An order-theoretic characterization of C*-algebras

Samuel Tiersma · 2026

Read An order-theoretic characterization of C*-algebras by Samuel Tiersma (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-16904.txt.

Introduction

Tiersma characterizes when an operator system, a structured space of operators, is really a C*-algebra in disguise. He uses order-theoretic tools built on gauge-reversing maps. He shows such a system matches a C*-algebra exactly when each of its matrix spaces carries a compatible JB-algebra structure. He applies the result to ranges of n-positive projections on real C*-algebras.

Catalog record

CREATORSamuel Tiersma
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59060
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.16904

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An order-theoretic characterization of C*-algebras Samuel Tiersma Abstract We give an order-theoretic characterization of the essential image of the forgetful functor from the category of real/complex unital C*-algebras to the category of real/complex unital operator systems. It is based on the characterization of JB-algebras among the order unit spaces in terms of the existence of gauge-reversing bijections obtained by M. Roelands and the author in [ 22 ] . To this end, we show that a unital operator system is completely order isomorphic to a C*-algebra if and only if each of its matrix spaces admits a compatible JB-algebra structure. As an application, we prove that for n ≥ 4 n\geq 4 the range of a unital n n -positive projection on a unital real C*-algebra is unitally n n -order isomorphic to a unital real C*-algebra, which is the analogue of a result proven for complex C*-algebras by Choi–Effros. Keywords: operator systems, JB-algebras, real C*-algebras, gauge-reversing bijections, order unit spaces, positive projections on real C*-algebras, C*-algebras Subject Classification: 46L07, 17C65, 46L05, 46L70 1 Introduction C*-algebras form a natural framework for the mathematical formulation of quantum mechanics. For this reason, there has been a substantial interest in characterizations of C*-algebras in terms of the underlying order or Banach space structure [ 28 ] , [ 26 ] . The commutative case of this problem is classical, see e.g. [ 15 ] and the references therein. Impetus to the study of the noncommutative case was given by Connes’ characterization of the ordered vector spaces underlying \sigma -finite von Neumann algebras [ 9 ] . Alfsen–Shultz gave a convex-geometric characterization of the state spaces of unital C*-algebras [ 1 ] . Characterizations of C*-algebras and related objects in terms of the existence of holomorphic (or analytic) symmetries have been given in various categories [ 30 , 19 , 11 , 8 ] . The main result of this article is the following order-theoretic characterization of unital C*-algebras among the operator systems (pertinent definitions are given later in this introduction). Theorem 1.1 . Let E be a real (resp. complex) complete unital operator system. Then E is unitally completely order isomorphic to a unital real (resp. complex) C*-algebra if and only if for arbitrarily large integers n\geq 1 there exists an order-anti-isomorphism \Phi_{n}\colon M_{n}(E)^{\circ}_{+}\to M_{n}(E)^{\circ}_{+} which is homogeneous of degree -1 of the interior of the positive cone of M_{n}(E) . We remark that no smoothness assumptions are made on the maps \Phi_{n} , which are known as gauge-reversing bijections . The key ingredient in the proof is a characterization of JB-algebras among the order unit spaces obtain by M. Roelands and the author in [ 22 ] . We shall first discuss this result for JB-algebras, and then make the connection with operator systems. The prototypical example of a JB-algebra is the self-adjoint part A_{sa} of a real or complex C*-algebra A , endowed with the nonassociative Jordan product x\circ y:=\frac{1}{2}(xy+yx) . If J is a JB-algebra with identity 1_{J} , then J is partially ordered by its cone of squares J_{+}=\{x^{2}\colon x\in J\} and (J,J_{+},1_{J}) is an order unit space. The interior J_{+}^{\circ} of J_{+} consists of the positive invertible elements. We record the following observation which will be of cardinal importance. The inversion map i\colon J_{+}^{\circ}\to J_{+}^{\circ} , i(x)=x^{-1} is an