The Econometrics of Matching with Transferable Utility: A Progress Report

Pierre-André Chiappori, Dam Linh Nguyen, Bernard Salanié · 2026

Read The Econometrics of Matching with Transferable Utility: A Progress Report by Pierre-André Chiappori, Dam Linh Nguyen, Bernard Salanié (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-16127.txt.

Introduction

Chiappori, Nguyen, and Salanie survey recent matching markets with fully transferable utility and separable joint surplus, after Choo and Siow from 2006. Mixing theory and simulations, they show the separable approach holds up well to omitted variables and non-separabilities. They close with a caveat on data needs and imbalanced datasets.

Catalog record

CREATORPierre-André Chiappori, Dam Linh Nguyen, Bernard Salanié
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42930
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.16127

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Econometrics of Matching with Transferable Utility: A Progress Report Thanks: We thank Alfred Galichon, Jeremy Fox, Thierry Magnac, and Shruti Sinha for helpful comments. A previous version of this paper was circulated under the title “Matching with Random Components: Simulations”. We dedicate this paper to the memory of our friend Yinghua He. Pierre-André Chiappori, Dam Linh Nguyen, Bernard Salanié Abstract Since ? , a burgeoning literature has analyzed matching markets when utility is perfectly transferable and the joint surplus is separable. We take stock of recent methodological developments in this area. Combining theoretical arguments and simulations, we show that the separable approach is reasonably robust to omitted variables and/or non-separabilities. We conclude with a caveat on data requirements and imbalanced datasets. Introduction The empirical analysis of matching markets has made considerable progress in recent years. We will focus here on markets where partners exchange transfers freely. In the usual terminology, we study matching markets with perfectly transferable utility (hereafter “TU”). In most matching markets, observationally identical agents end up with very different matching outcomes: some may be unmatched, and others will be matched to partners with variable observable characteristics. This can be rationalized by introducing frictions, unobserved heterogeneity, or a mixture of both. As explained in ? , these two groups of rationalizations have essentially identical predictions for cross-sectional data; they can only be distinguished with data featuring transitions, which are often unavailable to the analyst. We choose here to model the dispersion of outcomes using unobserved heterogeneity. More precisely, we work with the class of models pioneered by ? , which incorporates a quasi-additive error structure called separability by ? . ? ( ? , ? ) study the properties of separable models in much more detail. ? show that this class of models can be easily estimated using minimum distance, which often boils down to generalized least squares; and that the Choo and Siow model can also be estimated with Poisson GLM. Beyond ? , this framework has been applied by ? to changes in the marital college premium in the US. ? used it to analyze cross-border marriages in South-East Asia, and ? to describe matching on income levels in the marriage market. It was also applied to the (many-to-many) market for car parts by ? ; to the labor market (in a many-to-one version) by ? ; and to mergers and acquisitions (a roommate problem) by ? . It was extended to continuous types by ? to study the contribution of personality traits to marital surplus; by ? to imperfectly transferable utilities; and by ? to non-bipartite matching in order to compare same-sex and different-sex marriages. By definition, separability rules out the interaction between partners’ unobserved heterogeneity in the production of joint surplus. While it is a very useful assumption for keeping the model tractable, it is also restrictive, especially if the set of characteristics available to the analyst is small. A standard intuition would suggest that this may not matter much if unobserved characteristics are drawn independently of observed characteristics. However, we are dealing here with a two-sided market where we cannot just transpose this intuition. The first goal of this paper is to explore the consequences of relaxing separability on equilibrium matching patterns, utilities, and division of surplus. We will also quantify the misspecifications that result from mistakenly assuming separability when estimating