A Model and Estimation of the Bitcoin Transaction Fee

Daniel J. Aronoff, Kristian Praizner, Armin Sabouri · 2026

Read A Model and Estimation of the Bitcoin Transaction Fee by Daniel J. Aronoff, Kristian Praizner, Armin Sabouri (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-17183.txt.

Introduction

Aronoff, Praizner, and Sabouri build and estimate a model of Bitcoin fee choice, treating the mempool as a blockspace market. From their own node they assemble a mempool panel recording arrivals, exits, inclusion, and congestion. They characterize the fee market as a Vickery-Clarke-Groves mechanism, derive a fee equation, and estimate a delay technology linking fee priority to expected delay. Congestion emerges as the main determinant of delay. Priority value rises with faster confirmation per queue step, and RBF, CPFP, and block conditions carry large fee effects.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel J. Aronoff, Kristian Praizner, Armin Sabouri
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE88276
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.17183

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Model and Estimation of the Bitcoin Transaction Fee Daniel J. Aronoff, Kristian Praizner, Armin Sabouri Abstract Bitcoin transaction fees will become more important as the block subsidy declines, but fee formation is hard to study with blockchain data alone because the relevant queueing environment is unobserved. We develop and estimate a structural model of Bitcoin fee choice that treats the mempool as a market for scarce blockspace. We assemble a novel, high-frequency mempool panel, from a self-run Bitcoin node that records transaction arrivals, exits, block inclusion, fee-bumping events, and congestion snapshots. We characterize the fee market as a Vickery-Clarke-Groves mechanism and derive an equation to estimate fees. In the first-stage we estimate a monotone delay technology linking fee-rate priority and network state to expected confirmation delay. We then estimate how fees respond to that delay technology and to transaction characteristics. We find that congestion is the main determinant of delay; that the marginal value of priority is priced in fees, which is increasing in the gradient of confirmation time reduction per movement up in the fee queue; and that transactor choice of RBF, CPFP, and block conditions have economically important effects on fees. Keywords: Bitcoin; transaction fees; mechanism design; fee market; machine learning; blockchain. JEL: D44, D47, C45, C52, L86. ACM CCS: Applied computing \rightarrow Electronic commerce; Theory of computation \rightarrow Algorithmic mechanism design; Computing methodologies \rightarrow Machine learning; Security and privacy \rightarrow Distributed systems security; Mathematics of computing \rightarrow Regression analysis. MSC 2020: 91B26; 62J05; 62G08; 91B24; 68M20. 1 Introduction Bitcoin is built on a proof-of-work protocol that requires miners to assemble transactions into blocks and compete to solve a puzzle in a lottery where the winner appends its block to the chain and earns a block reward. The block reward is the mining revenue which provides incentive for a miner to invest in hashrate (puzzle guesses per unit time) to solve the puzzle. Hashrate consumes electricity, which has a private cost to the miner. The block reward serves two functions. One function is to ensure the liveness of the blockchain - i.e. that miners append transactions to each block and that a new block is added approximately every 10 minutes - by ensuring that computers are engaged in mining at all times. The other function is to enhance network security by erecting a threshold expected cost that an attacker, who builds a fork chain, must exceed to make its fork the consensus chain. The equilibrium condition for Bitcoin mining implies that hashrate increases and decreases with the value (usually expressed in USD) of the block reward Figure 1 displays the empirical relationship between the block reward (in USD) and energy consumption over time. The monotonicity of the relationship validates the prediction of the theoretical model. Figure 1 : Source: Cambridge Centre for Alternative Energy The block reward has two parts: an algorithmic subsidy and voluntary transaction fees. The subsidy is programmed to fall through periodic halvings, so a larger share of miner revenue will eventually have to come from fees. A transactor’s motivation to pay a fee is to secure a priority position in the transaction queue; a higher fee induces the miner to append the transaction to its block ahead of a lower fee transaction, thereby shortening the expected confirmation time. A useful model of the fee market will recover two distinct objects: the mapping from priority into delay, and the user-side willingness to pay for a shorter wait. We study that problem with a novel transaction-level mempool data-set collected from a self-run Bitcoin Core node operated by the Medai Lab Digital Currency Initiative. The data record transaction entry into and exit from the mempool, block inclusion, replace-by-fee events, child-pays-for-parent relationships, and high-frequency snapshots of congestion. Those data enable us to reconstruct the queueing environment each transaction faced when its fee was chosen, which is the crucial object missing from standard blockchain-only data. Our empirical strategy follows the economics closely. In the first stage, we estimate expected confirmation delay as a flexible function of fee-rate priority and network conditions, impose the economically sensible restriction that higher priority cannot raise expected delay, and recover the local slope of the delay schedule. In the second stage, we relate fees to that estimated slope and to transaction characteristics in a log-fee equation with epoch fixed effects. We also examine a re-spend-based impatience proxy in supplementary specifications, but the baseline estimates do not depend on it. The main findings are straightforward. Congestion is the dominant determinant of confirmation delay, and the delay schedule – i.e. expected delay between size-ranked fees – becomes steeper when the mempool is congested Fees move with that technology in the direction implied by the model: when a marginal increase in priority buys a larger reduction in delay, users pay more for it. Several institutional details matter as well. RBF-tagged transactions pay large premia, CPFP packages are priced differently from stand-alone transactions, and fees rise with blockspace utilization, mempool depth, and the time since the previous block. The model is most informative within epochs, where it explains a substantial share of cross-sectional fee variation; epoch-to-epoch shifts in the overall fee level are harder to account for and are largely absorbed by fixed effects. One surprising result is that the number of blocks to re-spend UTXO’s is not informative. Möser and Böhme Möser and Böhme 2015 found this measure to be correlated with the presence of a transaction fee on pre-2015 Bitcoin data. Intuitively, a fast turnaround by a receiver of UTXO’s should be a motive to pay a fee to ensure the transaction is processed quickly. We expected to find this correlation to hold in our data, but it does not. This paper sits between several literatures. [ Huberman et al. 2021 ] provide the closest theoretical starting point by modeling blockchain fees as payments for priority in a queue. [ Easley et al. 2019 ] study fee payment using lower-frequency reduced-form data, while [ Lehar and Parlour 2020 ] use transaction-level data to study miner market power. Our contribution is to take a structural priority-pricing framework to transaction-level mempool data. The mempool data spans only a little more than nine weeks, so long-run extrapolation requires caution, particularly because the sample comes from a period of relatively stable network operation, there is limited variation in the explanatory variables of our model. We validate this by comparing the variance of key on-chain variables in our sample to the prior three years. Our remedy is to continue running the DCI Bitcoin node to lengthen our sample over time. The remainder of the paper proceeds as follows. Section 2 describes Bitcoin fee formation and the mempool. Section 3 develops the model. Section 4 describes the data. Section 5 presents the empirical strategy. Section 6 reports the results. Section 7 concludes. 2 Background This section summarizes the institutional features of Bitcoin that govern fee formation. We clarify what economic object a transaction fee represents, how miners select transactions into blocks, and why confirmation delay is a function of transaction priority and network congestion. These mechanics motivate the sparse model in Section 3 and the empirical design in Section 5 . 2.1 Transactions, blockspace, and the block reward A Bitcoin payment

Read the complete text