The Inference Bottleneck: A Formal Model of Vertical Foreclosure in AI Markets
Gaston Besanson Universidad Torcuato Di Tella April 2026 Working paper · 2026
Read The Inference Bottleneck: A Formal Model of Vertical Foreclosure in AI Markets by Gaston Besanson Universidad Torcuato Di Tella April 2026 Working paper (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-17431.txt.
Introduction
Besanson models vertical foreclosure in AI inference markets, where advantage lies in inference, distribution, and routing. Two routes need no predatory pricing: quality-of-service bias against downstream rivals and routing bias in assistant tools. A third route, tier-based access bias, follows Anthropic's April 2026 release pattern. Under logit demand with even rivals, the gap grows with quality importance and margins and shrinks with price and entry response. A four-provider mapping points to Google and OpenAI as most exposed, and the paper offers a Neutral Inference conduct framework.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gaston Besanson Universidad Torcuato Di Tella April 2026 Working paper |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 83059 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.17431
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Inference Bottleneck: A Formal Model of Vertical Foreclosure in AI Markets Gaston Besanson Universidad Torcuato Di Tella April 2026 Working paper Abstract . As generative AI commercializes, competitive advantage is shifting from one-time model training toward continuous inference, distribution, and routing. This paper develops a formal game-theoretic model of vertical foreclosure in inference markets, as the formal-model companion to the policy framework in Besanson and Celani 2026 . The model isolates two foreclosure mechanisms that operate without predatory pricing: quality-of-service (QoS) discrimination against downstream rivals via latency, throughput, context limits, or feature access; and routing bias in assistant-layer interfaces. An extension motivated by Anthropic’s April 2026 release of Claude Opus 4.7 alongside the restricted-access Claude Mythos Preview under Project Glasswing introduces a third mechanism, tier-based access discrimination , parameterized by a tier gap τ \tau and partner-exclusivity κ \kappa . The main theoretical result provides an explicit local equilibrium characterization of the QoS gap q U ∗ − q i ∗ q_{U}^{*}-q_{i}^{*} . Under logit demand and symmetric rivals, the gap is strictly increasing in the importance of inference quality ( α \alpha ), strictly increasing in downstream margins ( m U m_{U} ), strictly decreasing in the API access price ( p p ), and strictly decreasing in rival entry elasticity ( η \eta ). Discrimination vanishes at a joint boundary in ( m U , p , η ) (m_{U},p,\eta) space rather than at a simple threshold in α \alpha alone, refining the framework used in earlier working drafts. The paper illustrates the model through a stylized calibration to four providers using public adoption data as of April 2026. The calibration is presented with explicit methodology and sensitivity analysis: parameter values are treated as interpretive inputs to a comparative risk mapping, not structural estimates. Under baseline assumptions, the mapping suggests Google and OpenAI face conditions most conducive to foreclosure, Microsoft’s realized routing bias has been voluntarily constrained by a March 2026 multi-model pivot, and Anthropic’s position is split: low risk on consumer channels, elevated risk in the enterprise coding-agent segment where Claude Code now competes with rivals built on the same API. The policy section proposes Neutral Inference , a four-pillar conduct framework extending the three pillars in the companion paper: QoS parity, routing transparency, FRAND-style non-discrimination, and tier transparency with release-pathway discipline. Illustrative welfare calculations under a range of parameter scenarios suggest conduct-based intervention could generate net welfare gains in the tens of billions of dollars annually, with the range reflecting the underlying calibration uncertainty rather than a point estimate. Keywords: vertical foreclosure; quality discrimination; AI infrastructure; platform competition; self-preferencing; raising rivals’ costs; tiered access; safety carve-outs. JEL codes: L13, L41, L86, K21. 