a non-separable model. Theoretical arguments and a Monte Carlo simulation suggest that non-separability impacts matching patterns and utilities in ways that, ex post, seem intuitive. It takes a rather large amount of non-separability to see a qualitative difference from the separable case, however. We find that when we estimate a non-separable model as if it were separable, the estimated complementarities in surplus are surprisingly robust. This is reassuring since we have known since ? that complementarities play a crucial role in TU matching markets. Our conclusions are strongest when the distributions of the observable characteristics of the partners are similar (“symmetric margins”). As we will see, non-separabilities matter more when markets are very unbalanced. The second contribution of the paper is to point out that estimates may be fragile when the data contain matching cells of very different size. We give a simple, two-by-two example to show that the asymptotic variance of the estimator may be dominated by the inverse of the size of the smallest cell, unless precautions are taken to minimize its influence. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 1 introduces the class of separable matching models with perfectly transferable utilities. Section 2 discusses the separability assumption and its implications. Section 3 explores the consequences of omitted variables and of mistakenly imposing separability. Section 4 discusses the effects of imbalanced data, and how to remedy them. We conclude with some directions for further work. 1 Model and Methods We focus throughout on a bipartite one-to-one model of matching with unobserved heterogeneity and perfectly transferable utilities 1 1 1 ? extend the analysis to more complex separable models. . Since it is similar to Becker’s “marriage market”, we will use that terminology and refer to potential partners as “men” and “women”. Our framework easily accommodates other interpretations. We maintain some of the standard assumptions: matching is frictionless and all potential partners have the same information. The analyst only observes a subset of individual characteristics. Men are indexed by \displaystyle i\in\mathcal{I} and women by \displaystyle j\in\mathcal{J} . Each man \displaystyle i (resp. woman \displaystyle j ) has a “type” \displaystyle x_{i}\in\mathcal{X} (resp. \displaystyle y_{j}\in\mathcal{Y} ). This is observable to all men, all women, and to the analyst. When a man \displaystyle i and a woman \displaystyle j marry, their match generates a surplus \displaystyle\tilde{\Phi}_{ij} which they can share freely. Singles match to “0”: a single man \displaystyle i attains a utility of \displaystyle\tilde{\Phi}_{i0} and a single woman \displaystyle j attains \displaystyle\tilde{\Phi}_{0j} . This paper will assume that the sets of types are finite: \displaystyle\mathcal{X}=\{1,\ldots,X\} and \displaystyle\mathcal{Y}=\{1,\ldots,Y\} . As mentioned in the introduction, ? extend the model to continuous types. We will denote by \displaystyle\bm{\tilde{\Phi}}=(\tilde{\Phi}_{ij})_{i=1,\ldots,I;j=1,\ldots,J} the matrix of surpluses. A matching is a list of numbers \displaystyle(\mu_{ij},\mu_{i0},\mu_{0j})_{i=1,\ldots,I;j=1,\ldots,J} , with \displaystyle\mu_{ij}=1 if \displaystyle i and \displaystyle j match, \displaystyle\mu_{i0}=1 if \displaystyle i is single, etc. We focus on the stable matching (it is generically unique). Since only types are observed by the analyst, the data consist of matching patterns : the numbers of men and women of each type, which we denote \displaystyle n_{x} and \displaystyle m_{y} , and the numbers of marriages \displaystyle\mu_{xy} between men of each type \displaystyle x and women of each type \displaystyle y . By construction, \displaystyle\textstyle\mu_{x0}=n_{x}-\sum_{y=1}^{Y}\mu_{xy} and \displaystyle\textstyle\mu_{0y}=m_{y}-\sum_{x=1}^{X}\mu_{xy} are the numbers of single men of type \displaystyle x and of single women of type \displaystyle y . Note that in some empirical applications, the analyst may not observe singles—only the numbers of marriages \displaystyle\mu_{xy} . We denote by \displaystyle\bm{\Phi} and \displaystyle\bm{\mu} the matrix of surpluses and the matching patterns, respectively; and \displaystyle\bm{r}=(\bm{n},\bm{m}) the margins , i.e., the numbers of men and women of each type. Like most of the literature, we work with the large market limit in which the vectors \displaystyle\bm{n} and \displaystyle\bm{m} grow proportionately. 1.1 Separability The separable model restricts the

Read the complete text