A Generalized Synthetic Control Method for Baseline Estimation in Demand Response Services
Jonas Sievers, Mardavij Roozbehani · 2026
Read A Generalized Synthetic Control Method for Baseline Estimation in Demand Response Services by Jonas Sievers, Mardavij Roozbehani (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-18469.txt.
Introduction
Sievers and Roozbehani extend the synthetic control method for baseline gauging in demand-response power markets. These numbers decide payouts, yet machine learning predicts weakly and causal methods stay rarely used. The classical version fits the treated unit from same-day donors but ignores time-based structure in leftovers. The extended version adds outside signals, lagged treated load, and lagged donor signals, catching echo effects, delayed replies, and error fixes. Ausgrid smart-meter tests beat the classical version and strong benchmarks, most through dynamic add-ons.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jonas Sievers, Mardavij Roozbehani |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40370 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.18469
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Generalized Synthetic Control Method for Baseline Estimation in Demand Response Services Jonas Sievers, Mardavij Roozbehani Abstract Baseline estimation is critical to Demand Response (DR) settlement in electricity markets, yet existing machine learning methods remain limited in predictive performance, while methodologies from causal inference and counterfactual prediction are still underutilized in this domain. We introduce a Generalized Synthetic Control Method that builds on the classical Synthetic Control Method (SCM) from econometrics. While SCM provides a powerful framework for counterfactual estimation, classical SCM remains a static estimator: it fits the treated unit as a combination of contemporaneous donor units and therefore ignores predictable temporal structure in the residual error. We develop a generalized SCM framework that transforms baseline estimation into a dynamic counterfactual prediction problem by augmenting the donor representation with exogenous features, lagged treated load, and selected lagged donor signals. This enriched representation allows the estimator to capture autoregressive dependence, delayed donor-response patterns, and error-correction effects beyond the scope of standard SCM. The framework further accommodates nonlinear predictors when linear weighting is inadequate, with the greatest benefit arising in limited-data settings. Experiments on the Ausgrid smart-meter dataset show consistent improvements over classical SCM and strong benchmark methods, with the dominant performance gains driven by dynamic augmentation. I INTRODUCTION Flexibility services such as Demand Response (DR) and Local Flexibility Marketss (LFMs) are becoming increasingly important for maintaining grid stability in power systems with growing shares of volatile Renewable Energy Sources (RES) . While DR programs incentivize consumers to adjust electricity consumption in response to grid conditions, LFMs provide market-based mechanisms for procuring local flexibility to relieve congestion. A central challenge in both DR and LFM is baseline estimation, i.e., the counterfactual consumption that would have occurred absent a flexibility incentive [ 10 , 15 ] . Because delivered flexibility is measured as the deviation from this baseline, accurate and transparent estimation is essential for fair settlement and efficient market design. Inaccurate baselines can distort remuneration, weaken participation incentives, and create opportunities for strategic manipulation through deliberate load shifting [ 7 ] . Fig. 1: Architectural overview of the Generalized Synthetic Control Method for baseline estimation in residential flexibility services. I-A Related Work Recent approaches to customer baseline estimation can be broadly grouped into averaging, regression, clustering-based, and deep learning methods ( Table I ). Averaging-based methods, including Exponential Moving Average and X-of-Y techniques, are widely used in practice because of their simplicity [ 11 ] . However, their reliance on historical averages limits accuracy when consumption patterns shift rapidly. Regression-based methods improve adaptability by modeling consumption as a function of explanatory variables. Early approaches used linear and polynomial regression [ 11 ] , with Ridge or Lasso regularization. More flexible models include Support Vector Machines [ 5 ] , Random Forests, and XGBoost [ 11 ] . Deep learning has further advanced baseline estimation by capturing nonlinear dependencies in load profiles through architectures such as Dense Neural Networks (DNN) , Long Short-Term Memory Models (LSTM) , and Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) with attention mechanisms [ 21 , 18 , 19 ] . Like other forecasting-based approaches, these models estimate counterfactual consumption from pre-intervention information, extrapolating historical load and covariates under the assumption of no flexibility activation. In clustering-based approaches, the baseline is inferred from historical trends together with contemporaneous observations from a peer group selected to resemble the treated building. Methods that use reference-building information during the intervention period are closer in spirit to the Synthetic Control Method. Common techniques include K-Means, DBScan, Self-Organizing Maps, and frequency-based clustering based on the Discrete Fourier Transform [ 16 ] . The SCM , originally introduced by Abadie et al. [ 2 , 1 ] , extends this peer-based logic by replacing discrete group selection with continuous weight optimization. Rather than relying on a pre-clustered subset, SCM constructs a synthetic counterfactual as a weighted combination of units in a donor pool that are not exposed to the intervention. In the context of baseline estimation, this amounts to combining profiles from similar non-participating buildings with weights chosen to match the treated building’s historical consumption. Owing to its causal interpretability and flexibility, SCM has been widely applied in economics, public health, social sciences, and engineering [ 3 ] . TABLE I: Concept Matrix for the Literature on Baseline Estimation in Flexibility Services. Reference Year Focus Average Regression Deep L. Cluster Optimization [ 12 ] 2024 Aggregated BE with a Graph Neural Network \bullet \bullet \bullet \bullet [ 18 ] 2020 Aggregated BE with Stacked Autoencoders \bullet \bullet \bullet \bullet [ 19 ] 2024 BE with an Attention-based GAN \bullet \bullet \bullet \bullet [ 13 ] 2024 BE with a Diffusion Model \bullet \bullet \bullet \bullet [ 11 ] 2020 BE with Dense Neural Networks \bullet \bullet [ 5 ] 2023 BE Evaluation of various ML Models \bullet \bullet [ 22 ] 2022 BE with Mixed Effect Regression \bullet [ 8 ] 2022 BE with K-means and Lasso Regression \bullet \bullet \bullet [ 20 ] 2023 BE with K-means and Weighted Averaging \bullet [ 21 ] 2024 BE with K-means and LSTM [ 16 ] 2020 BE with Frequency-based Clustering and Averaging \bullet \bullet This paper 2025 BE with Advanced Synthetic Control Method \bullet \bullet \bullet \bullet Where represents a proposed method in the respective category, and \bullet indicates its inclusion as a benchmark. Abbreviations: Baseline Estimation (BE); Generative Adversarial Network (GAN); Machine Learning (ML); Long Short-Term Memory Model (LSTM); Deep Learning (Deep L). I-B Contribution We propose a Generalized Synthetic Control framework for baseline estimation ( Figure 1 ). To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to apply counterfactual prediction ideas from the causal-inference literature, and specifically Synthetic Control, to DR baseline estimation. Our main methodological contribution is to extend classical SCM from a static estimator based on contemporaneous donor loads to a dynamic counterfactual predictor built from an augmented representation including exogenous features, lagged treated load, and selected lagged donor signals. This reformulation enables SCM to incorporate temporal information that is excluded by its standard static formulation. We further generalize the framework to admit nonlinear predictors and show empirically that their benefit is most pronounced in data-constrained settings or when donor pools are small. Finally, using real-world smart-meter data, we demonstrate consistent improvements over classical SCM and strong benchmark methods, with the largest gains attributable to dynamic augmentation while retaining the interpretability that makes SCM attractive for market applications. II METHODOLOGY II-A Baseline Estimation Using the Synthetic Control Method We estimate the DR baseline using a synthetic control formulation, in which the untreated consumption of a participating building is approximated by a weighted combination of non-participating buildings. Let y_{jt}\in\mathbb{R} denote the electricity consumption of building j\in\{1,\dots,J{+}1\} at time t\in T_{0}\cup T_{1} , where T_{0} and T_{1} denote the pre and post intervention periods, respectively. Building j=1 is the treated unit, i.e., the building that received the flexibility payment, while the remaining J buildings serve as donor units and receive no flexibility payments. During congestion ( t\in T_{1} ), the delivered flexibility, or treatment effect, is defined as the deviation of observed consumption y_{1t} from the estimated baseline \hat{y}_{1t} [ 3 ] : \hat{\tau}_{1t}=\hat{y}_{1t}-y_{1t},\quad t\in T_{1}. (1) The baseline is estimated as