From Business Problems to AI Solutions: Where Does Transformation Support Fail?

Abir Trabelsi 1 , Imen Benzarti 1 , Hafedh Mili 2 , Darine Ameyed 3 · 2026

Read From Business Problems to AI Solutions: Where Does Transformation Support Fail? by Abir Trabelsi 1 , Imen Benzarti 1 , Hafedh Mili 2 , Darine Ameyed 3 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-18770.txt.

Introduction

Trabelsi and three colleagues review 18 approaches for turning business problems into well-defined machine-learning tools, covering requirements engineering, project management, and automation. They sort the methods into four families and compare them on inputs, outputs, and a seven-stage plan. Most list task or algorithm specs among expected outputs, yet only four give partial help in deriving it and none gives systematic help. The authors name this gap the Analytics Translation Problem and offer five recommendations.

Catalog record

CREATORAbir Trabelsi 1 , Imen Benzarti 1 , Hafedh Mili 2 , Darine Ameyed 3
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59559
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.18770

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

From Business Problems to AI Solutions: Where Does Transformation Support Fail? Abir Trabelsi 1 , Imen Benzarti 1 , Hafedh Mili 2 , Darine Ameyed 3 Abstract Translating business problems into well-specified machine learning solutions is a prerequisite for successful AI systems, yet this upstream translation is still one of the least supported steps in existing methodologies. We conduct a structured narrative literature review of 18 approaches spanning requirements engineering (RE), machine learning (ML) project management, and automation. We organize these approaches into a taxonomy of four families and compare them across six input artifact categories, six output artifact categories, and a transformation framework of seven stages, grounded in RE refinement theory and ML lifecycle process. Our study shows that most approaches list ML task or algorithm specification among their expected outputs, yet only four provide partial guidance for deriving it, and none provides systematic guidance. We characterize this gap as the Analytics Translation Problem (ATP) and derive five research recommendations addressing multi-formulation exploration, task derivation guidance, constraint-algorithm filtering, probabilistic traceability, and data-triggered revision. These findings outline a focused research agenda for the translation step largely left to practitioner intuition. I Introduction AI projects fail at rates estimated to be twice those of conventional IT projects [ 43 ] . Misalignment between the business problem stakeholders intend to solve and the technical formulation delivered to data science teams has been identified as a recurring root cause through interviews with 65 practitioners [ 43 ] . When stakeholders express a need such as ”reduce customer churn” or ”detect fraudulent transactions”, data science teams must determine what machine learning (ML) task to formulate (e.g., classification, survival analysis, clustering), which data to collect, and which metrics operationalize success. This upstream translation from business problem (BP) to ML solution specification (MLS) is still mostly ad hoc, reliant on individual expertise, and weakly supported by existing methodologies. As a result, teams may construct technically sound models that do not address the intended business objective, or spend extended periods iterating on problem formulation before modeling begins [ 42 , 17 ] . This challenge is, at its core, a requirements engineering (RE) problem. The steps of eliciting stakeholder needs, specifying system requirements, ensuring problem-solution alignment, and validating that solutions address original needs are central concerns of RE research [ 54 , 20 , 29 ] . Yet, the BP \rightarrow MLS transformation differs from traditional RE in a fundamental way. Such transformation requires cross-domain derivation , translating business characterizations expressed in the language of goals, decisions, and constraints into statistical and algorithmic constructs (ML paradigms, task types, evaluation metrics) that have no semantic correspondence in the original problem statement. This is what sets the problem apart from classical goal-to-requirement refinement [ 54 , 20 ] , and it goes a long way toward explaining why neither traditional RE methods nor data science process models have managed to support it systematically. Recent RE research addressed AI-specific concerns, including requirements for ML-enabled systems [ 13 , 1 ] , non-functional requirements for ML [ 21 ] , and development challenges for AI-intense systems [ 17 ] . In parallel, the data science community has developed lifecycle models