1. Introduction Antitrust economics has long grappled with a fundamental question: when does control over an essential input become the power to pick winners in adjacent markets? The question has traveled through different technological eras, from operating systems ( United States v. Microsoft ) to search engines ( Google Shopping ) to mobile platforms ( Epic v. Apple ), but the underlying economic logic remains constant. Vertically integrated firms controlling bottleneck infrastructure may profitably foreclose downstream rivals through discriminatory access terms, even absent predatory pricing. The generative AI era presents a new instantiation of this classic problem. Firms like Google, OpenAI, Microsoft, and Anthropic control what Besanson and Celani 2026 term cognitive infrastructure : scalable inference capabilities that downstream applications depend upon to function, delivered under technical and contractual terms that providers can adjust to favor their own competing services. The companion paper develops the legal and institutional argument. The present paper develops the formal economic model. What this paper is, and is not. This is a formal mechanism paper with stylized calibration. It is designed to identify the incentive conditions under which non-price foreclosure is profitable, to derive falsifiable empirical predictions from those conditions, and to discipline subsequent policy analysis by making the mapping from model primitives to regulatory observables explicit. It is not a structurally estimated quantitative industrial organization paper. The firm-level numerical outputs reported in Section 6 should be read as comparative risk mappings under stated assumptions rather than recovered deep parameters. The illustrative welfare figures in Section 9 should be read as orders of magnitude that discipline the scale of policy response, not as econometric point estimates. The model is built around a single dominant upstream provider; the April 2026 market includes three major enterprise API providers, and an explicit oligopolistic extension is left for future work. Contributions The paper makes four distinct contributions relative to the companion paper ( Besanson and Celani 2026 ) , which develops the legal and institutional argument from a policy perspective. (1) A formal model of inference-layer foreclosure without price discrimination. The paper derives conditions under which a vertically integrated inference provider profitably degrades third-party QoS or biases routing, using a logit demand framework with endogenous downstream effort. Proposition 1 provides an explicit local equilibrium characterization of the QoS gap under stated assumptions, with comparative statics derived rather than asserted. (2) Tier-based access discrimination as a modelable mechanism. Section 4.3 distinguishes two distinct foreclosure dimensions. Conventional QoS discrimination operates within a shared model or service layer and generates rents that are eroded by ordinary competitive pressure. Tier-based access discrimination operates at the capability frontier, gates access to a distinct model class, generates more durable rents because it is not subject to competitive erosion in the baseline-model market, and has a distinct empirical signature (bimodal capability distributions across customer classes) requiring distinct audit methodology. Proposition 5 parameterizes this mechanism through a tier gap \tau and partner-exclusivity \kappa and establishes monotonic comparative statics. Pillar 4 in Section 9 operationalizes this mechanism as a regulatory obligation. (3) A transparent calibration with explicit identification limits. Section 5 makes the calibration methodology explicit. It distinguishes observed, inferred, and judgment-based parameters; states baseline values for structural parameters held fixed across providers; and provides sensitivity analysis establishing which conclusions are robust to parameter perturbations. The resulting firm-level assessments are framed as comparative risk mappings, not structural estimates. (4) A model-to-observables bridge that connects the formal apparatus to regulatory triggers. Section 8 maps each latent model primitive to an empirical object a regulator could measure or audit. This bridge is the practical connective tissue between the model’s abstract parameters and the designation criteria in Section 9 . It is intended to make the framework usable in enforcement practice, not only in academic commentary. Relation to the companion paper. The companion paper ( Besanson and Celani 2026 ) makes the policy case for treating inference as cognitive infrastructure subject to conduct-based neutrality obligations. The present paper provides microfoundations for that case: the formal derivation of the QoS-gap mechanism (Proposition 1 ), the identification of tier-gating as a distinct foreclosure mechanism requiring a distinct regulatory response (Proposition 5 and Pillar 4), the calibration methodology and sensitivity framework, and the model-to-observables mapping. Readers who accept the companion paper’s policy framing can read this paper as the formal underpinning. Readers who are skeptical of those conclusions can read this paper on its own terms as a model of vertical foreclosure in a market with bottleneck inference inputs. The paper proceeds as follows. Section 2 reviews