Teacher-Authored Prompts for Configuring Student–AI Dialogue: K–12 Classroom Implementation

Alex Liu \affilnum 1, Min Sun \affilnum 1, Lief Esbenshade \affilnum 1, Victor Tian \affilnum 1, Zachary Zhang \affilnum 2, and Kevin He \affilnum 2 · 2026

Read Teacher-Authored Prompts for Configuring Student–AI Dialogue: K–12 Classroom Implementation by Alex Liu \affilnum 1, Min Sun \affilnum 1, Lief Esbenshade \affilnum 1, Victor Tian \affilnum 1, Zachary Zhang \affilnum 2, and Kevin He \affilnum 2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-16738.txt.

Introduction

Liu and colleagues examine teacher-authored prompts and starters for student-AI dialogue. The Spring 2025 pilot covered 39 classrooms, yielding 1,479 conversations with 878 unique students. Conversations matched intent, with 71 percent on-track and fewer than 1 percent off-track. A demand gap persisted, with 38 percent under-reaching the targeted level, approaching 50 percent at level three. Explicit finish lines cut that gap by zero point two two levels, and no-direct-answers guardrails cut final-answer rates by eight point five. Teacher prompts translate intent into structured dialogue, though higher-order reasoning needs support.

Catalog record

CREATORAlex Liu \affilnum 1, Min Sun \affilnum 1, Lief Esbenshade \affilnum 1, Victor Tian \affilnum 1, Zachary Zhang \affilnum 2, and Kevin He \affilnum 2
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE104044
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.16738

