A Bayesian Updating Framework for Long-term Multi-Environment Trial Data in Plant Breeding

Stephan Bark, Waqas Ahmed Malik, Maryna Prus, Hans-Peter Piepho and Volker Schmid · 2026

Read A Bayesian Updating Framework for Long-term Multi-Environment Trial Data in Plant Breeding by Stephan Bark, Waqas Ahmed Malik, Maryna Prus, Hans-Peter Piepho and Volker Schmid (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-16203.txt.

Introduction

Bark, Malik, Prus, Piepho, and Schmid propose a Bayesian framework for long-term multi-environment crop trials, where variety performance is tested across many sites. Estimating variance components is hard: standard restricted maximum likelihood often shrinks them to zero or gets them wrong, and rich historical data usually go unused. Their Bayesian linear mixed model uses priors and Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling to keep variance components positive and quantify uncertainty better.

Catalog record

CREATORStephan Bark, Waqas Ahmed Malik, Maryna Prus, Hans-Peter Piepho and Volker Schmid
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE76683
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.16203

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Bayesian Updating Framework for Long-term Multi-Environment Trial Data in Plant Breeding Stephan Bark, Waqas Ahmed Malik, Maryna Prus, Hans-Peter Piepho and Volker Schmid Abstract Abstract: In variety testing, multi-environment trials (MET) are essential for evaluating the genotypic performance of crop plants. A persistent challenge in the statistical analysis of MET data is the estimation of variance components, which are often still inaccurately estimated or shrunk to exactly zero when using residual (restricted) maximum likelihood (REML) approaches. At the same time, institutions conducting MET typically possess extensive historical data that can, in principle, be leveraged to improve variance component estimation. However, these data are rarely incorporated sufficiently. The purpose of this paper is to address this gap by proposing a Bayesian framework that systematically integrates historical information to stabilize variance component estimation and better quantify uncertainty. Our Bayesian linear mixed model (BLMM) reformulation uses priors and Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods to maintain the variance components as positive, yielding more realistic distributional estimates. Furthermore, our model incorporates historical prior information by managing MET data in successive historical data windows. Variance component prior and posterior distributions are shown to be conjugate and belong to the inverse gamma and inverse Wishart families. While Bayesian methodology is increasingly being used for analyzing MET data, to the best of our knowledge, this study comprises one of the first serious attempts to objectively inform priors in the context of MET data. This refers to the proposed Bayesian updating approach. To demonstrate the framework, we consider an application where posterior variance component samples are plugged into an A-optimality experimental design criterion to determine the average optimal allocations of trials to agro-ecological zones in a sub-divided target population of environments (TPE). Keywords: LMM, linear mixed models; BLUP, best linear unbiased prediction; BLMM, Bayesian linear mixed model; ESS, effective sample size; FA, factor-analytic; HMC, Hamiltonian Monte Carlo; INLA, integrated nested Laplace approximation; VI, variational inference; MET, multi-environment trials; MLE, maximum likelihood estimates; MCMC, Markov chain Monte Carlo; MSE, mean squared error; NUTS, No-U-Turn Sampler; RCBD, randomized complete block design; REML, residual (restricted) maximum likelihood; TPE, target population of environments; US, unstructured; VCU, value for cultivation and use. 1 Introduction Multi-environment trials (MET) for plant breeding play a central role in modern variety testing, as they provide the empirical basis for assessing genotype performance across diverse environments ( 28 ; 36 ). Their importance extends beyond simple performance evaluation: MET are routinely employed in value for cultivation and use (VCU) variety testing, typically conducted in 2–3 year cycles and in long-term stability trials that enable the disentanglement of genetic from non-genetic trends over time ( 19 ; 33 ). These applications highlight the dual function of MET as both a short-term genotype evaluation tool and a long-term monitoring system for genetic progress. They also play a key role in plant breeding programs, where newly developed candidate lines need to be evaluated across diverse target populations of environments (TPE). The statistical backbone of MET analysis is traditionally known to be the linear mixed model (LMM), with variance components point estimated via residual (restricted) maximum likelihood (REML) ( 24 ; 13 ). While REML has become the standard approach, several well documented issues remain. First, variance component estimates may be shrunk to exactly zero when signals are weak ( 9 ), implicitly dropping random effects from the model and thereby reducing accuracy of the analysis( 40 ). Second, although the incorporation of more historical data could, in principle, improve the precision of variance component estimation, the increasing complexity of random effect structures often leads to convergence difficulties as the amount of data grows ( 39 ). These limitations motivate the search for alternative inferential frameworks that can better exploit historical information while maintaining computational stability. A promising alternative is the adoption of a fully Bayesian approach, where variance components of random effects are treated as random variables with prior distributions, and posterior inference is obtained using Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods. When sufficient historical data is available, Bayesian methods can provide more robust and stable distributional estimates of variance components, particularly if priors are carefully chosen ( 8 ; 5 ; 23 ; 6 ). Such approaches provide a principled way to quantify uncertainty in variance component estimation. It is surprising that for variety testing, however, hardly any attention seems to have been paid to leveraging historical databases to objectively inform variance component priors across successive historical windows. Addressing this gap, the present work develops a Bayesian framework for analyzing large historical MET databases, in which variance component priors are regularly updated as new data from current testing cycles become available. Following the terminology of Section 5.5 in the textbook of 37 , this iterative incorporation of historical information is referred to as a Bayesian updating approach. In addition to the prior information in the variance components justified by real historical data, we consider this approach to be more robust than the common practice of feeding a large MET dataset into the Bayesian linear mixed model (BLMM) all at once. We expect our framework to deliver a basis for a new generation of BLMM for MET that is more meaningful in terms of the systematic incorporation of prior knowledge and is potentially more efficient and more stable than other current models, which still do not benefit from data usage in historical windows. Note that our proposed method can be applied in two closely related contexts: (i) breeding programs and (ii) variety testing. While these areas differ in their objectives and operational structures, they share many methodological commonalities in the analysis of MET data, making our framework relevant for both. For demonstration purposes, we consider a long-term dataset based on VCU trials for rice in Bangladesh, described in 33 . This data clearly falls into category (ii), where we went through an implementation example. First, we specified and implemented our Bayesian updating framework. It contains four climatic zones of Bangladesh. Second, we illustrated Bayesian updating, considering an optimal design problem in MET for a sub-divided TPE, as discussed by 30 . 2 Materials and Methods 2.1 Data The experimental design of the data is described in 33 . 41 varieties released in the winter season and 45 varieties released in the monsoon season were examined for the years from 2001-2002 to 2020-2021 in Bangladesh. Their grain yield was measured in tons per hectare (t/ha). The trials were carried out as a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with three replicates at eight different locations in Bangladesh. The eight locations can be assigned to four climatic zones of Bangladesh. While some varieties were released in the years from 1970 to 2001, other varieties were added to the dataset after their release. Every year, a new randomization is carried out for the current set of genotypes. Based on that, it becomes clear that the genotypes in each replicate nested in the location will not be allocated to the same individual plot each year by design. This becomes important when modeling the data. It should be mentioned that we labeled the varieties with respect to three different genotype groups: ’Short’, ’Medium’, and ’Long’. The Winter season genotype group ’Medium’ data is sufficient for the

Read the complete text