt.

Introduction

Calloo and three colleagues study diffusion synthetic acceleration for transport equations on polytopic meshes. They use a discontinuous Galerkin method with a discrete angle scheme, building the correction from an interior penalty operator. Two forms are compared, a standard SIP form and an MIP variant, under Dirichlet and Marshak boundary conditions. MIP stays robust across the tested ranges, while SIP can lose robustness in the middle regime. The team ran many tests and checked speed in each case.

Catalog record

CREATORAnsar Calloo 1 , Matthew Evans 2∗ , François Madiot 3 , Tristan Pryer 2,4
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE84075
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.18771

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Diffusion Synthetic Acceleration for polytopal discretisations of Boltzmann transport Ansar Calloo 1 , Matthew Evans 2∗ , François Madiot 3 , Tristan Pryer 2,4 Abstract . We present a computational study of diffusion synthetic acceleration (DSA) for the monoenergetic, isotropically scattering S N S_{N} transport equations, discretised in space by a polytopic discontinuous Galerkin method. Using a discrete ordinates angular discretisation, we construct the DSA correction with an interior-penalty diffusion operator and compare a classical symmetric interior penalty (SIP) formulation with a modified interior penalty (MIP) variant, together with homogeneous Dirichlet and Marshak (Robin) diffusion boundary conditions imposed weakly in the DG framework. We quantify the observed convergence behaviour of the resulting source iteration across variations in optical thickness, scattering ratio, angular quadrature, mesh refinement, polynomial degree and mesh anisotropy on families of bounded Voronoi meshes. The results show that MIP-based DSA remains robust across the parameter ranges tested, whereas SIP-based DSA can lose robustness in the intermediate regime. In challenging optically thick, highly scattering settings, the observed convergence factors for the MIP-based schemes are typically below 0.6 0.6 . 1. Introduction Transport models based on the linear Boltzmann transport equation (BTE) sit at the core of three application areas that drive both the modelling choices and the computational constraints in this paper, nuclear engineering (reactor physics, criticality support calculations and shielding), medical physics (in particular radiotherapy dose and optimisation workflows) and space technologies (space radiation transport for shielding design and crew risk assessment). Deterministic discrete ordinates ( S_{N} ) solvers remain a mainstay in these settings, both as production tools and as components inside hybrid workflows, for example in large-scale shielding calculations and reactor analysis [ 17 ] . In radiotherapy, there is renewed interest in fast deterministic transport surrogates for dose calculation and optimisation loops, including proton-specific transport modelling pipelines [ 4 ] . The discrete ordinates method (DOM) is a standard approach to semi-discretise the BTE by approximating its angular dependence with a quadrature rule, yielding a coupled system of spatial equations (the S_{N} equations). Given the scale of these systems, iterative methods with preconditioning are required. One widely adopted scheme is source iteration, a Richardson iteration that avoids full inversion by isolating the transport operator, which can be inverted efficiently by a sweep, either directly or in a matrix-free manner. Source iteration performs well in many settings but deteriorates in diffusive regimes such as moderators, reflectors and shielding problems. In highly scattering and optically thick settings the contraction factor approaches unity, leading to slow convergence or pseudo-convergence. Under standard absorption assumptions, source iteration is contractive, but in highly scattering and optically thick regimes its convergence factor can be arbitrarily close to one, making acceleration essential [ 1 ] . Acceleration strategies for the BTE are often grouped into synthetic methods, which preserve the discrete fixed point through an additive correction, and other acceleration strategies, which may improve convergence without corresponding exactly to a fixed-point-preserving preconditioner. Examples include transport synthetic acceleration [ 34 ] and quasi-diffusion acceleration [ 19 ] . Synthetic methods approximate the inverse of the full transport system and yield a preconditioned fixed-point iteration via an additive correction. A particularly effective option in diffusive regimes is diffusion synthetic acceleration (DSA) [ 