Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin–Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number
Emma R. Bouckley 1, Sam F. Lewin 2, Adrien Lefauve 3,4 · 2026
Read Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin–Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number by Emma R. Bouckley 1, Sam F. Lewin 2, Adrien Lefauve 3,4 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-16173.txt.
Introduction
Bouckley, Lewin, and Lefauve study secondary shear instability in the thin braids joining Kelvin-Helmholtz billows in layered shear flow. Strain from the billows steadies the braids yet squeezes their tilted density surfaces, boosting baroclinic shear that lets disturbances grow fast. Their time-dependent model, checked against simulations at very high Reynolds numbers, shows instability can start well before the main billow saturates when stratification is strong.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Emma R. Bouckley 1, Sam F. Lewin 2, Adrien Lefauve 3,4 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35104 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.16173
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin–Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number Emma R. Bouckley 1, Sam F. Lewin 2, Adrien Lefauve 3,4 Abstract We study the onset of two-dimensional secondary shear instability (SSI) in the braid regions connecting primary Kelvin-Helmholtz billows in stratified shear flows. While strain induced by the billows stabilises the braids, it also compresses their tilted isopycnals, enhancing baroclinic shear that enables rapid perturbation growth. By modifying the classical analysis of Corcos & Sherman ( J. Fluid Mech. 73 , 241-264, 1976) in braid-aligned coordinates and adding an additional stability criterion based on the ratio of strain rate to shear, we develop an inviscid, time-dependent model for the braid and the onset of SSI. We show that the criterion for instability can be achieved significantly earlier than the saturation of the primary billow at sufficiently high initial Richardson number \Ri \Ri , as increased stratification slows billow growth while accelerating baroclinic shear production in the braid. Two-dimensional direct numerical simulations up to Reynolds numbers \Reynolds = 10 7 \Reynolds=10^{7} quantify the role of viscosity. At high \Reynolds \Reynolds , we find that SSI indeed develops early in the braid, as predicted by the inviscid model, while the primary billow is still growing and before viscosity slows braid thinning. These results provide a mechanistic explanation for field observations of braid-dominated mixing and suggest that, at geophysically relevant \Ri \Ri and \Reynolds \Reynolds , SSI can control the three-dimensional turbulent transition and ensuing diapycnal mixing by preceding and pre-empting both vortex pairing instabilities and secondary convective instabilities in the billow core. \Crefname@preamble equationEquationEquations \Crefname@preamble figureFigureFigures \Crefname@preamble tableTableTables \Crefname@preamble pagePagePages \Crefname@preamble partPartParts \Crefname@preamble chapterChapterChapters \Crefname@preamble sectionSectionSections \Crefname@preamble appendixAppendixAppendices \Crefname@preamble enumiItemItems \Crefname@preamble footnoteFootnoteFootnotes \Crefname@preamble theoremTheoremTheorems \Crefname@preamble lemmaLemmaLemmas \Crefname@preamble corollaryCorollaryCorollaries \Crefname@preamble propositionPropositionPropositions \Crefname@preamble definitionDefinitionDefinitions \Crefname@preamble resultResultResults \Crefname@preamble exampleExampleExamples \Crefname@preamble remarkRemarkRemarks \Crefname@preamble noteNoteNotes \Crefname@preamble algorithmAlgorithmAlgorithms \Crefname@preamble listingListingListings \Crefname@preamble lineLineLines \crefname@preamble equationeq.eqs. \crefname@preamble figurefig.figs. \crefname@preamble pagepagepages \crefname@preamble tabletabletables \crefname@preamble partpartparts \crefname@preamble chapterchapterchapters \crefname@preamble sectionsectionsections \crefname@preamble appendixappendixappendices \crefname@preamble enumiitemitems \crefname@preamble footnotefootnotefootnotes \crefname@preamble theoremtheoremtheorems \crefname@preamble lemmalemmalemmas \crefname@preamble corollarycorollarycorollaries \crefname@preamble propositionpropositionpropositions \crefname@preamble definitiondefinitiondefinitions \crefname@preamble resultresultresults \crefname@preamble exampleexampleexamples \crefname@preamble remarkremarkremarks \crefname@preamble notenotenotes \crefname@preamble algorithmalgorithmalgorithms \crefname@preamble listinglistinglistings \crefname@preamble linelinelines \cref@isstackfull \@tempstack \@crefcopyformats sectionsubsection \@crefcopyformats subsectionsubsubsection \@crefcopyformats appendixsubappendix \@crefcopyformats subappendixsubsubappendix \@crefcopyformats figuresubfigure \@crefcopyformats tablesubtable \@crefcopyformats equationsubequation \@crefcopyformats enumienumii \@crefcopyformats enumiienumiii \@crefcopyformats enumiiienumiv \@crefcopyformats enumivenumv \@labelcrefdefinedefaultformats 1 Introduction The transition to turbulence from Kelvin–Helmholtz (KH) instability in stably stratified, parallel shear flows is a long-standing open problem in fluid dynamics with broad geophysical and astrophysical relevance. Classically, this transition is