Overcoming the Lamb Shift in System-Bath Models via KMS Detailed Balance: High-Accuracy Thermalization with Time-Bounded Interactions

Hongrui Chen, Zhiyan Ding, Ruizhe Zhang · 2026

Read Overcoming the Lamb Shift in System-Bath Models via KMS Detailed Balance: High-Accuracy Thermalization with Time-Bounded Interactions by Hongrui Chen, Zhiyan Ding, Ruizhe Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-15616.txt.

Introduction

Chen, Ding, and Zhang find a surprise in weak-coupling quantum thermal state preparation. When the Lindblad jump part meets KMS detailed balance, its fixed point lands very near the Gibbs state no matter the Lamb shift term. This holds even when the rough Lindblad map strays far from the ideal Davies form and the Lamb shift term fails to commute with the thermal state. Mix-time bounds give a full cost of order one over epsilon.

Catalog record

CREATORHongrui Chen, Zhiyan Ding, Ruizhe Zhang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE161227
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.15616

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Overcoming the Lamb Shift in System-Bath Models via KMS Detailed Balance: High-Accuracy Thermalization with Time-Bounded Interactions Hongrui Chen, Zhiyan Ding, Ruizhe Zhang Abstract We investigate quantum thermal state preparation algorithms based on system-bath interactions and uncover a surprising phenomenon in the weak-coupling regime. We rigorously prove that, if the system-bath interaction is engineered so that the transition part of the approximate Lindbladian generator satisfies the KMS detailed balance condition, then the unique fixed point of the dynamics can be made arbitrarily close to the Gibbs state in the weak-coupling limit, regardless of the structure of the Lamb shift term. Importantly, this remains true even when the approximate Lindbladian differs substantially from the ideal Davies generator and the Lamb shift term does not commute with the thermal state. Our result shows that the role of the KMS detailed balance condition extends well beyond standard Lindbladian dynamics, serving as a general principle for a broader class of dissipative systems. Furthermore, by combining this with a general perturbation framework, we bound the mixing time of the dynamics and establish an end-to-end complexity of 𝒪 ⁡ ( ε − 1 ) \mathcal{O}(\varepsilon^{-1}) for Gibbs state preparation. These guarantees apply to any Hamiltonian for which the corresponding KMS-detailed-balance Lindbladian is known to mix rapidly. I Introduction Given a Hamiltonian H and an inverse temperature \beta , the Gibbs state \rho_{\beta}=e^{-\beta H}/\mathrm{Tr}(e^{-\beta H}) is a fundamental object in quantum many-body physics, quantum chemistry, and materials science. It encodes the equilibrium properties of quantum systems and serves as a crucial resource for various applications. One leading approach to prepare the Gibbs state on a quantum computer is through simulating Lindblad dynamics, inspired by the natural thermalization process of quantum systems interacting with their environment. In this framework, the system density operator evolves under an engineered Lindblad dynamics that drives it toward the target Gibbs state. In particular, breakthrough work 6 ; 4 and follow-up 10 have demonstrated that a large class of Lindbladian dynamics can be efficiently simulated while strictly maintaining the Gibbs state as the unique fixed point of the dynamics. The key design principle behind these dynamics is engineering the dissipative and coherent terms to satisfy the Kubo–Martin–Schwinger (KMS) Detailed Balance Condition, which ensures the evolution exhibits a form of time-reversal symmetry with respect to the Gibbs state. This condition not only guarantees that the Gibbs state is stationary, but also frequently yields favorable convergence properties, enabling rigorous performance guarantees for a wide range of physically relevant models 33 ; 16 ; 1 ; 25 ; 9 ; 17 ; 26 ; 34 ; 31 ; 36 ; 2 . Despite the success of Lindbladian-simulation-based quantum Gibbs state preparation, an important challenge remains: existing Lindbladian dynamics for thermal state preparation often involve jump operators and coherent terms with highly nontrivial structure, such as linear combinations of Heisenberg evolutions of local operators. Implementing such dynamics on quantum hardware typically requires block-encoding these complicated jump operators, time-reversed Hamiltonian simulation, elaborate clock-register logic, and a large number of ancilla qubits. These requirements place such approaches well beyond the resource capabilities of early fault-tolerant quantum computers. To resolve this issue, a different class of dissipative dynamics—the system–bath interaction framework—has recently emerged 21 ; 15 ; 12 ; 