Position: No Retroactive Cure for Infringement during Training
Satoru Utsunomiya, Masaru Isonuma, Junichiro Mori, Ichiro Sakata · 2026
Read Position: No Retroactive Cure for Infringement during Training by Satoru Utsunomiya, Masaru Isonuma, Junichiro Mori, Ichiro Sakata (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-18649.txt.
Introduction
Utsunomiya and three colleagues say after-the-fact fixes cannot wipe away liability from unlawful capture and training, since compliance turns on data history, not outputs. First, copying and intake without leave can break the law, and weights can act as fixed copies holding training value. Second, contract, tort, and unfair-competition rules can curb access and use. Third, since guarded-input value can linger in weights, stripping gains may reach the model itself. They urge a move from after-the-fact cleanup to upfront checked compliance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Satoru Utsunomiya, Masaru Isonuma, Junichiro Mori, Ichiro Sakata |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45740 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.18649
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Position: No Retroactive Cure for Infringement during Training Satoru Utsunomiya, Masaru Isonuma, Junichiro Mori, Ichiro Sakata Abstract As generative AI faces intensifying legal challenges, the machine learning community has increasingly relied on post-hoc mitigation —especially machine unlearning and inference-time guardrails—to argue for compliance. This paper argues that such post-hoc mitigation methods cannot retroactively cure liability from unlawful acquisition and training, because compliance hinges on data lineage, not the outputs. Our argument has three parts. First, unauthorized copying/ingestion can be a legally complete completed act , and model weights may operate as fixed copies that retain training-derived expressive value, making later filtering beside the point for infringement. Second, contract and tort/unfair-competition rules—via licenses, terms of service, and anti-free-riding principles—can independently restrict access and use, often bypassing copyright defenses (e.g., fair use or TDM exceptions). Third, since value from protected inputs can persist in weights, remedies such as unjust enrichment and disgorgement may require stripping gains and, in some cases, reaching the model itself. We therefore argue for a shift from Post-Hoc Sanitization to verifiable Ex-Ante Process Compliance . 1 Introduction The rapid rise of modern foundation models has been enabled by what we might call the data ingestion paradigm: training on unprecedented volumes of text and images drawn from across the open web ( 7 ; 5 ) . But since these datasets are so large, it has become technically and economically unrealistic to identify and remove every instance of harmful material or protected content before training (i.e., ex-ante filtering). As a result, many developers have proceeded with large-scale training on broadly collected data and have often defended this practice under the banner of fair use. This approach has triggered serious legal challenges that now threaten the foundations of the AI development ecosystem. Allegations include copyright infringement, privacy violations, and breaches of licensing terms. Rights holders have responded forcefully, arguing that training on protected works and sensitive personal data without authorization is unlawful. High-profile lawsuits—including The New York Times v. OpenAI ( 43 ) and Getty Images v. Stability AI ( 16 ) —have brought these issues into sharp focus. Importantly, these disputes are not limited to whether model outputs resemble protected works. They also raise broader questions about legal liability for the acts of copying, storing, and using protected or personal data during the training process itself. In this sense, the litigation risk concerns not merely product behavior, but the viability of model development as such. Against this backdrop—where ex-ante filtering is infeasible and legal pressure is increasing—the research community and industry have increasingly turned toward post-hoc mitigation strategies, namely interventions applied after a model has already been trained. For instance, some generative AIs have introduced opt-out mechanisms intended to prevent the generation of specific copyrighted content, and academic interest in machine unlearning has grown as a technique for removing the influence of particular training data from an already-trained model. These approaches are often presented as pragmatic ways to reduce legal exposure. They are supported by an engineering intuition we call output equivalence: if the system no longer produces infringing or harmful outputs, then it is effectively equivalent to a model that never learned from the problematic data—and therefore should be treated as compliant. This paper argues that such post-hoc mitigation strategies do not, as a matter of law, eliminate legal liability arising from the training process. Across jurisdictions, developers can face multiple, overlapping forms of exposure based on how training data are acquired and used, including copyright infringement , contract-based claims (e.g., license or terms-of-service violations), and tort/unfair competition theories . Because these liabilities can be established based on acts of acquisition, copying, and reproduction—not solely on a model’s current output behavior—adjusting outputs after training generally cannot retroactively cure an unlawful training-stage act. As a result, incurring legal liability can impose substantial costs on developers, potentially resulting in severe remedies such as algorithmic disgorgement and significant monetary exposure. This is why the AI industry must shift away from treating post-hoc mitigation as a compliance strategy and toward verifiable ex-ante process compliance . In the remainder of this paper, we proceed from context-setting to premises, then to doctrinal analysis, and finally to practical implications. Section 2 surveys related work at the intersection of engineering and law, emphasizing a persistent disconnect between them. Section 3 states and motivates our legal premise by tying unauthorized dataset creation and training to the reproduction right across jurisdictions and showing why key defenses (fair use/TDM) are increasingly constrained. Building on this premise, Section 4 presents our core copyright analysis—introducing the completed-act framing and examining model weights through fixation and perceptibility—showing why suppressing outputs does not retroactively cure training-stage exposure. We then broaden the lens in Section 5 to contract and tort/unfair competition theories that can independently constrain data acquisition and reuse, and in Section 6 to remedial doctrines such as unjust enrichment and disgorgement. Section 7 addresses leading counterarguments and clarifies the limits of defenses commonly invoked in practice. Finally, Section 8 translates our findings into concrete directions for model development and governance. 2 Related Work: The Disconnect Between Engineering and Law Research on legal compliance for generative AI is marked by a clear divide between disciplines. In engineering, most works evaluate technical interventions using engineering metrics while taking legal validity for granted. In legal scholarship, by contrast, much of the discussion focuses on abstract doctrines and policy, often without assessing whether the emerging technical remedies, such as post-hoc mitigation techniques, are legally meaningful. This section highlights this epistemic gap and our contributions. 2.1 Engineering Mitigation and the Output Equivalence Assumption The engineering literature has proposed a wide range of techniques intended to suppress or remove undesirable information from trained models. Machine unlearning methods—including SISA ( 6 ) and gradient-based approaches ( 23 ; 15 ) —seek to eliminate the influence of specific training examples. Relatedly, model editing techniques such as ROME ( 29 ) aim to directly modify particular factual associations in model parameters. Inference-time guardrails further attempt to prevent infringing outputs through retrieval-based constraints or other runtime controls ( 20 ) . A central feature of this engineering work is an often implicit assumption we call output equivalence: if post-hoc interventions make a model’s output distribution statistically indistinguishable from that of a counterfactual model trained without the problematic data, then the system is treated as compliant. To ensure the robustness of our legal analysis, we adopt a strong technical premise that represents the best-case performance of post-hoc mitigation methods. Specifically, for the sake of argument, we assume that post-hoc methods such as inference-time guardrails and parameter modification can achieve their theoretical ideal, producing a modified model whose output distribution P^{*} is statistically identical to that of a model retrained from scratch without the infringing data: P^{*}(y|x)=P(y|x;\text{retrained model}) for any input x and output y . In practice, prior studies emphasize effectiveness and utility metrics (e.g., retention of general capabilities and reduction of targeted behaviors), but they typically do not examine whether even this strongest form of output-level equivalence satisfies the doctrinal requirements of copyright law, particularly with respect to liability arising from upstream acts of ingestion, copying, and reproduction during training. 2.2 Legal Scholarship and the Technical Blind Spot Legal scholarship on LLMs