order-anti-isomorphism which is homogeneous of degree -1 (see e.g. [ 3 , Lemma 1.31] ). Now let (V,V_{+},v) be an order unit space and denote V^{\circ}_{+} the interior of its positive cone. A mapping \Phi\colon V^{\circ}_{+}\to V^{\circ}_{+} is called a gauge-reversing bijection if it is an order-anti-isomorphism and homogeneous of degree -1 , that is, for all x,y\in V_{+}^{\circ} and \lambda>0 it holds that x\leq y\iff\Phi(x)\geq\Phi(y)\quad\text{ and }\quad\Phi(\lambda x)=\lambda^{-1}\Phi(x). (1) Let us call a compatible JB-algebra structure on (V,V_{+},v) to be a structure of JB-algebra on V for which v is the identity element and V_{+}=\{x^{2}:x\in V\} the cone of squares; it is unique if it exists [ 3 , Thm. 2.80] . In view of the above observation about the inversion map in a JB-algebra, a necessary condition for the existence of a compatible JB-algebra structure on (V,V_{+},v) is the existence of a gauge-reversing bijection on V_{+}^{\circ} . Remarkably, this conditions is also sufficient. Theorem ( [ 22 ] ) . A complete order unit space (V,V_{+},v) has a compatible JB-algebra structure if and only if there exists a gauge-reversing bijection \Phi\colon V^{\circ}_{+}\to V^{\circ}_{+} . We refer to the introduction of [ 22 ] for a discussion of this and related characterizations of Jordan structures, and will now turn to C*-algebras. Let E=(E,*,\{M_{n}(E)_{+}\}_{n},e) be a unital operator system, i.e. E is a matrix-ordered *-vector space with Archimedean matrix order unit e , defined over the base field \mathbb{K}\in\{\mathbb{R},\mathbb{C}\} . Each unital C*-algebra A over \mathbb{K} defines a unital operator system as follows from the fact that M_{n}(A)=A\otimes_{\mathbb{K}}M_{n}(\mathbb{K}) is again a C*-algebra. Hence M_{n}(A)_{sa} is a JB-algebra whose inversion map defines a gauge-reversing bijection i_{n}\colon M_{n}(A)_{+}^{\circ}\to M_{n}(A)_{+}^{\circ} . This shows necessity of the condition in Theorem 1.1 for E to be isomorphic, in the category of unital operator systems, to a unital C*-algebra A . We now give an outline of the proof of sufficiency. First, the order-theoretic characterization of JB-algebras is invoked to obtain a compatible JB-algebra structure on (M_{n}(E)_{sa},M_{n}(E)_{+},e\otimes I_{n}) , whose product we write as (x,y)\mapsto x\circ y . It turns out (cf. Theorem 3.2 ) that the product \circ is automatically compatible with the operator system structure, in the sense that for all a\in M_{n}(\mathbb{K})_{sa} and x\in M_{n}(E)_{sa} it holds that a\circ x=\frac{1}{2}(a\cdot x+x\cdot a), where the right hand side is given by the M_{n}(\mathbb{K}) -bimodule structure on M_{n}(E) . This equality is deduced from an order-theoretic characterization of compressions in a unital JB-algebra in terms of bicomplementary projections due to Alfsen–Shultz. We are then prepared to apply coordinatization theorems for JB-algebras containing an isomorphic copy of M_{n}(\mathbb{R})_{sa} or M_{n}(\mathbb{C})_{sa} , due to Hanche–Olsen resp. Jacobson. This yields a JB-isomorphism M_{n}(E)_{sa}\cong M_{n}(D)_{sa} . The ‘coordinate’ algebra D is an associative unital *-algebra with a proper involution, whose self-adjoint part D_{sa} is a JB-algebra, and is shown to be a C*-algebra in the norm \lVert x\rVert_{D}=\lVert x^{*}x\rVert_{D_{sa}}^{1/2} . In this way we shall obtain the following result, which is an alternative formulation of our main theorem. Theorem 1.2 . Let (E,*,\{M_{n}(E)_{+}\}_{n},e) be a (real or complex) unital operator system. Let m\in\mathbb{Z} be an integer such that m\geq 2 if E is complex and m\geq 4 if E is real. Then: (1) E is unitally m -order isomorphic to a C*-algebra if and only if there exists a compatible JB-algebra structure on the order unit space (M_{m}(E),M_{m}(E)_{+},e\otimes I_{m}) . (2) E is unitally completely order isomorphic to a C*-algebra if and only if there exists a compatible JB-algebra structure on the order unit space (M_{n}(E),M_{n}(E)_{+},e\otimes I_{n}) for arbitrarily large n\geq 1 . This theorem is inspired by and should be compared with the holomorphic characterization of complex C*-algebras obtained by Neal–Russo in [ 19 ] . They showed that for each integer m\geq 2 a complex operator space E is m -isometrically isomorphic to a C*-algebra if and only if the open unit ball of M_{m}(E) is

Read the complete text