Estimating government worker skills

Kevin Michael Frick, Jonas Gathen · 2026

Read Estimating government worker skills by Kevin Michael Frick, Jonas Gathen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-15819.txt.

Introduction

Frick and Gathen estimate government worker skills in Indonesia, where output is hard to observe and pay may not reflect ability, by linking skills to observables through private-sector wages and machine learning. Using household panel data from 1988 to 2014, they find government skills fell steadily relative to the private sector as the most skilled workers moved out. Conditional on skills, the Indonesian government still pays a wage premium of 43 percent.

Catalog record

CREATORKevin Michael Frick, Jonas Gathen
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE123212
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.15819

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Estimating government worker skills Application to worker selection and wage setting in Indonesia Thanks: For helpful feedback and comments, we want to thank in no particular order: Matteo Bobba, Mitch Downey, Oscar Fentanes, Olivier de Groote, Christian Hellwig, Johanna Isman, Guohui Jiang, Pascal Lavergne, Thierry Magnac, Stéphane Straub, and Jens Wäckerle. We are indebted to the feedback by seminar and conference participants at the IAST Political Economy workshops, the TSE Macroeconomics, Econometrics, and Development workshops, the EUDN development conference in Passau 2020, Stockholm University’s applied micro workshop and the workshop of the World Bank’s Bureaucracy Lab. All remaining errors are our own. Kevin Michael Frick, Jonas Gathen Abstract We propose a new approach to estimate government worker skills, a setting where output is hard to observe and wages may be uninformative about skills. The approach uses wages in comparable jobs in the private sector and machine learning tools to link skills to skill-related observables. We apply the approach to rich Indonesian household-level panel data from 1988-2014, showing two main applications. First, government skills have continuously declined relative to the private sector, driven by the most skilled workers ending up in the private sector. Second, the Indonesian government pays a wage premium of 43% conditional on skills. \NewTableCommand \tinytableDefineColor [3] 1 Introduction How do relative skills of government workers evolve over the course of development, and how does this affect changes in the quality of government services? Does the government manage to select highly skilled workers? Are government wages informative about underlying skills and does the government pay a wage premium? A key ingredient for answering these questions is a good measure of government worker skills. This paper provides a new approach to estimate such skills, showing how to estimate unobserved skills in potential government jobs for any worker in the economy. The paper then applies the estimation approach to rich household-level panel data from Indonesia over a period of 25 years to study (1) systematic changes in the skills of government workers and their selection and (2) government wage setting. Traditional approaches in economics measure a worker’s skill — or marginal productivity of labor — either directly by observing output and making an assumption on the underlying production function ( 1 ; 19 ) or by drawing on observed wages assuming a wage setting process that makes wages a noisy signal of a worker’s skill ( 61 ; 39 ; 45 ) . For the skill estimation of government workers, both approaches are problematic, because government output is usually unobserved (think of the output of a bureaucracy), government worker wages often follow rigid wage-setting rules that disguise underlying skill differences ( 49 ) and wage competition may not force bureaucracies to change wages. This paper provides a new approach to estimate government worker skills that is applicable in settings where government output is unobserved and government wages are uninformative about skill differences. In summary, the approach estimates skills from wages in comparable jobs in the private sector, relates these skills to skill-related observables using machine learning tools, and then predicts government worker skills out-of-sample. The idea is that there are jobs in the private sector in similar social service occupations and with similar task contents as government jobs but for which wages — however imperfect — are at least a very noisy signal of skills in these jobs. This skill signal, extracted as an individual fixed effect, can then be regressed on a rich set of skill-related observables. We show how machine learning algorithms are particularly useful here to disentangle actual skills from estimation noise and other wage determinants. In the last step, we can then enforce the estimated relationship between individual-specific skills in comparable jobs and skill-related observables to obtain an out-of-sample potential skill estimate for government jobs. This provides an estimate of skills in government jobs for any worker in the economy for whom we observe these skill-related observables. The approach can thus also be used in other settings in which researchers need to estimate potential job-specific skills for workers who work in other jobs with very different skill requirements. The approach relies on rich skill-related observables as it defines relevant skills solely as a function of observables. Unobserved skills pose two distinct problems for the approach. The first is a measurement limitation: To the extent that some skill dimensions are unobserved and only weakly correlated with observables, the approach will miss these skill dimensions. Importantly, this does not immediately bias the skill estimate since we are not interested in estimating the causal effect of a change in a specific covariate x . The second problem is selection. Since we use comparable jobs in the private sector to estimate skills in the government, an issue is if comparable private sector workers are systematically selected on skill-related unobservables that directly affect their wages (compared to government workers). While rich skill-related observables ameliorate selection concerns, we also show how to extend the baseline approach to correct for selection ( 55 ) . We apply the estimation approach to Indonesia between 1988 and 2014 drawing on a large and high-quality representative panel that tracks individuals over time. The data — the Indonesian Family and Life Survey (IFLS) — is particularly suited for the estimation approach as it features (1) a large sample of government and private sector workers across many different occupations, (2) one of the longest wage and employment panels in a developing country context, and (3) an exceptional breadth of skill-related variables such as educational background, national exam scores, test results for self-administered Raven tests ( 40 ) , cognition and memory tasks, the big-5 personality traits ( 54 ) and elicited risk and time preferences. Drawing on the IFLS, we estimate individual-level skills in government-like jobs using comparable private sector workers. We define comparable jobs in the private sector as jobs in similar occupations and sectors as government jobs, and with a similar set of worker demographics, which are enforced using propensity score weighting. The approach draws on a noisy skill signal from comparable private sector workers, which is the worker wage fixed effect after purging the wage from (1) experience effects using a standard Mincerian regression and (2) from changes in the equilibrium skill price using the flat spot identification approach in 32 . To identify skills, we use off-the-shelf machine learning algorithms to predict skills from these noisy skill signals. We find a Gradient Boosted Model (GBM) to perform best, far outperforming more traditional methods like a basis expansion, precisely because machine learning algorithms are trained to not overfit, which is crucial in our prediction exercise with noisy input data. Having estimated government worker skills, we then illustrate two main applications for which skill estimates are key. In the first application, we look at changes in government worker skills, the selection of government workers based on skills and how relative skills of government workers have evolved. We find that Indonesian government workers are strongly positively selected on skills and that their skills have also increased over time as new cohorts with higher skills entered the labor force. However, we find that relative skills of government workers actually declined over time in comparison to the private sector.

Read the complete text