Sharing the proceeds from a hierarchical venture when agents have needs

R. Pablo Arribillaga · 2026

Read Sharing the proceeds from a hierarchical venture when agents have needs by R. Pablo Arribillaga (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-18108.txt.

Introduction

Arribillaga, Moreno-Ternero, and Neme study how to split the proceeds of a joint venture organized as a hierarchy. Each participant also has individual needs to meet. They describe a set of need-adjusted geometric rules in which surplus revenue bubbles upward through the ranks. They add a serial rule that shares each person's surplus equally with everyone above them.

Catalog record

CREATORR. Pablo Arribillaga
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47375
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.18108

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sharing the proceeds from a hierarchical venture when agents have needs Thanks: R. Pablo Arribillaga and Pablo Neme acknowledge financial support from Universidad Nacional de San Luis (UNSL) through grants 032016, 031620 and 031323, from Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET) through grant PIP 112-200801-00655, and from Agencia Nacional de Promoción Científica y Tecnológica through grant PICT 2017-2355. Juan D. Moreno-Ternero acknowledges grant PID2023-146364NB-I00, funded by MCIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and FSE+. Thanks: Department of Economics, Universidad Pablo de Olavide, Spain; email: [email protected] R. Pablo Arribillaga Abstract We consider a setting in which a set of agents are hierarchically organized for a joint venture. They each generate revenues for the joint venture and have individual needs to cover. The aim is to distribute aggregate revenues appropriately. We characterize a family of need-adjusted geometric rules where the net revenue (after covering needs) ‘bubbles up’ in the hierarchy, as well as a need-adjusted serial rule in which the net revenue is equally shared among each agent and his predecessors in the hierarchy. JEL numbers : C71, D63, L24, M52. Keywords : Hierarchies, Joint ventures, Resource allocation, Need-adjusted geometric rules, Need-adjusted serial rule. 1 Introduction Agents typically engage in joint ventures. Often, these ventures are hierarchically organized, with each agent located in a different layer of the hierarchy, reflecting a different degree of responsibility, command, or even seniority (e.g., Garicano, 2000; Demange, 2004). In this paper, we are concerned with a basic resource allocation problem arising in those settings. That is, suppose agents generate revenues to the (hierarchical) venture, but also have needs to cover. The issue is how to allocate the overall revenue among participating agents, while taking into account their needs and locations in the hierarchy. Thus, we follow Hougaard et al. (2017), who introduced the problem of sharing revenues in a hierarchy. 1 1 1 Related problems had been studied much earlier in the literature (e.g., Claus and Kleitman, 1973; Littlechild and Owen, 1973; Bird, 1976). More recently, see Hougaard et al. (2022) and Gudmundsson et al. (2025). The novelty of our model is to introduce individual needs in the problem. 2 2 2 Similarly, Martínez and Moreno-Ternero (2024, 2026a) have recently extended the basic setting of redistribution problems (e.g., Ju et al., 2007) to account for needs. The requirement that the allocation process grants each individual an amount at least as large as to cover the need will be crucial for our analysis. We shall formalize this principle as the axiom of needs lower bound , which aligns with the long tradition in axiomatic work that endorses lower bounds as a basic axiom of distributive justice (e.g., Rawls, 1971; Moulin, 2004; Moreno-Ternero and Roemer, 2006). Hougaard et al. (2017) characterize in their setting a family of geometric rules in which revenue ‘bubbles up’ in the hierarchy. With a geometric rule, the lowest-ranked agent gets a share of his revenue, his immediate superior gets the same share of his resulting revenue, after adding the remaining ‘surplus’ from the lowest-ranked agent, etc. This is reminiscent of the so-called geometric incentive tree mechanisms, which are proven successful for social mobilization (e.g., Pickard et al., 2011). We characterize in this paper need-adjusted geometric rules , which extend the family of geometric rules mentioned above to the case in which agents have needs (which are measured in the same monetary units as the revenues). In our benchmark case, we assume that each agent in the hierarchy has a need below the revenue he brings to the hierarchy. With a need-adjusted geometric rule, the lowest-ranked agent gets his need, as well as a share of his remaining revenue, his immediate superior also gets his need, as well as the same share of his resulting revenue, after adding the remaining ‘surplus’ from the lowest-ranked agent, etc. We show that the family of need-adjusted geometric rules is characterized by the needs lower bound axiom, together with the same axioms Hougaard et al. (2017) considered in their characterization (with the exception of a specific modification of scale invariance ). We highlight three focal rules within the family, arising when the share of (net) revenue agents keep is, respectively, zero, one-half and one. That is, the need-adjusted full-transfer rule , the need-adjusted balanced transfer rule and the no-transfer rule , respectively. We characterize each of those rules adding one additional axiom to the list characterizing the family of geometric rules. We then single out another rule outside the family of need-adjusted geometric rules. This rule states that each agent keeps his need and shares the residual equally with all his predecessors. The rule is dubbed the serial rule as it is reminiscent of the cost-sharing rule introduced by Moulin and Shenker (1992). We characterize this rule by the combination of one of the axioms in the characterization of the need-adjusted geometric rules, and two axioms strengthening two other axioms used therein. Our results also have connections to the literature on river sharing. Ambec and Sprumont (2002) is the seminal contribution to analyze the allocation of water that flows along a river among the agents located therein. More recently, Martínez and Moreno-Ternero (2025a, 2026b) have analyzed a resourcist version of this model of river sharing in which agents are not endowed with utility functions. As a consequence, the model becomes a mirror version of the problem of revenue sharing in hierarchies, with no needs. They characterize counterpart rules for the geometric and serial rules mentioned above, without adjusting for needs. Earlier, Ansink and Weikard (2012, 2015) extended the river sharing model to account for agents’ claims on the river water too, which can be seen as similar to the concept of needs in our model. Finally, Yang et al. (2025) and Martínez and Moreno-Ternero (2025b) have studied another stylized model to analyze the problem of distributing a budget of emissions permits among agents located along a river. 3 3 3 Ni and Wang (2007) and Dong et al. (2012) studied earlier another model of sharing the cost of cleaning a polluted river. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we introduce the model and basic axioms for our analysis. In Section 3, we present the main results of our analysis. First, the characterization of the family of need-adjusted geometric rules. Then, the independent characterizations of each of the three focal elements within the family. Finally, the characterization of the need-adjusted serial rule. In Section 4, we explore three extensions of our benchmark analysis. First, we consider the larger domain of problems in which needs can be collectively (but not necessarily individually) covered by revenues. Second, we consider the restricted domain in which needs are all null. Finally, we study in more detail the canonical two-agent case. 2 The model Suppose there exists a set of potential agents , identified with the set of natural numbers. Let \mathcal{M} be the class of finite subsets of the natural numbers, with generic element M . Each set M\in\mathcal{M} will represent a linear hierarchy , with the convention that lower numbers in M refer to lower positions in the hierarchy. For instance, if M=\{1,\dots,m\} , then 1 is representing the agent with the lowest rank in the hierarchy, whereas

Read the complete text