Uniform Reinterpretation of Rocky Exoplanet Secondary Eclipse Observations and the Impact of Stellar and Orbital Uncertainties
Christopher Monaghan, Björn Benneke, Nicholas J. Connors, Louis-Philippe Coulombe, Pierre-Alexis Roy · 2026
Read Uniform Reinterpretation of Rocky Exoplanet Secondary Eclipse Observations and the Impact of Stellar and Orbital Uncertainties by Christopher Monaghan, Björn Benneke, Nicholas J. Connors, Louis-Philippe Coulombe, Pierre-Alexis Roy (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-15421.txt.
Introduction
Monaghan and four colleagues redo rocky-exoplanet secondary eclipse studies in one shared model that carries star and orbit errors all the way through. Even for a simple dark bare rock, model error in forecast eclipse depth can rival errors in the data, blurring atmosphere verdicts. Their method yields a linear link between model error and errors in planet-star radius ratios and star temperature. That link sets a floor on how sharply future work can pin down composition.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christopher Monaghan, Björn Benneke, Nicholas J. Connors, Louis-Philippe Coulombe, Pierre-Alexis Roy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 80674 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.15421
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Uniform Reinterpretation of Rocky Exoplanet Secondary Eclipse Observations and the Impact of Stellar and Orbital Uncertainties Christopher Monaghan, Björn Benneke, Nicholas J. Connors, Louis-Philippe Coulombe, Pierre-Alexis Roy Abstract Secondary eclipse observations are a powerful way to investigate whether or not a rocky exoplanet hosts an atmosphere, as an atmospheric presence would transport heat to the nightside and render the dayside colder than anticipated. The interpretation of the secondary eclipse observations relies, however, on models based on imperfect knowledge of the host star properties and the system parameters. Any uncertainties in such astrophysical variables will propagate into both atmospheric and bare-rock models, potentially leading to poorly constrained results and erroneous conclusions. In this work, we introduce a framework to efficiently account for the stellar and orbital uncertainties when modeling the emission spectra of rocky exoplanets, and demonstrate its use by reanalyzing the current suite of rocky exoplanets with published eclipse observations. Our analysis reveals notable uncertainty in the predicted eclipse depth even for a simple dark ( A B A_{\mathrm{B}} = 0) bare rock as a result of the finite precision of the system’s parameters and treatment of the host star’s flux. In some cases, the model uncertainty is comparable to the observational uncertainty, further complicating our capability to constrain an atmospheric presence from secondary-eclipse observations. From our modeling schematic, we derive a linear correlation between the model uncertainty and the error in R p / R ∗ R_{\mathrm{p}}/R_{\mathrm{*}} , a p / R ∗ a_{\mathrm{p}}/R_{\mathrm{*}} , and T ∗ T_{\mathrm{*}} , therefore enabling a more robust compositional analysis in future studies. The model uncertainty serves as a fundamental precision limit to surface analyses, and must be mitigated to strongly constrain the composition of exoplanets in future eclipse observations. I Introduction I.1 Characterization of Terrestrial Exoplanets with Emission Spectroscopy A critical area of research in the modern era of astrophysics is the search for atmospheres on rocky exoplanets. The recent success of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has further accelerated the search for terrestrial exoplanets with atmospheric signatures, particularly in the context of potential habitability ( Kreidberg & Stevenson 2025 ) . Transmission spectro- scopy has long been the primary method of atmospheric characterization for both terrestrial planets and gas giants ( Kreidberg 2018 , Deming et al. 2018 ) . However, for smaller worlds with weaker signals, the Transit Light Source (TLS) effect may inject contaminants into the transit data that