3 ] . DSA can deliver mesh- and thickness-robust convergence, but only when the diffusion correction is discretised in a way that is compatible with the transport discretisation. For discontinuous Galerkin (DG) transport discretisations with upwind numerical fluxes, the dominant discrete dissipation in thick regimes is delivered facewise by the upwind jump terms. A diffusion correction based on a symmetric interior penalty (SIP) DG discretisation is elliptically coercive, but elliptic coercivity alone does not guarantee effective acceleration. On some meshes or for some quadrature–mesh alignments the SIP jump control can be weaker than the dissipation delivered by the upwind transport flux, which degrades or stalls or even destabilises the accelerated iteration. This motivates penalty choices that explicitly match, face by face, the transport dissipation scale while retaining elliptic stability of the diffusion solve. A companion analytic paper [ 10 ] develops this perspective and provides contraction estimates for transport-matched penalty choices. Polytopic DGFEMs are attractive for transport because they support high-order approximation, flexible treatment of complex geometries and a rigorous approximation theory [ 13 ] . Although DG methods introduce additional face terms, the ability to work on agglomerated or general polytopic meshes (for example, Voronoi tessellations) can reduce element counts in smooth regions or geometrically complex settings, while retaining parallel scalability in transport sweeps. Recent work has also clarified when such meshes admit robust sweep constructions [ 9 ] . Despite these advantages, DSA-based preconditioning for polytopic DGFEMs remains relatively unexplored, particularly from the standpoint of quantifying how penalty choices, hp -refinement, quadrature and mesh anisotropy affect the contraction factor. This computational study explores diffusion synthetic acceleration for the monoenergetic, isotropically scattering S_{N} transport equations discretised in space by a polytopic discontinuous Galerkin method. The present paper accompanies the companion paper [ 10 ] , which focusses on the analytic perspective, establishes discrete contraction bounds and motivates transport-matched penalty choices. We implement DSA in the same discontinuous polynomial space and on the same mesh as the transport discretisation, and we focus on interior-penalty diffusion operators with weakly imposed boundary conditions. In particular, we compare a classical symmetric interior penalty (SIP) diffusion discretisation with a modified interior penalty (MIP) variant. The MIP idea is well established in the DSA literature for DG S_{N} discretisations on simplicial and Cartesian meshes [ 43 , 33 ] , where it is used to prevent loss of robustness in optically thick and highly scattering regimes. Our focus is not novelty of MIP per se, but rather a systematic investigation of its behaviour in a modern polytopic DG setting, where facet geometry, local anisotropy and quadrature–mesh interactions can substantially affect penalty scaling and sweep performance. To the best of our knowledge, this has not been explored in a dedicated empirical study on general polytopic meshes. We also examine the role of the diffusion boundary model by comparing a strong vacuum surrogate (homogeneous Dirichlet) with a Marshak (Robin) condition motivated by the diffusion limit of vacuum inflow. We quantify how the empirical contraction factor depends on the key parameters that control difficulty in the diffusive regime. This includes the angular quadrature (choice of S_{N} rule), polynomial degree p , scattering ratio and mesh refinement on families of bounded Voronoi meshes. We also study the effect of element anisotropy, including regimes in which interior-penalty schemes can under-penalise because facets are small relative to element diameter. We report its impact on observed convergence factors, iteration counts and wall-clock time. We report the impact of aspect ratio on the observed contraction factor and, within a fixed direct-solve implementation, on practical performance metrics including iteration counts and wall-clock time. To isolate outer-iteration behaviour from differences in inner linear-solver technology, we use direct sparse solves for both transport and diffusion throughout the reported experiments. DG spatial discretisations have been used for discrete ordinates ( S_{N} ) transport since the earliest triangular-mesh formulations, with supporting analysis developed soon afterwards [ 35 , 27 ] . Subsequent work extended these ideas to three-dimensional unstructured settings and

Read the complete text