Classification and deontic explosion for contrary-to-duty obligations

Bjørn Kjos-Hanssen · 2026

Read Classification and deontic explosion for contrary-to-duty obligations by Bjørn Kjos-Hanssen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-17703.txt.

Introduction

Kjos-Hanssen examines Carmo and Jones' sequence of candidate axiom systems for conditional obligation from 1997 to 2022. For their most recent system, he demonstrates a limited form of deontic explosion. When a student misses the top grade on a test, every other passing grade counts as acceptable. Alongside that negative result, he gives a positive one. Returning to Carmo and Jones' strongest 1997 system, he provides an unexpected classification of all satisfying models through one forbidden possible world.

Catalog record

CREATORBjørn Kjos-Hanssen
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE18040
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.17703

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Classification and deontic explosion for contrary-to-duty obligations Bjørn Kjos-Hanssen Abstract Carmo and Jones have presented a sequence of candidate axiom systems for conditional obligation between 1997 and 2022. For their most recent system we demonstrate a limited form of deontic explosion: given that a student does not get the highest possible grade on a test, any other passing grade is acceptable. In addition to that negative result, we give a positive one: revisiting the strongest version of Carmo and Jones’ 1997 system, we provide a surprising classification of all satisfying models in terms of a single forbidden possible world. 1 Introduction Carmo and Jones in 2022 [ 1 ] proposed certain axioms 5(a)–(g) for a relation \ob that holds between sets of possible worlds X and Y if X is obligatory in the context Y . It was the latest iteration in a sequence of systems [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] . We will exhibit an anomaly therein: a weak form of conditional deontic explosion. Given that something is somewhat desirable (passing a course with a grade of C, say) and given that the most desirable outcome (the grade of A) is unavailable, the somewhat desirable outcome becomes obligatory. We then show that despite this explosion, the systems of Carmo and Jones have interesting mathematical content. For the strongest system we provide a full classification of its models; for weaker versions we characterize the least models (under inclusion) satisfying the axioms and basic contrary-to-duty assumptions. 2 The anomaly Let W be a finite set of possible worlds of a given model, and let \mathscr{P} denote the power set operation. Combining the systems from several papers, the full list of Carmo and Jones’ conditions on a function ob:\mathscr{P}(W)\to\mathscr{P}(\mathscr{P}(W)) is as follows. • Axiom 5(a): \emptyset\not\in\ob(X) . (Obligations cannot be impossible to fulfil.) • Axiom 5(b): If Y\cap X=Z\cap X then Y\in\ob(X) iff Z\in\ob(X) . (Whether Z is obligatory in context X depends only on Z through Z\cap X .) • Axiom 5(c - ) ( [ 3 , page 319] ; finite version of 5(c ∗ ) in [ 4 ] , which is called 5(c) in [ 1 ] ): If Y\in\ob(X) and Z\in\ob(X) and X\cap Y\cap Z\neq\emptyset , then Y\cap Z\in\ob(X) . (Closure under intersection.) • Axiom 5(c) ( [ 2 ] and [ 3 , page 287] ): If Y\in\ob(X) and Z\in\ob(X) then Y\cap Z\in\ob(X) . (Closure under intersection, even for disjoint sets.) • Axiom 5(d): If Y\subseteq X and Y\in\ob(X) and X\subseteq Z , then (Z\setminus X)\cup Y\in\ob(Z) . (If Y is obligatory in context X then a form of the material conditional “ X\to Y ” holds in a wider context.) • Axiom 5(e): If Y\subseteq X and Z\in\ob(X) and Y\cap Z\neq\emptyset , then Z\in\ob(Y) . (If Z is obligatory in the context X then it remains obligatory in any subcontext in which it is still possible.) • Axiom 5(f): If X\in\ob(Y) and X\in\ob(Z) then X\in\ob(Y\cup Z) . (If X is obligatory in both of the contexts Y and Z , then it is obligatory in their union.) • Axiom 5(g): If Y\in\ob(X) and Z\in\ob(Y) and X\cap Y\cap Z\neq\emptyset , then Y\cap Z\in\ob(X) . (A form of transitivity for obligations.) The argument. Axioms 5(b)(e)(f) will now be used to derive an anomaly. Suppose that James is taking an exam on which the possible grades, in decreasing order of quality, are A, B, C, D and F. If seems reasonable to assume that given that James’ grade is A or B, it ought to be A. Moreover, given that the grade is C or D, it ought to be C. Then by axiom 5(b), given that the grade is C or D, it ought to be A or C. Moreover, also by 5(b), given that the grade is A or B, it ought to be A or C. In other words, James ought to make sure the proposition “the grade is A or C” is true (of course, ideally by getting an A). It also follows that the grade ought to be A or C given that it is A, B, C, or D, this time using axiom 5(f) applied to the two previous statements. (If this is getting hard to follow, the reader may rest assured that a formalization is available, see Section 4 .) So far this is not entirely unintuitive. But now we use 5(e), and conclude that since A or C was obligatory in the context A, B, C, or D it must remain obligatory in a more restrictive context in which it is still possible, namely B, C, or D. Finally, using 5(b) again, we conclude that given that the grade is B, C, or D, it ought to be C. While there is such a concept as ‘‘gentleman’s C’’, surely this is a paradox. 1 1 1 Traditionally a Gentleman’s C is given to someone who deserves D or F but for extraneous reasons is deemed worthy of a C. Here this is reversed, as a C is deemed obligatory even when a B is available. A literary perspective. Let us consider the anomaly above in another context, beside students and their grades. Suppose James has the following options. A Marriage to Alice, his favorite. B Marriage to Alice’s sister Beatrice, or one of several other women he also quite likes. C Remaining a lonely bachelor. D Marriage to Deirdre, whom he despises. Then our conclusion is like that of the Bee Gees in 1977: If I can’t have you, I don’t want nobody. From despondency to mathematics. Hage [ 5 ] thinks the task Carmo and Jones and others have set themselves is impossible. From Hage’s book review, in the context of discussing a man who (i) should visit his neighbor, (ii) if he does visit, should call to say that he is coming, and (iii) is not in fact coming: […] Actually, A does not assist his neighbours and therefore should not call them. The two intuitions presuppose a different role for deontic logic, namely, reasoning about what is ideally the case, and reasoning about what ought to be done in the real world. These two roles are hard to reconcile in one logic, unless the logic combines the two kinds of reasoning in different parts. The paper by Carmo and Jones in the present volume provides such a combination logic. Nevertheless, many have attempted to do what is, in my opinion, undoable 2 2 2 [emphasis ours] and this has lead to many modifications of the Standard System of Deontic Logic (Hilpinen, 1971, p. 13f.; Chellas, 1980, p. 190f.). These new systems have lead to new paradoxes that deal with CTD obligations. Given Hage’s sentiment and the anomaly we have presented, one might temporarily become despondent. If deontic systems always have flaws, why pursue them? However, in the course of uncovering this paradox I also discovered interesting mathematical structure in the axioms 5(a)–5(g). Definition 1 . Let us say that a function \ob is the least member of a family \mathcal{O} if \ob\in\mathcal{O} , and for each \ob^{\prime}\in\mathcal{O} and each X and Y , if X\in\ob(Y) then X\in\ob^{\prime}(Y) . The least model of 5(b) given certain

Read the complete text