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Teacher-Authored Prompts for Configuring Student–AI Dialogue: K–12 Classroom Implementation Alex Liu \affilnum 1, Min Sun \affilnum 1, Lief Esbenshade \affilnum 1, Victor Tian \affilnum 1, Zachary Zhang \affilnum 2, and Kevin He \affilnum 2 Abstract GenAI has rapidly entered instructional and learning settings as a teaching assistant or AI tutor. However, less is known about how pedagogical intent connects to the learning generated within these systems, especially when student-facing AI dialogues are fine-tuned through teacher orchestration in live classrooms. This study examines a classroom deployment of a “Classroom Teaching Aide” (TASD) system, which enables teachers to author both a teacher-to-AI setup prompt (instructional scaffold) and a student-facing conversation starter to launch AI-mediated classroom discussions. We analyze a multi-subject pilot conducted in Spring 2025, involving 20 participating teachers (16 of whom implemented the system), across 39 classrooms and 77 TASD settings, yielding 1,479 student-AI conversations with 878 unique students. Using platform logs, LLM coding with human validation, and post-study teacher interviews (N=10), we characterize teacher authoring choices and link them to enacted student-AI interaction outcomes. Teachers predominantly authored highly specific tasks targeting higher-order thinking, with 92% at Depth of Knowledge (DOK) Levels 2–3 [ 64 ] . In deployment, student-AI conversations were largely aligned with instructional intent: 71% were fully on-track, and fewer than 1% were substantially off-track. However, a persistent design-enactment gap emerged for cognitive demand: 38% of conversations under-reached the teacher-targeted DOK level, approaching 50% when targeting DOK 3. The study also shows that explicit finish lines in the prompt reduced the DOK gap by 0.22 levels (p < < .001), and “no direct answers” guardrails reduced AI final-answer rates by 8.5 percentage points. These findings position teacher-authored prompt layers as critical orchestration levers that translate pedagogical intent into structured student-AI dialogue, underscoring both their promise for scalable classroom integration and the need for additional supports to reliably sustain higher-order reasoning during enactment. keywords Generative AI, Classroom Orchestration, Teacher-Authored AI Chat, K-12, Multilingual Learners, Personalized Learning at Scale, Human-AI Complementarity † † runninghead: Liu et al. † † affiliation: \affilnum 1Univeristy of Washington \affilnum 2Colleague AI, INC. † † corresponding: Alex Liu, Univeristy of Washington College of Education, AmplifyLearn AI Center, Seattle, WA, 98195, US. 1 Introduction Large language models (LLMs) have made conversational support broadly accessible, accelerating interest in AI tools that assist educators and students at scale [ 30 ] . In current educational use, AI is commonly configured as (a) a backstage teacher assistant for planning and materials generation [ 44 , 11 ] , (b) a teaching assistant surfaced through teacher-facing dashboards that suggest instructional moves based on classroom activity or tutoring-system data [ 2 , 25 ] , or (c) a direct-to-student learning platform in which the primary interaction occurs between learner and system with comparatively limited teacher control [ 34 , 58 ] . Each configuration reassigns roles between teachers, students, and AI systems, but ultimately it should be teachers who possess the professional expertise and contextual information to determine whether and how AI contributes to instructionally meaningful learning [ 32 ] . Classroom orchestration refers to teachers’ real-time coordination of students, activities, tools, and instructional decisions to sustain coherent progress toward learning goals under practical constraints [ 16 , 49 ] . In live classrooms, teachers must manage time, norms, safety, and alignment to curricular goals under real-time conditions [ 33 ] . When an additional AI agent is introduced into this workflow, teachers need to coordinate across students, tools, and teaching moments while sustaining pedagogical intent, potentially increasing managerial and cognitive load as they synthesize and translate output from multiple planes into actionable next steps [ 27 ] . Prior orchestration research emphasizes that classroom technologies are most viable when they incorporate direct support for coordination work across simultaneous learners and activities [ 14 , 56 , for eg.] . From this perspective, AI systems designed for synchronous classroom use must be legible, bounded, and supervisable in ways that foreground teachers’ ability to configure, interpret, and oversee learning occurring within the technology, rather than emphasizing solely on underlying model capabilities [ 52 , 35 ] . Prior research has demonstrated how AI-powered tools can support scalable teaching and learning, such as orchestration layers in MOOCs [ 20 ] or real-time awareness features in intelligent tutoring systems [ 9 ] . At the same time, studies of teacher-AI argumentation highlight that instructional value arises not from model fluency alone, but from how educators and AI systems coordinate roles, information, and decisions in the flow of classroom activity [ 25 , 24 ] . Still, much of this work focuses either on enabling teaching or on shaping learning, with fewer investigations into how teacher can configure AI systems to mediate the connection between pedagogical intent and student learning within those systems [ 57 , 27 , 62 ] . This study examines teacher-student-AI facilitation through a teacher-authored student-AI dialogue tool that treats the teacher-authored prompt as an instructional design lever for shaping student discourse at classroom scale. The implemented system, Colleague AI Classroom Teaching Aide (TASD), enables a teacher-configured, student-facing AI conversation that preserves teacher intent while supporting individualized dialogue across students. A teacher authors (i) an AI-facing shared prompting layer that conditions the AI’s role, discussion topics, scaffolding moves, and interaction constraints for the whole class or specific groups (e.g., multilingual learners, advanced students) and (ii) a common student-facing opening instruction that launches the discussion activity. Rather than treating AI chat as an autonomous tutor, TASD frames student-AI interaction as a configurable classroom routine that scales teacher-designed dialogue structures that preserve teachers’ instructional intent and oversight. This approach aligns with AI system designs that rely on system prompts to guide and stabilize human-LLM interactions [ 21 , 61 ] , examining how these systems are enacted, configured, and orchestrated within real K-12 classroom conditions. Guided by two research questions: • RQ1 (Teacher authoring): What do teachers build when given control to author and configure student-AI dialogues at classroom scale? • RQ2 (Classroom orchestration outcomes): How do teacher-authored designs shape what actually happens in student-AI conversations, specifically task alignment, cognitive demand realization, student interaction moves, and AI scaffold adherence? We conducted a multi-site pilot study in Spring 2025 to examine classroom deployment and interaction outcomes. Data sources included teacher-authored prompts, full student-AI conversation traces (including instances of non-use), and semi-structured teacher interviews. Together, these support an analysis of the full instructional chain: from teacher-authored instructional frames and entry scaffolds \rightarrow to student participation and student-AI interactions \rightarrow to outcomes such as task alignment, realization of cognitive demand, and adherence to AI use safeguards, interpreted through teachers’ accounts of orchestration strategies and constraints. To address these questions, we conducted a multi-site pilot study during Spring 2025 across 16 teachers and 878 students. The study examines the full instructional chain: from teacher-authored instructional frames and entry scaffolds \rightarrow to student participation and student-AI interactive outcomes. Drawing on descriptive and qualitative analysis of platform logs, student-AI conversations, and teacher interviews, we analyze how instructional intent is realized in practice. Findings highlight high task alignment, but a consistent gap between intended and actual cognitive demand, alongside evidence that prompt features such as finish lines and safety guardrails

Read the complete text