dominate the observed spectra, potentially leading to false detections and systematic errors ( Rackham et al. 2018 , Rackham et al. 2019 , Rackham et al. 2023 , Rackham & de Wit 2024 , e.g.,) . Planet R_{\mathrm{p}}/R_{\mathrm{*}} a_{\mathrm{p}}/R_{\mathrm{*}} T_{\mathrm{*}} log(g) ∗ [M/H] ∗ T_{\mathrm{max}} K log 10 (cm/s 2 ) dex K TOI-561 b 0.0152 \pm 0.0003 2.69 \pm 0.02 5372 \pm 70 4.50 \pm 0.12 -0.40 \pm 0.12 2947 \pm 45 K2-141 b 0.0203 \pm 0.0009 2.36 \pm 0.07 4570 \pm 100 4.62 \pm 0.03 0.00 \pm 0.06 2689 \pm 71 55 Cnc e 0.0182 \pm 0.0002 3.52 \pm 0.01 5214 \pm 53 4.38 \pm 0.05 0.37 \pm 0.02 2560 \pm 37 TOI-431 b 0.0160 \pm 0.0007 3.32 \pm 0.13 4850 \pm 75 4.60 \pm 0.06 0.20 \pm 0.05 2404 \pm 56 GJ 367 b 0.0140 \pm 0.0003 3.33 \pm 0.16 3522 \pm 70 4.78 \pm 0.03 -0.01 \pm 0.12 1744 \pm 54 TOI-1685 b 0.0296 \pm 0.0006 5.37 \pm 0.22 3575 \pm 53 4.78 \pm 0.03 0.30 \pm 0.10 1394 \pm 35 GJ 1252 b 0.0277 \pm 0.0011 5.03 \pm 0.27 3458 \pm 140 4.83 \pm 0.05 0.10 \pm 0.10 1392 \pm 67 LTT 3780 b 0.0321 \pm 0.0007 6.79 \pm 0.29 3358 \pm 92 4.85 \pm 0.11 0.06 \pm 0.11 1167 \pm 39 LHS 3844 b 0.0635 \pm 0.0009 7.11 \pm 0.03 3036 \pm 77 5.06 \pm 0.01 - 1031 \pm 33 GJ 486 b 0.0372 \pm 0.0001 11.38 \pm 0.15 3317 \pm 37 4.91 \pm 0.01 -0.15 \pm 0.13 889 \pm 12 TOI-1468 b 0.0346 \pm 0.0010 12.20 \pm 0.35 3376 \pm 45 4.85 \pm 0.03 -0.01 \pm 0.22 873 \pm 16 LHS 1478 b 0.0439 \pm 0.0015 16.35 \pm 0.55 3415 \pm 82 5.02 \pm 0.03 -0.38 \pm 0.29 763 \pm 22 GJ 1132 b 0.0494 \pm 0.0001 15.26 \pm 0.59 3229 \pm 78 5.04 \pm 0.03 -0.17 \pm 0.15 746 \pm 22 GJ 3929 b 0.0318 \pm 0.0007 17.05 \pm 0.43 3384 \pm 88 4.89 \pm 0.05 -0.02 \pm 0.12 743 \pm 23 LTT 1445 A b 0.0454 \pm 0.0012 30.23 \pm 2.35 3340 \pm 150 4.98 \pm 0.07 -0.34 \pm 0.09 549 \pm 31 LHS 1140 c 0.0528 \pm 0.0013 26.88 \pm 0.62 3096 \pm 48 5.04 \pm 0.02 -0.15 \pm 0.09 539 \pm 10 TRAPPIST-1 b 0.0859 \pm 0.0004 20.84 \pm 0.16 2566 \pm 26 5.24 \pm 0.01 0.05 \pm 0.09 508 \pm 6 TRAPPIST-1 c 0.0844 \pm 0.0004 28.55 \pm 0.21 2566 \pm 26 5.24 \pm 0.01 0.05 \pm 0.09 434 \pm 5 Table 1: Properties and associated error bars of rocky exoplanets ( R_{\mathrm{p}} \leq 2R ⊕ ) with emission-based observations, sorted by the planet’s maximum dayside temperature. T_{\mathrm{max}} is derived for each planet using Equation 4 . Astrophysical parameters of each planet are set to match those used in the most recent emission-based study, and are sourced from the following for each target: TOI-561 b ( Teske et al. 2025 ) , K2-141 b ( Bonomo et al. 2023 ) , 55 Cnc e ( Hu et al. 2024 ) , TOI-431 b ( Osborn et al. 2021 ) , GJ 367 b ( Goffo et al. 2023 ) , TOI-1685 b ( Burt et al. 2024 ) , GJ 1252 b ( Crossfield et al. 2022 ) , LTT 3780 b ( Bonfanti et al. 2024 ) , LHS 3844 b ( Vanderspek et al. 2019 ) , GJ 486 b ( Mansfield et al. 2024 ) , TOI-1468 b ( Meier Valdés et al. 2025 ) LHS 1478 b ( August et al. 2024 ) , GJ 1132 b ( Xue et al. 2024 ) , GJ 3929 b ( Xue et al. 2025a ) , LTT 1445 A b ( Pass et al. 2023a ) , LHS 1140 c ( Cadieux et al. 2024 ) TRAPPIST-1 b ( Agol et al. 2021 ) , & TRAPPIST-1 c ( Agol et al. 2021 ) . Thermal emission measurements of a planet’s surface flux during a secondary eclipse have emerged as an efficient method for detecting atmospheres on tidally locked rocky worlds ( Alonso 2018 , Seager & Deming 2009 , Mansfield et al. 2019 , Koll et al. 2019 ) . Both photometric and spectroscopic observations of a planet’s occultation can be used to constrain a planet’s atmospheric presence and composition. Secondary eclipse observations directly measure the planet’s occultation depth, which encodes the surface flux of both the host star and the planet ( f_{\mathrm{*}} and f_{\mathrm{p}} , respectively). Across the bolometric wavelength space, the eclipse depth can be modeled as: (F_{\mathrm{p}}/F_{\mathrm{*}})(\lambda)=\left(\frac{R_{\mathrm{p}}}{R_{\mathrm{*}}}\right)^{2}\frac{f_{\mathrm{p}}(\lambda)}{f_{\mathrm{*}}(\lambda)} (1) Where R_{\mathrm{*}} and R_{\mathrm{p}} are the radii of the star and planet, respectively. The eclipse depth can be used to infer the planet’s dayside brightness temperature T_{\mathrm{d}} , which represents the