Hilbert Space Fragmentation and Gauge Symmetry

Joao C. Pinto Barros · 2026

Read Hilbert Space Fragmentation and Gauge Symmetry by Joao C. Pinto Barros (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-15820.txt.

Introduction

Budde and two colleagues trace a fresh gauge-like rule that lives only in some shards of the split S=1 dipole-keeping spin chain. The chain's own one-way gauge-like rules can tag a vast count of its shards, though most shards lack shift-evenness. Running that chain, which itself lacks gauge freedom, still yields a true quantum run of a gauge theory.

Catalog record

CREATORJoao C. Pinto Barros
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21892
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.15820

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hilbert Space Fragmentation and Gauge Symmetry Joao C. Pinto Barros Abstract The Hamiltonian formulation of lattice gauge theories plays a central role in quantum simulations of gauge theories, and understanding their spectrum and other properties is expected to become crucial in the upcoming years. The relevant Hamiltonians in this framework possess local symmetry at each lattice site and may exhibit higher-form symmetries. There are then an exponentially large number of dynamically disconnected symmetry sectors, most of which are not translation-invariant. An exponential number of dynamically disconnected sectors, i.e., Hilbert space fragmentation, can also occur in systems in which no such symmetries have been identified. In this contribution, we describe an emergent gauge symmetry that is valid only in a subset of sectors of the fragmented S = 1 S=1 dipole-conserving spin chain. These non-invertible symmetries can label exponentially many of the model’s sectors. Simulating this Hamiltonian, which is not gauge-invariant, yields an exact quantum simulation of a gauge theory. [a]Thea Budde 1 Introduction Real-time dynamics quantities have remained a major challenge in lattice Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) since Monte Carlo simulations are performed in Euclidean time [ 14 ] . This has been a major motivation to move towards a new paradigm in which quantum simulations of QCD are performed alongside (classical) Monte Carlo simulations. Quantum technologies are being developed rapidly, promising efficient simulations of quantum many-body systems, including gauge theories [ 16 ] . This has motivated renewed interest in the study of gauge theories in the Hamiltonian formulation with finite-dimensional local Hilbert spaces. While QCD remains a far-reaching goal, other interesting questions have emerged in simpler gauge theories. One such aspect is the thermalization of closed systems. The ergodicity of closed systems evolving in time underlies their thermalization [ 31 , 12 , 13 , 15 ] . In recent years, it has become increasingly evident that ergodicity does not hold in a wide range of systems [ 9 , 20 ] . Thermalization can occur if the system ergodically explores the accessible Hilbert space, subject to energy conservation and other symmetries. To verify this, ergodicity for each symmetry sector must be checked individually. Phenomena under which only a small set of initial states break the expectations of thermalization, or in which only a subextensive fraction of the spectrum is affected, are classed as weak ergodicity breaking. Since only a small part of the spectrum is affected, this will not be visible in common statistical spectral analyses, such as level-spacing ratios. These have commonly been used to test ergodicity and to examine how the high-energy spectrum of interacting Hamiltonians can statistically resemble that of a random matrix [ 31 , 13 ] . An example where weak ergodicity breaking occurs is when the spectrum of the Hamiltonian contains quantum many-body scars (QMBS) [ 20 , 9 ] . The term QMBS encompasses multiple classes of phenomena. They were originally established in the PXP model [ 30 , 4 ] , where a small set of eigenstates with approximately equidistant energies has unusually large overlap with two product states. Evolving these two states leads to prolonged oscillations, beyond the timescales at which thermalization is expected. The set of eigenstates is not thermal and does not fulfill the requirements of ETH. There are other models with similar phenomena [ 11 , 6 ] , and there are models with non-thermal eigenstates that do not have equidistant energies and therefore do not lead to oscillations [ 18 , 2 , 7 ] . In these cases, initial states with low entanglement evolve to values that differ from those expected under thermalization. A third class of QMBS consists of models with a small set of initial states whose dynamics will never mix with the rest of the Hilbert space, even after infinite time [ 22 , 26 , 20 , 32 ] . In the case of strong ergodicity breaking, the system fails to thermalize from most initial states [ 20 ] . Beyond integrable models [ 13 , 34 , 19 ] , this has been observed in models with Hilbert space fragmentation [ 20 , 29 , 21 , 23 ] . In the latter case, states initialized in some product state remain confined to a small subspace of the Hilbert space. Concretely, let \ket{\psi_{0}} be a state on the Hilbert space. If the system is initialized in this state, it will be within its Krylov sector \mathcal{K}(\ket{\psi_{0}})\equiv\mathrm{span}\left\{\ket{\psi_{0}},H\ket{\psi_{0}},H^{2}\ket{\psi_{0}},\ ...\right\} (1) at any future time. Naturally, different product basis states can share the same Krylov sector, and they commonly do for generic states and interacting Hamiltonians. However, this need not be the case in general, and the Hilbert space can decompose into several distinct Krylov sectors. In an extreme case, the number of distinct Krylov sectors in the product basis can scale exponentially with system size. This is called “Hilbert space fragmentation”. For such a product basis, the Hamiltonian becomes block-diagonal, and many of the Krylov sectors are small. One can distinguish the cases where most of the Hilbert space lies in a single Krylov sector from those where even the largest Krylov sector grows asymptotically more slowly than the dimension of the product Hilbert space with system size. The latter case is called “strong fragmentation”. Fragmentation cannot be explained by what has been considered “standard” symmetries, since they can only lead to a polynomial scaling in the number of symmetry sectors [ 20 ] . In this context, “standard” symmetries are those that are generated by global sums over local densities. In Ref. [ 8 ] , we have shown that a large class of generalized symmetries and gauge symmetry leads to exponential scaling of the number of symmetry sectors in the tensor-product basis, and therefore to fragmentation. If these symmetries are not resolved, this may be mistaken for ergodicity breaking. Non-invertible symmetries, specifically higher-form partial isometries, may be a mechanism underlying the fragmentation of other models, and we refer to [ 8 ] for details. While standard symmetries admit a unitary representation and are therefore invertible on the full Hilbert space, it has recently been shown that this is not necessary [ 25 ] . When a partial isometry D=UP commutes with the Hamiltonian, transition probabilities are also conserved. Here, U is unitary and P is a projector onto a subspace of the Hamiltonian. Such symmetries have not yet been considered in the context of ergodicity breaking and could underlie some of the unexplained phenomena. In these proceedings, we demonstrate that even when a local symmetry of the Hamiltonian cannot be identified, a fragmented model can still have a set of Krylov sectors with an emergent gauge symmetry that is not present in other Krylov sectors. This may be interpreted as non-invertible gauge symmetry. Sectors with non-invertible gauge symmetry realize the dynamics of gauge theories and can therefore be used for quantum simulations of gauge theories. The remainder of this contribution is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we introduce the so-called “Dipole Conserving Spin Chain”, which exhibits fragmentation. We then describe how certain fragments have emergent conserved local quantities which constitute a U(1) gauge symmetry. In Section 3 , we interpret this from the perspective of non-invertible symmetry.

Read the complete text