35 ; 24 ; 18 ; 27 . The high-level intuition is to simulate the open quantum system dynamics from first principles by introducing a small ancillary bath register that is weakly coupled to the system register, with the joint evolution governed by an engineered Hamiltonian . Dissipation is then naturally induced by tracing out and resetting the bath after a prescribed evolution time. Note that to exactly simulate the natural thermalization process, the bath should be extremely large or infinite, whereas this system-bath interaction framework can approximately prepare the Gibbs state after sufficiently many iterations with as small as a single-qubit bath. The simple implementation avoids the significant overhead required by Lindblad dynamics-based approaches. Formally, the system density matrix \rho_{n} at the n -th iteration updates via the quantum channel \Phi_{\alpha} : \rho_{n+1}=\Phi_{\alpha}(\rho_{n}):=\mathbb{E}\left[\mathrm{Tr}_{E}\left(U_{\alpha}(T)\left(\rho_{n}\otimes\rho_{E}\right)U_{\alpha}(T)^{\dagger}\right)\right]\,, (1) where \rho_{E} is the bath density matrix reset in each iteration, and U_{\alpha}(T) denotes the unitary evolution by a carefully designed Hamiltonian H_{\alpha} acting on both system and bath registers with coupling strength \alpha . A key observation for this approach is that, similar to one of the derivations of the Lindblad master equation, in the weak-coupling limit ( \alpha\rightarrow 0 ), \Phi_{\alpha} can be approximated by a Lindbladian up to the unitary transformation: \Phi_{\alpha}(\rho)=\mathcal{U}_{S}(T)\,\circ\,\exp(\mathcal{L}\alpha^{2})\,\circ\,\mathcal{U}_{S}(T)[\rho]+\mathcal{O}(\alpha^{4})\,, (2) where \mathcal{U}_{S}(t)[\rho]:=e^{-iHt}\rho e^{iHt} is the Hamiltonian evolution only on the system part, and {\cal L} is a Lindbladian. However, none of the existing constructions can simultaneously guarantee both that {\cal L} exactly fixes the target Gibbs state and that \Phi_{\alpha} can be efficiently simulated. As a result, without carefully tuning the parameters, existing theoretical results cannot show that the fixed point of the quantum channel \Phi_{\alpha} is close to the Gibbs state, even in the weak-coupling limit. From an algorithmic perspective, overcoming this issue requires tuning the parameters in U_{\alpha}(T) and taking T=\Omega(1/\varepsilon) so that the fixed point of \Phi_{\alpha} is \varepsilon -close to the Gibbs state. However, these requirements introduce a large polynomial in 1/\varepsilon overhead in the end-to-end simulation cost for preparing an \varepsilon -accurate Gibbs state 30 . A natural question to ask is: Q1: For the system-bath interaction model, is it possible to achieve efficient high-accuracy Gibbs state preparation? Under Lindbladian-simulation-based quantum Gibbs state preparation, recent constructions of KMS-detailed-balance Lindbladians can achieve efficient, high-accuracy preparation 6 ; 10 . Motivated by the success of this KMS-detailed-balance approach, recent works 21 ; 15 engineered system–bath interactions so that part of the effective Lindbladian {\cal L} in these constructions also exactly satisfies the KMS detailed balance condition. However, this observation alone does not resolve Q1, because the resulting Lindbladian still contains an additional Lamb shift term. More specifically, the Lindbladian generator in ( 2 ) can be decomposed as {\mathcal{L}}(\rho)=-i[H_{\rm Lamb},\rho]+{\cal L}_{\rm KMS}(\rho),. (3) Here, H_{\rm Lamb} is a Hermitian term, often called the Lamb shift, and \mathcal{L}_{\rm KMS} is a Lindbladian satisfying the KMS detailed balance condition. Although \mathcal{L}_{\rm KMS} fixes the Gibbs state, the Lamb shift generally does not commute with \rho_{\beta} , with [H_{\rm Lamb},\rho_{\beta}]=\Omega(1/T) , implying that the KMS detailed balance condition alone does not remove the main bottleneck: to show that the fixed point of \Phi_{\alpha} is close to \rho_{\beta} , one still needs to choose the interaction time T sufficiently large. This requirement is very similar to that in the first construction of approximate detailed-balance Lindbladians in 5 ; see the discussion below ( 4 ). Based on the existing literature, the KMS detailed balance condition by itself does not appear sufficient to enable high-accuracy Gibbs state preparation through a system–bath interaction model. This naturally leads us to the following question: Q2: Can KMS-detailed balance provide any algorithmic benefits for the system-bath interaction framework? One main contribution of our work is to give a rigorous positive answer to Q2 within the same system-bath interaction framework. We present the first unified analysis showing that the fixed point of the quantum channels \Phi_{\alpha} in existing algorithms 12 ; 21 ; 15 can be made arbitrarily

Read the complete text