assumed to occur after normal mode perturbations grow to finite amplitude, producing quasi two-dimensional vortex structures (referred to as billows) that subsequently collapse, resulting in the rapid onset of three-dimensional motions. Importantly, the properties of subsequent turbulence and mixing are sensitive to the details of the transition ( Caulfield 2021 ; Mashayek & Peltier 2013 ) . At high Reynolds number, the finite amplitude billow structure is subject to a wide range of secondary instabilities ( Mashayek & Peltier 2012b ; Mashayek & Peltier 2012a ) that may be grouped broadly into three classes. The first class consists of vortex pairing instabilities (e.g. Klaassen & Peltier 1989 ) occurring at subharmonics of the most unstable primary streamwise wavenumber. The second class extracts their energy from unstable density gradients in the billow core and are referred to as secondary convective instabilities (e.g. Klaassen & Peltier 1985 ). The third class instead extracts their energy from the narrow, inclined strips of vorticity connecting adjacent billows, referred to as braids ( Corcos & Sherman 1976 ; Staquet 1995 ; Smyth 2003 ) . Though a range of braid instabilities are possible ( Mashayek & Peltier 2012b ; Mashayek & Peltier 2012a ) , this study focuses specifically on secondary shear instability (SSI), which produces trains of vortices that are advected along the braid and towards the cores. Turbulent transition is governed by a competition between the growth rates of these instabilities, which evolve significantly as the primary billow grows and saturates in amplitude. In the ocean, KH instability is considered a primary pathway between submesoscales and stratified turbulence ( Smyth & Moum 2012 ) , with coherent billow structures observed from the deep ocean to the thermocline, continental shelves and estuaries. In some cases, detailed acoustic, velocity and density observations ( Geyer et al. 2010 ; Vladoiu et al. 2025 ; Lefauve et al. 2026 ) show intense turbulent mixing concentrated in the braids, with large overturns rarely present. A compilation of observations from the past four decades (Appendix A of Lefauve et al. 2026 ) suggests that such braid-dominated mixing is widespread across stratification types (temperature, salinity, and turbidity interfaces) and shear-layer thicknesses spanning \approx 0.5 – 200 m, corresponding to Reynolds numbers \approx 10^{5} – 10^{8} . Providing a mechanistic and predictive basis for the hypothesis of Geyer et al. 2010 that mixing is braid-dominated at these Reynolds numbers, the present study clarifies why and when SSI is expected to control the transition to three-dimensional turbulence, thereby shaping subsequent mixing across a range of ocean flows. Seminal early work on SSI by Corcos & Sherman 1976 analysed the local flow in a tilted, braid-aligned coordinate system, assuming the resulting instabilities to be of the classical inflectional shear type. Subsequently, Staquet 1995 drew on the stability of a strip of vorticity under strain ( Dritschel et al. 1991 ) to propose a modified braid stability criterion based on the ratio of strain to shear, later adopted by Smyth 2003 and ( Mashayek & Peltier 2012b ; Mashayek & Peltier 2012a ) . Importantly, these later studies assumed either a steady or frozen-in-time background flow following saturation of the primary billow. Here, we relax this assumption and explicitly model the time-evolving steepening of the braid. This distinction is essential because, as we will show, at geophysical Reynolds numbers SSI can develop well before billow saturation and must therefore be predicted from the evolving braid. To this end, we introduce an inviscid model for the time evolution and stability of the braid in \cref modelsetup, followed by two-dimensional numerical simulations in \cref numsim. In \cref results, we present results for the onset of SSI across a range of Richardson and Reynolds numbers and examine the agreement with the inviscid model. Finally, we conclude in \cref discussion. 2 Theory \label modelsetup 2.1 Governing equations and parameters We consider a two-dimensional, stably stratified, vertically sheared layer evolving in time t with streamwise coordinate x and vertical coordinate z . The flow is incompressible, with small density variations under the Boussinesq approximation. The dimensionless governing equations and initial conditions are \displaystyle\nabla\cdot\bm u=0,\qquad\frac{D\bm u}{Dt}=-\nabla p+\Ri\,b\,\bm{\hat{z}}+\frac{1}{\Reynolds}\nabla^{2}\bm u,\qquad\frac{Db}{Dt}=\frac{1}{\Reynolds\,\Prandtl}\nabla^{2}b, (1) \displaystyle\bm u(z,\;t=0)=\tanh(z)\,\bm{\hat{x}},\qquad b(z,\;t=0)=\tanh(z). (2) All lengths are scaled by the shear layer half-depth d , whilst velocities and buoyancy are scaled with half the dimensional velocity and buoyancy differences across the shear layer u_{0} and b_{0} . \Cref govnd,ICnd include three dimensionless numbers, the Reynolds number \Reynolds , the Richardson number \Ri , and the Prandtl number \Prandtl : \Reynolds=\frac{u_{0}\,d}{\nu},\qquad\Ri=\frac{b_{0}\,d}{u_{0}^{2}},\qquad\Prandtl=\frac{\nu}{\kappa}=1, (3) where \nu and \kappa are the kinematic viscosity and buoyancy diffusivity, respectively. 2.2 Inviscid model of braid evolution \label theoreticalbraidanalysis Following Corcos & Sherman 1976 (hereafter CS76), we begin by defining a braid-aligned coordinate system tilted at an average