The Power of Information for Intermediate States in Contract Design

Yirui Zhang, Zhixuan Fang · 2026

Read The Power of Information for Intermediate States in Contract Design by Yirui Zhang, Zhixuan Fang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-15636.txt.

Introduction

Zhang and Fang extend contract design with intermediate states revealed during delegation, beyond final outcomes alone. They compare pay-halfway contracts, which pay on intermediate as well as final states, against terminate-halfway contracts, which let the principal stop on bad intermediate states. Both can beat standard contracts, and the paper maps when and how much intermediate-state information helps.

Catalog record

CREATORYirui Zhang, Zhixuan Fang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE86568
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.15636

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Power of Information for Intermediate States in Contract Design Thanks: Corresponding author: Zhixuan Fang at [email protected] . This work is supported by Tsinghua University Dushi Program. Yirui Zhang, Zhixuan Fang Abstract . In the conventional principal-agent problem, a principal delegates a task to an agent and formulates a contract to incentivize the agent’s actions on behalf of the principal. However, this framework overlooks the information that is possibly available during the delegation process in some scenarios. To address this limitation, we propose a novel model that incorporates multiple intermediate states to capture such information revealed during the delegation. Furthermore, to evaluate the impact of the information embedded in these intermediate states, we introduce two distinct contracts: the pay-halfway contract, which provides payments based not only on final outcomes but also on intermediate states, and the terminate-halfway contract, which allows the principal to terminate the delegation process upon encountering undesirable intermediate states. This leads to the question of whether and how these contract types can leverage intermediate-state information? In particular, we ask: Can these contract types outperform standard contracts, and if so, when and to what extent? We answer the first question affirmatively and provide several important insights regarding the second, shedding light on the circumstances in which intermediate-state-aware contracts yield substantial advantages. 1. Introduction Contract theory is a fundamental area of economics that examines how contractual arrangements are formulated in the presence of information asymmetry. Prior research has typically utilized the principal-agent framework to study the dynamic between the involved parties, where the principal (employer) often lacks complete information about the agent’s (employee’s) actions or effort levels. This uncertainty necessitates the creation of incentive-compatible contracts that motivate the agent to act in the principal’s best interest while considering the agent’s self-interest. In the classic setup, the principal delegates decision-making authority to the agent and can only observe the final outcome, not the actions taken by the agent. This leads to a potential moral hazard, as the agent may not act in the best interest of the principal. To mitigate this problem, the principal designs incentive-compatible contracts that link compensation to observable outcomes in order to encourage desirable behavior. The agent, seeking to maximize her own benefits, will then take actions based on the promised compensations. Much of the existing literature in this field ( ( 3 ; 7 ; 12 ) ) is dedicated to determining the optimal contract arrangement from the principal’s perspective. However, real-world delegation often allows the principal to observe some information during the process. For instance, when assigning a project to an employee, the employer may receive mid-term progress reports, enabling them to monitor the project’s advancement. Similarly, in supply chain scenarios, suppliers may provide periodic updates on the production process. Such intermediate information is not captured in the standard principal-agent framework. To address this limitation, we propose a new model within contract theory: the two-stage delegation process. This model incorporates intermediate states to capture information revealed during the delegation. Specifically, the process consists of two stages: (i) The agent takes an initial action and transitions to a specific intermediate state, which embeds the information about the delegation process. (ii) At the intermediate state, the agent takes further action, resulting in an outcome. Importantly, the principal can observe both the intermediate state and the final outcome. This extended framework provides a more accurate representation of the dynamic nature of real-world contractual environments. Many practical settings fit naturally into our framework, including procurement, crowdsourcing, and adaptive task assignment. For example, in procurement, the evolving stages of a project can be interpreted as intermediate information revealed progressively over the course of the delegation process. Consequently, within this two-stage model that incorporates intermediate states, it becomes both interesting and necessary to analyze how such information revelation influences contractual relationships and outcomes. 1.1. Main Results In this section, we summarize our main results, focusing on the central question: whether and how information embedded in intermediate states benefits the principal. To explore this, we introduce two conceptually distinct contractual mechanisms: the pay-halfway contract and the terminate-halfway contract. Unlike standard contracts, which provide compensation solely based on the final outcome, the pay-halfway contract allows for compensation upon the realization of specific intermediate states, while the terminate-halfway contract permits early termination of the delegation process when undesirable intermediate states are observed. We analyze and compare the performance of these contracts against the standard outcome-based contract. The information embedded in intermediate states comprises two key types: (I) the intrinsic quality of the state, meaning how likely final actions from this state lead to valuable outcomes; and (II) the agent’s initial action choice. To examine which type(s) of information benefit the principal, and how the proposed contracts leverage them, we consider three specialized two-stage delegation processes that differ in the informational content of their intermediate states: • In the tree two-stage process, each final outcome is uniquely linked to a single intermediate state, rendering the intermediate state uninformative beyond the final outcome. (No additional information) • In the stochastic first-stage process, there is only one initial action; although intermediate states do not reveal any information about the agent’s initial choice, they carry predictive value regarding the likelihood of favorable final outcomes. (Type I information only) • In the deterministic first-stage process, each intermediate state corresponds to a unique initial action, thereby containing information both about the state itself and fully revealing the agent’s initial choice. (Type I and II information) Our results demonstrate the following: • In the tree two-stage process, both the pay-halfway and terminate-halfway contracts perform identically to the standard contract due to the lack of informative intermediate states. • In the stochastic first-stage process, the terminate-halfway contract can significantly outperform the standard contract, while the pay-halfway contract only match the standard contract. • In the deterministic first-stage process, both contracts can outperform the standard contract and extract welfare from the informative intermediate states. These findings suggest that the pay-halfway contract primarily utilizes Type II information to infer the agent’s initial action and incentivize desirable behavior. In contrast, the terminate-halfway contract makes use of both Type I and Type II information: it not only deters poor initial actions but also allows the principal to exit early from low-quality intermediate states that are likely to result in unfavorable outcomes. Finally, we compare the two newly proposed contracts directly. While the terminate-halfway contract can utilize richer information, our analysis shows that it does not always outperform the pay-halfway contract across all settings. 1.2. Related Works Contract theory, as a fundamental discipline within economics, finds application across diverse contexts. It also boasts a rich historical lineage dating back to seminal works such as ( 13 ; 10 ) . For an introductory exploration of contract theory, interested readers are directed to the comprehensive volumes ( 3 ) and the introductory chapters provided by ( 4 ) , which offer foundational insights. Contract Design Without States. Recent research in contract theory spans a wide array of topics. Without introducing states, studies such as ( 8 ) , ( 11 ) , ( 12 ) , and ( 6 ) delve into the effectiveness of diverse contract types. For instance, ( 8 ) conduct an analysis of

Read the complete text