True and Pseudo-True Parameters

Isaiah Andrews, Harvey Barnhard, Jacob Carlson · 2026

Read True and Pseudo-True Parameters by Isaiah Andrews, Harvey Barnhard, Jacob Carlson (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-15563.txt.

Introduction

Andrews, Barnhard, and Carlson ask whether pseudo-true parameter values, the limits of estimates under misspecification, matter for Bayesian decision-makers. In a linear population minimum-distance problem with priors tied to the objective, they characterize prior sequences whose posteriors concentrate on the pseudo-true value. That convergence proves fragile to small prior changes, so pseudo-true values guide choices only in special cases, though simple intervals still ensure average coverage.

Catalog record

CREATORIsaiah Andrews, Harvey Barnhard, Jacob Carlson
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE86348
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.15563

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

True and Pseudo-True Parameters Isaiah Andrews, Harvey Barnhard, Jacob Carlson Abstract Parameter estimates in misspecified models converge to pseudo-true parameter values, which minimize a population objective function. Pseudo-true values often differ from quantities of economic interest, raising questions of how, if at all, they are relevant for decision-making. To study this question we consider Bayesian decision-makers facing a linear population minimum distance problem. Within a class of priors motivated by the minimum distance objective, we characterize prior sequences under which posteriors concentrate on the pseudo-true value. This convergence is fragile to small changes in priors, implying that pseudo-true values are relevant for decision-making only in special cases. Constructive results are nevertheless possible in this setting, and we derive simple confidence intervals that guarantee correct average coverage for the true parameter under every prior in the class we study, with no bound on the magnitude of misspecification. Keywords: Model Misspecification, Pseudo-True Values JEL Codes: C10, C52 1 Introduction Empirical research in economics often begins by positing a model which relates quantities of economic interest to the distribution of observable data. Researchers then use model-implied relationships, together with observed data, to construct estimates or bounds for parameters of interest. Unfortunately, commonly-used models impose assumptions which are difficult to validate, and which are sometimes rejected outright. For instance, some models impose functional form restrictions such as linearity, or distributional restrictions on latent error terms. Others impose homogeneity across economic agents, or behavioral assumptions such as utility or profit maximization. Finally, methods that aim to uncover causal or structural relationships impose assumptions regarding unconfoundedness of treatment and the scope for spillovers across units. When we have reason to doubt these assumptions, it can be unclear how to interpret model-implied estimates or bounds. Indeed, absent some restriction on model misspecification, the quantities of interest are necessarily unidentified, and we can learn nothing from data. There is a large literature on model misspecification spanning statistics and economics. An influential econometrics literature, including 29 , 14 , 25 , 15 , 2 , and 18 , studies the problem of inference under model misspecification, and avoids identification problems for the quantity of economic interest \theta by shifting the focus to “pseudo-true” parameter values, defined as the minimizers of a population objective function. Under mild conditions these papers show consistency of estimates for the pseudo-true value (in point-identified settings) or the pseudo-true identified set (in set-identified ones). Moreover, these papers provide inference results, for example showing asymptotic normality of point estimates and deriving consistent standard errors for the pseudo-true value. These results have been highly influential for empirical practice with, for instance, the “sandwich” standard error formula discussed by White (1982) now widely adopted in the context of maximum likelihood estimation. While focusing on pseudo-true values allows us to provide statistical guarantees, it leaves open the question of how, if at all, these pseudo-true values relate to the original quantities of economic interest. The literature studying inference on pseudo-true values discusses this tension, with 29 writing “[the estimator] converges to a well defined limit, and may or may not be consistent for particular parameters of interest.” Similarly, 25 writes that “[it] is important to keep in mind that the pseudo-true parameter of the misspecified model must remain the object of interest for … inference to make sense” and 15 write that “it is difficult to give economic interpretation to pseudo-true parameter values. Consequently, this limits interest in valid inference procedures for pseudo-true values.” This paper revisits the distinction between true and pseudo-true parameter values. To abstract from sampling uncertainty we consider a population minimum-distance problem in which the distribution of the data is perfectly observed. We adopt a decision-theoretic, and specifically Bayesian, perspective to ask under what conditions the posterior distribution for \theta , given the distribution of the observable data, concentrates around the pseudo-true parameter. Such concentration implies, under mild conditions, that Bayes decision rules converge to plug-in rules based on pseudo-true values. We provide three main results. First, we characterize a class of joint priors for the data distribution and \theta such that the posterior density for \theta is proportional to a transformation of the minimum distance objective function. This proportionality implies that the minimum distance objective is sufficient for decision-making, and hence an optimal way to summarize the data. This is a natural class of priors to consider in the context of minimum distance estimation, since it corresponds to a belief that the minimum distance objective captures all decision-relevant information. We show under independence and conditional mean-zero restrictions on the implied prior for model misspecification, proportionality holds if and only if an implicit misspecification prior satisfies a rotation-invariance condition. Second, we characterize prior sequences in this rotation-invariant class such that the posterior distribution concentrates around the pseudo-true value. These priors assume that the degree of misspecification is negligible, which seems implausible in many economic applications. We further find that concentration is fragile, in the sense that seemingly small changes to the prior lead posterior concentration to fail dramatically. 1 1 1 While these priors imply that the degree of misspecification is negligible a-priori, our results cover cases where the data violate the model’s over-identifying restrictions to an arbitrarily large extent. Hence, posterior convergence to the pseudo-true value requires that the posterior continues to reflect that misspecification is as small as possible, even once we know that the model is badly wrong. When posterior concentration fails, researchers with different priors on the form and degree of misspecification will have different posteriors for \theta. This naturally raises the question of whether it is possible to give positive results under the class of priors we consider. Our third main result constructs confidence intervals that guarantee correct coverage of \theta under all priors satisfying our rotation-invariance condition. Since we consider the population problem, there is no randomness due to sampling and we instead define coverage using the ex-ante probability under the prior. Our misspecification-robust confidence intervals: 1. are centered at the pseudo-true parameter value; 2. require no researcher input beyond the choice of weighting matrix; 3. have width proportional to the square root of a population J -statistic; and 4. impose no ex-ante upper bound on the degree of misspecification. Since these intervals are valid under a class of priors motivated by the minimum distance objective, they are a natural option for summarizing misspecification-driven uncertainty in settings where researchers adopt a minimum distance approach. Inference under model misspecification is closely related to the large literature on partial identification, and the practice of plugging in pseudo-true parameter estimates for decision-making is an instance of what 20 terms “as-if optimization.” In settings where we are concerned with model misspecification an alternative approach is to explicitly bound the possible degree of misspecification and derive results which are valid under all data generating processes satisfying this bound, for instance by characterizing the identified set for the quantity of interest. We show, however, that computing identified sets under a bound on the norm of the moments at the true parameter leads to counter-intuitive behavior in our setting, where the identified set narrows as the observed violation of the model’s over-identifying restrictions grows worse, rather than widening, as our confidence intervals do. The next section

Read the complete text