Strategic Pricing and Consumer Welfare under One-Sided Price Regulation
Philipp Denter · 2026
Read Strategic Pricing and Consumer Welfare under One-Sided Price Regulation by Philipp Denter (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-17576.txt.
Introduction
Denter studies fuel pricing under Germany's April 2026 rule that bars more than one price rise per day. With demand uncertain across two periods, flexible pricing lets a firm simply charge the static monopoly price each period. Under the rule, by contrast, the firm may price high early to keep room to move later. Denter shows the rule weakly raises expected average prices, strictly so when high future demand is likely enough and the high-low demand gap is large. Consumer surplus rises only when expected prices do not.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Philipp Denter |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22492 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.17576
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Strategic Pricing and Consumer Welfare under One-Sided Price Regulation Thanks: Email: [email protected]. Financial support by grants CEX 2021-001181-M and PID2022-141823NA-I00 financed by MICIU/AEI /10.13039/501100011033 is gratefully acknowledged. Philipp Denter Abstract Motivated by Germany’s April 2026 fuel price regulation, in this note I study a two-period pricing problem with demand uncertainty and a rule that prohibits more than one price increase during the day. Under flexible pricing, the firm chooses the static monopoly price in each period. Under the regulation, by contrast, it may price strategically high in period 1 to preserve flexibility in period 2. I show that the regulation weakly raises expected average prices. The increase is strict when period-2 high demand is sufficiently likely and the gap between high and low demand is large; otherwise, expected average prices are unchanged. Expected consumer surplus increases when expected prices remain constant and decreases otherwise. Keywords: gasoline prices; price regulation; asymmetric adjustment; intraday pricing JEL classification: D43, L13, L41, Q41 1 Introduction On 1 April 2026, Germany introduced a rule under which petrol stations may increase fuel prices only once per day, while price decreases remain allowed at any time ( 4 ) . The reform was presented as a way to make pump prices more predictable and transparent. Before the regulation was enacted, fuel prices were highly volatile and increased multiple times over the course of a day, see the left panel of Figure 1 : Figure 1: Box-and-whisker plots of intraday super E5 petrol prices before (left panel) and after (right panel) the reform. The figures are based on prices posted by petrol stations in the German state of Berlin during the 14 days preceding and following the reform. Average crude oil price after about 1 cent lower than before. Data source: https://benzinpreis.de/de/preisarchiv . Since the reform took effect, however, the picture looks very different—see the right panel of Figure 1 —and many commentators have argued that the reform increased rather than reduced prices. For example, “ According to statistics gathered by ADAC, Europe’s largest automobile association, the price for one litre of petrol has increased by €0.09 (£0.08) since the introduction of the new rule in Germany. Meanwhile, the price for diesel has gone up by €0.13 (£0.11) ” ( 10 ). Figure 2 shows that, in the two weeks following the reform, the average price was higher in every hour of the day than in the two weeks before the reform, even though the average crude oil price over the same period was about 1 cent lower. This note studies the regulation in a simple model of pricing with demand uncertainty. If a station sets a price that is too high, it can later cut it. If it sets a price that is too low, it may be unable to return to the desired higher price later in the day. This irreversibility creates an incentive to set prices strategically high early in the day and to reduce them only gradually thereafter. However, once prices have fallen, unlike under flexible pricing they cannot be increased again. Figure 2: Average hourly difference in Super E5 prices (after minus before), with 90% confidence intervals. Own calculations based on data from https://benzinpreis.de/de/preisarchiv . I study this mechanism in a simple two-period model. The main result is that the regulation weakly raises expected average prices. When the probability of future high demand is sufficiently large and the difference between high and low demand is sufficiently pronounced, the firm chooses the high price in period 1 even when current demand is low. In that case, the regulation strictly increases expected average prices relative to flexible pricing. Otherwise, the firm still prices strategically above the low-demand monopoly benchmark, but the expected average price remains unchanged. The analysis therefore suggests that one-sided price regulation need not lower prices and may instead increase them. The model also delivers a nuanced implication for consumer welfare. If the regulation increases expected average prices, expected consumer surplus decreases. In this case, the regulation backfires in multiple dimensions at once. If, by contrast, expected average prices are unchanged, then expected consumer surplus actually increases. The policy can increase consumer welfare. However, the policy is a double-edged sword, and this positive outcome is not guaranteed. Related literature: This note is closest to the literature on retail fuel-price regulation that restricts upward price adjustments. 8 studies the Austrian one-increase-per-day rule in a two-period duopoly model with consumer search and shows that such regulation can backfire and harm consumers. 6 provide complementary experimental evidence: in their laboratory markets, the Austrian rule tends to raise prices and profits relative to an unregulated benchmark. By contrast, 3 estimate the Austrian Fuel Price Fixing Act using synthetic control methods and find price reductions, especially for gasoline. 2 compare several retail fuel-pricing regulations in a laboratory setting, including a regime in which price increases are allowed once per day at a specific time while price decreases remain unrestricted. 5 examine whether Austria’s one-increase-per-day rule altered the dynamics of retail fuel price adjustment, thereby linking such policies to the broader pass-through literature. Taken together, these papers show that one-sided price regulation can matter, but that its effects are theoretically and empirically ambiguous. The paper most directly related to the German reform is 9 , who studies the optimal reset hour of Germany’s once-daily price-increase limit in a spatial-competition model calibrated to German intraday pricing patterns. My note differs from 9 in both objective and method. Rather than asking which reset hour minimizes average prices, I isolate a simple dynamic mechanism through which one-sided adjustment constraints affect firms’ pricing incentives under demand uncertainty. The contribution of the note is to show, in a tractable reduced-form model, how the inability to reverse low prices can induce firms to set prices strategically high early in the day, and how this effect can raise expected average prices. The note also relates to work on gasoline price dynamics and sticky pricing more broadly. 1 show empirically that infrequent and large price changes can serve as a commitment device that facilitates coordination in the Italian petrol market. 7 document recurring patterns of repeated small decreases interrupted by larger upward resets in retail gasoline prices. Relative to this literature, the present note focuses on a different mechanism: the effect of an exogenous asymmetric pricing constraint on the dynamic path of prices, expected average prices, and consumer welfare. 2 Model I begin with a simple baseline model. Time within the day is discrete, and there are two periods, t=1,2 . At time t , quantity demanded is q_{t}=\max\{d_{t}-p_{t},0\}. Since the idea is to model pricing of fuel at petrol stations, I assume marginal cost during the day equals c\geq 0 and is constant. Therefore, profit at time t is \pi(p_{t},d_{t})=(p_{t}-c)q_{t}, (1) and daily profit is \Pi=\sum_{t=1}^{2}\pi(p_{t},d_{t}) . Demand conditions vary stochastically over the day. In each period, d_{t}=\begin{cases}d_{H}&\text{with probability }\gamma_{t},\\ d_{L}&\text{with probability }1-\gamma_{t},\end{cases}\qquad d_{H}>d_{L}>c,\qquad\gamma_{t}\in(0,1), (2) with draws independent across periods. The realization of d_{t} is observed before the period- t price is chosen. Because the probabilities of high and low demand may change over the course of the day, the model also captures expected demand swings, for example because demand may be higher during rush hour