such as CRISP-DM [ 31 , 28 ] , MLOps frameworks [ 27 ] , RE-inspired approaches (GR4ML [ 33 ] , RE4HCAI [ 2 ] ), and automation-oriented approaches that address algorithm selection downstream [ 30 ] . Still, these efforts are fragmented and, as we demonstrate, provide little systematic guidance for deriving the ML task from business characterizations. To address this fragmentation, we conduct a narrative literature review examining how 18 existing approaches, spanning requirements engineering, data science project management, and automation, support the BP \rightarrow MLS transformation. We analyze these approaches through a common analytical view (input/output artifacts, transformation mechanisms, and stage coverage) to identify where support exists, where it fails, and what a transformation framework would need to provide. In this paper, we first propose a four-family taxonomy that organizes 18 BP \rightarrow AI transformation approaches from fragmented research streams into a coherent landscape (Section IV ). Second, we provide a comparative artifact- and stage-based analysis revealing the limitations in existing transformation mechanisms (Section V ). Third, we characterize the Analytics Translation Problem (ATP) as the absence of explicit, traceable, and operationalizable mappings between business characterizations and ML formulations (Section VI ). Fourth, we derive five evidence-based recommendations (R1–R5) specifying what future transformation frameworks should provide to address the gaps (Section VI ). This work positions the BP→MLS transformation as a distinct RE research problem and aims to move the translation step from practitioner intuition toward principled, traceable refinement mechanisms. II Background This section defines key terms: Business Problem (BP). We define a BP as a measurable gap an organization seeks to close, characterized by four elements: strategic objectives , decision needs that stakeholders want to support with data-driven insights, performance gaps between current and target indicators, and constraints (budget, timeline, regulatory, ethical, technical) [ 22 , 54 , 19 , 5 ] . BPs are multi-causal and articulated at varying abstraction levels, consequently, they require progressive refinement to achieve addressable formulations [ 44 ] . ML Solution Specification (MLS). We define an MLS as the specification bridging business requirements and ML implementation. An MLS comprises the ML paradigm (supervised, unsupervised, reinforcement, or hybrid), the task type (classification, regression, clustering, anomaly detection, etc.), data requirements , constraint operationalization (e.g., “explainable” \rightarrow interpretability requirements), evaluation criteria aligned with business thresholds, and operational context [ 15 , 42 ] . Transformation. We define transformation as deriving a specified MLS from a characterized BP such that the MLS addresses the BP, the conceptual link is explicit and traceable, and stakeholders can validate that the intent has been captured. III Review Methodology This section presents the research design of our review, covering the research questions, search strategy, data extraction, and analysis framework. III-A Research Questions Our review is guided by four research questions that progressively characterize the BP \rightarrow MLS transformation landscape: • RQ1: How can existing BP \rightarrow MLS approaches be organized by methodological orientation? • RQ2: What problem-space and solution-space artifacts do these approaches consume and produce? • RQ3: What types of transformation mechanisms do these approaches employ? • RQ4: Which transformation stages receive systematic support, and where do approaches fail to specify how to derive outputs from inputs? III-B Review Design and Search Strategy We adopt a narrative literature review methodology [ 14 ] , appropriate for synthesizing diverse research streams and identifying conceptual gaps across heterogeneous approaches. A systematic review [ 25 ] was not feasible here because our corpus spans multiple fields, requirements engineering, data science, and automation that use incompatible terminologies and contribution types, making uniform quality scoring and quantitative aggregation impractical. The structured extraction schema and classification procedures we employ are intended to enhance transparency and support the replicability of our analysis, rather than to achieve the inferential validity of an SLR. We made the complete extraction data publicly available. We searched five digital libraries (IEEE Xplore, ACM Digital Library, Springer Link, ScienceDirect, arXiv) and targeted venues spanning RE and data science communities. The search combined terms across three domains problem (”business problem”, ”business

Read the complete text