Binary Evolution Can Mimic the Pair-Instability Mass Gap in Black Hole Mergers
Aleksandra Olejak · 2026
Read Binary Evolution Can Mimic the Pair-Instability Mass Gap in Black Hole Mergers by Aleksandra Olejak (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-18676.txt.
Introduction
Olejak and Stegmann ask whether mass flow in binaries can fake signs of the pair-instability limit in black hole masses. A flip in mass ratio at the first Roche-lobe spill, then a wasteful second flow, caps the first-born hole's mass and makes a cutoff. Accretion in the first flow lifts the heavier hole's top mass, while the lighter hole stays capped at the stripped first star's mass. So systems where the lighter hole tops 45 solar masses stay rare, under one in ten thousand in base models.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aleksandra Olejak |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22848 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.18676
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Binary Evolution Can Mimic the Pair-Instability Mass Gap in Black Hole Mergers Aleksandra Olejak Abstract Context. The recent O4a release from the LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA collaboration, which significantly increased the number of gravitational-wave (GW) detections, reveals features with potentially important astrophysical implications. One notable example is a hint of the so-called pair-instability mass gap. In particular, the observed decline in the number of black holes (BHs) with mass above ∼ 45 M ⊙ \sim 45\,M_{\odot} , together with indications of possibly higher spins for BHs above this threshold, has been interpreted by Antonini et al. and Tong et al. as evidence for pair-instability supernovae. Aims. In this work, we investigate whether mass transfer in binary systems can produce BH components’ mass distribution that mimics the pair-instability limit. Methods. We use both the population synthesis code StarTrack and a simple semi-analytical framework to highlight the impact of mass transfer efficiency on the BH masses. Results. We find that efficient mass transfer ( ≳ 50 % \gtrsim 50\% ) during the first Roche-lobe overflow, followed by a highly non-conservative second mass-transfer phase, naturally limits the mass of the first-born BH and produces a cutoff that mimics a mass gap. While the upper mass limit for the more massive BH is increased through accretion during the first mass-transfer phase and is ultimately set by the pair-instability limit, the less massive BH is limited to the stripped primary mass. As a result, the fraction of systems in which the less massive BH exceeds ∼ 45 M ⊙ \sim 45\,M_{\odot} is negligible, below 10 − 5 10^{-5} in our default model. Conclusions. While the pair-instability mass gap is a plausible interpretation of current GW data, similar features can naturally arise from binary evolution. Future detections will help distinguish between these scenarios. In particular, a predominance of positive effective spins or low-spin events within the gap would challenge the pair-instability interpretation and instead support a binary-interaction origin for high-mass BHs. 1 Introduction More than 200 binary black hole (BBH) mergers have so far been publicly announced by the LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA (LVK) collaboration ( 52 ) with the first part of the ongoing O4 observing run. Analyses of the properties of these systems, such as mass and spin distributions of compact objects, reveal encoded information about their formation channels ( 54 ) . The ultimate goal is to distinguish the relative contributions of various formation environments of detected GW systems which might be isolated field evolution of binaries ( 11 ; 8 ; 36 ; 37 ; 14 ; 57 ; 31 , e.g.,) or higher multiples systems ( 3 ; 20 ; 50 ; 49 , e.g.,) as well as globular clusters or galactic nuclei ( 3 ; 5 ; 46 ; 35 , e.g.,) . Some recent analysis suggest the current GW population could constitute of several subpopulations characterized by distinguished features ( 55 ; 45 ; 34 ) which could point towards contribution of various formation channels. It has been predicted since decades that the mass distribution of stellar-origin BHs should exhibit a gap caused by so-called pair-instability supernovae (PSN), originally expected to lie between around 50 and 130\,M_{\odot} ( 25 ; 29 ; 60 ; 9 ) . The exact boundaries of this mass gap, however, remain highly uncertain, as they depend sensitively on factors such as the poorly constrained 12 C( \alpha,\gamma ) 16 O reaction rate. As a result, the lower edge of the gap may vary from \sim 35 to even \sim 90\,M_{\odot} , while the upper edge may range from \sim 130 to \sim 180\,M_{\odot} ( 22 ; 17 ; 21 ) . Nevertheless, this mechanism is expected to limit formation of massive BHs formed through single stellar evolution above the uncertain threshold. Therefore, if PSN operates, the detected population of merging BBHs should exhibit a clearly distinguishable imprint of this mechanism in their mass distribution ( 9 ) . Among GW detections, there are mergers with BH components confidently lying within the expected PSN mass gap, such as GW190521 ( 1 ) and the more recent cases of GW231028 and GW231005 ( 53 ) . However, those detections do not necessarily yet challenge PSN theory, as they could have a hierarchical origin ( 35 ; 28 ) . In particular, they might be the products of previous BBH merger that subsequently paired in dense stellar environments, such as globular clusters with another BH. BHs that formed through such successive mergers, the so-called second-generation BBH mergers, are expected to be characterized by high spins, with individual spin magnitudes peaking around \sim 0.7 ( 27 ; 28 ) . Unfortunately, the individual spin magnitudes of BHs inferred from GW data carry large uncertainties ( 59 ) , making it difficult to confidently confirm or rule out a second‑generation origin based on their values. Recent analyses of GW data by 4 finds support for a transition in the spin distribution of BHs associated with a high mass threshold of \sim 40\,M_{\odot} . In particular, the effective spins 1 1 1 Effective spin \chi_{\rm eff}=\frac{\chi_{1}\cos\theta_{1}+q,\chi_{2}\cos\theta_{2}}{1+q}, where \chi_{1(2)} and \theta_{1(2)} are the component spin magnitudes and tilt angles, respectively, and 0<q\leq 1 is the binary mass ratio ( 18 ) . of the massive BHs within the apparent PSN mass‑gap region appear systematically higher than those of the lower‑mass BH subpopulation. Moreover, 56 shows that when the mass distributions of the more massive and less massive BH components are reconstructed separately, the distribution of the lower-mass component reveals a gap starting at \sim 45\,M_{\odot} . Such features may indicate that BHs with masses above this transition are predominantly second-generation merger remnants. Taken together, these results can be interpreted as evidence for the PSN mass gap, with the lower edge estimated at 45.3^{+6.5}_{-4.8}\,M_{\odot} ( 4 ) and 45^{+5}_{-4}\,M_{\odot} ( 56 ) with 90% credibility. If this PSN edge is real, it provides constraints on the uncertain reaction rates and particle physics in very massive stellar cores ( 22 ; 17 ; 21 ; 24 ) . While the interpretation of GW data with a PSN mass gap at \sim 45\,M_{\odot} is promising, we explore and highlight an alternative explanation. In particular, we demonstrate that binary evolution involving stable mass transfer alone can produce a sharp cutoff in the lower-mass BH component around \sim 45\,M_{\odot} , even if the true PSN limit lies much higher. Finally, we discuss how future detections of massive BBH mergers could help distinguish our scenario from the PSN mass gap at \sim 45\,M_{\odot} proposed by 4 and 56 . 2 Evolutionary scenario mimicking PSN mass gap Figure 1 : An evolutionary pathway for BBH mergers in which mass-transfer physics leads to a lower-mass first-born BH and a cutoff mimicking the presence of the PSN mass gap. Figure 1 illustrates a schematic formation pathway for merging BBH systems that produce cutoff in less massive BH mass distribution, thereby mimicking the presence of a PSN mass gap. The initially more massive star expands first and initiates the first mass transfer phase. This phase must be relatively efficient, with more than \sim 50\% of the transferred mass accreted by the initially less massive companion. As a result, the accretor gains a significant fraction of