An ‘Inverse’ Experimental Framework to Estimate Market Efficiency

Thomas Asikis, Heinrich H. Nax · 2026

Read An ‘Inverse’ Experimental Framework to Estimate Market Efficiency by Thomas Asikis, Heinrich H. Nax (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-18130.txt.

Introduction

Asikis and Nax invert the usual laboratory approach to double auctions. In these markets, buyers and sellers post bids and asks, but posted prices do not reveal true reservation values. The authors therefore train models on quantile-normalized bids, asks, and realized prices. Their models predict allocative efficiency early, with accuracy improving as more trades arrive, offering a tool for governing real digital marketplaces.

Catalog record

CREATORThomas Asikis, Heinrich H. Nax
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE111922
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.18130

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An ‘Inverse’ Experimental Framework to Estimate Market Efficiency Thomas Asikis, Heinrich H. Nax Abstract Digital marketplaces processing billions of dollars annually represent critical infrastructure in sociotechnical ecosystems, yet their performance optimization lacks principled measurement frameworks that can inform algorithmic governance decisions regarding market efficiency and fairness from complex market data. By looking at orderbook data from double auction markets alone, because bids and asks do not represent true maximum willingnesses to buy and true minimum willingnesses to sell, there is little an economist can say about the market’s actual performance in terms of allocative efficiency. We turn to experimental data to address this issue, ‘inverting’ the standard induced value approach of double auction experiments. Our aim is to predict key market features relevant to market efficiency, particularly allocative efficiency, using orderbook data only—specifically bids, asks and price realizations, but not the induced reservation values—as early as possible. Since there is no established model of strategically optimal behavior in these markets, and because orderbook data is highly unstructured, non-stationary and non-linear, we propose quantile-based normalization techniques that help us build general predictive models. We develop and train several models, including linear regressions and gradient boosting trees, leveraging quantile-based input from the underlying supply-demand model. Our models can predict allocative efficiency with reasonable accuracy from the earliest bids and asks, and these predictions improve with additional realized price data. The performance of the prediction techniques varies by target and market type. Our framework holds significant potential for application to real-world market data, offering valuable insights into market efficiency and performance, even prior to any trade realizations. keywords competitive equilibrium markets, double auctions, market efficiency, machine learning, allocative efficiency 1 Motivation As current digital societies increasingly rely on algorithmic systems for economic coordination, e.g. from procurement platforms to resource allocation mechanisms, the ability to assess and optimize market efficiency becomes essential for sustainable socio-technical development. Traditional economic theory may be difficult to apply when market complexity exceeds analytical tractability, creating a critical gap where traditional approaches can extract meaningful efficiency signals from high-dimensional orderbook data. Our framework addresses this challenge by developing machine learning methods that can predict allocative efficiency from observable market patterns, providing the computational tools necessary for evidence-based optimization of digital economic systems in smart societies. Key determinants of bargaining behavior in markets are often unobservable in real-world data. In the context of auction, trade and orderbook data, for instance, we are often limited to observing bids and asks, without having access to the traders’ corresponding true reservation prices. As economists, we are therefore unable to make some of the most crucial evaluations of realized market outcomes in terms of their efficiency, fairness, and welfare properties, which all necessitate knowledge of these unobservables. In a bilateral double auction, for example, we could make the most exciting statements from an economists perspective only if, in addition to bids, asks and realized prices, we also knew the true buyer and seller valuations; when trade occurs at a given price we could use such information to assess relative bargaining success and resulting fairness properties of the realized deal, and, conversely, when no trade occurs we would be able to tell whether this was because there were no positive gains of trade between the two parties or whether it was a case of inefficient bargaining and how much the two parties contributed to it relatively. In this paper, we propose a novel approach to answer these fundamental efficiency questions in the context of continuous bid-ask double auctions for nondurables a la Vernon 31 . We shall use controlled experimental data from such markets, in particular relying on the data from a large-scale reproduction of 31 by 16 . We develop a framework that ‘inverts’ the classical analytical approach of experimental studies using standard statistical learning approaches. The classical analytical approach uses the controlled nature of the experimental trade environment to directly test for the convergence of realized market dynamics in terms of Walrasian Competitive Equilibrium (CE). We invert this logic as our goal is to predict, based on (initial) orderbook data of realized trade behavior, that is, using data on bids, asks and price realizations—but not reservation prices!—key features of the underlying market structure derived from equilibrium prices and equilibrium gains of trade, and to assess the realized trade behavior in terms of performance vis-a-vis equilibrium. That is, while our models are trained using the controlled nature of experimental data that includes information concerning individual reservation values, our prediction relies on exactly the kind of orderbook data that is typically observable in the field that does not include reservation value information. Our predictive framework is compared with the classical experimental approach schematically in fig. 1 . The practical relevance of our framework extends to markets where efficiency assessment remains challenging despite the rich observational data. Consider supply chain procurement platforms where buyers and suppliers engage in repeated negotiations for standardized components. While platform operators observe bid patterns, clearing prices, and allocation outcomes, they cannot directly access suppliers’ production costs or buyers’ urgency levels, and therefore estimate actual valuation prices. Our inverse approach transforms this observational challenge into an opportunity for inference. By training models on experimental double auction data, where reservation values are known, we develop predictive tools that can assess market efficiency using only observable orderbook information. This methodology applies to markets with potential assumptions on stable valuations within trading windows and goods that have no resale value in the short term, such as industrial equipment auctions with fixed maintenance schedules, B2B commodity exchanges with contracted delivery dates, on-line ad exchanges or labor platforms matching freelancers to time-bounded projects. In each case, improving allocative efficiency by even 5% could generate substantial value while ensuring that resources reach their most productive uses. Crucially, our framework acknowledges that real markets deviate from idealized Walrasian assumptions, instead leveraging the specific structure of continuous double auctions to make practical efficiency predictions. The broader goal of our project is ultimately to propose a method that is able to evaluate the efficiency of a market based on the kind of data that typically would be available, that is, not including information regarding reservation values. 1 1 1 This includes bids, asks, realized prices, and market-level metadata such as feedback setting and price rule, but explicitly excludes buyer and seller reservation values. Our focus is on markets run as continuous bid-ask double auctions, and in this paper, we use experimental data to develop and train several models. Various approaches out there have pursued that same broader goal in other markets, and other methods have been used before us, which estimate buyers’ and sellers’ true willingnesses to buy and sell based on real-world data in various ways and contexts. To the best of our knowledge, none of them applies directly to markets a la Vernon Smith (1962), i.e., continuous bid-ask double auctions for homogeneous non-durable goods, and none of them has used experimental data to develop their models. The experimental approach illustrated in the bottom portion of fig. 1 represents over six decades of methodological development in experimental economics, beginning with 31 . This approach has become the gold standard for testing market theories: researchers induce known reservation values, creating a

Read the complete text