Boson star-black hole binaries: initial data and head-on collisions
Zhuan Ning · 2026
Read Boson star-black hole binaries: initial data and head-on collisions by Zhuan Ning (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-15240.txt.
Introduction
Ning studies head-on collisions of comparable-mass boson star and black hole binaries with numerical relativity. Plain superposition badly disturbs the boson star core, causing large constraint breaks and false radial shakes. A one-body conformal fix greatly cuts these flaws in the starting data. With cleaner starts, equal-mass pairs give off more as boson-star tightness rises, nearing the black hole limit, while a two-to-one case gives off slightly more than its black hole match.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhuan Ning |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70489 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.15240
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Boson star-black hole binaries: initial data and head-on collisions Zhuan Ning Abstract We present a numerical-relativity study of comparable-mass boson star-black hole (BS-BH) head-on collisions, focusing on both initial-data construction and gravitational-wave (GW) phenomenology. We show that plain superposition can strongly perturb the BS core, leading to large constraint violations and unphysical radial oscillations. To remedy this problem, we introduce a one-body conformal-factor correction and find that it robustly suppresses these artifacts. Using the improved initial data, we analyze GW emission from equal- and unequal-mass BS-BH binaries and compare with matched BS-BS and BH-BH baselines. For equal masses, the BS-BH radiated energy increases with BS compactness and approaches the BH-BH limit for highly compact stars. For unequal masses, the dominant ( 2 , 0 ) (2,0) mode often remains close to the BH-BH morphology, whereas the subdominant ( 3 , 0 ) (3,0) mode provides clear discriminatory power when the BH is the heavier companion. Our results identify higher multipoles as a key observable for distinguishing mixed BS-BH mergers from pure BH binaries. I Introduction The existence of dark matter (DM) is supported by a broad range of gravitational observations 90 ; 48 , while its microphysical nature remains unknown and constitutes one of the most important open problems in modern cosmology and fundamental physics 17 ; 60 . Despite extensive laboratory and astrophysical searches, no conclusive non-gravitational detection channel has yet been established 60 ; 79 ; 76 ; 39 . In this context, gravitational-wave (GW) astronomy 3 ; 4 ; 1 offers a complementary and potentially unique avenue 29 ; 18 : if some fraction of DM can form compact self-gravitating structures, their mergers may leave directly observable imprints in the strong-gravity regime. Several DM candidates have been proposed, ranging from particle-like candidates such as weakly interacting massive particles (WIMPs) 102 ; 10 ; 105 ; 113 and sterile neutrinos 54 ; 117 ; 2 , to wave-like candidates such as ultralight scalar fields 69 ; 71 ; 72 , and even macroscopic objects such as primordial black holes (PBHs) 38 ; 65 ; 95 ; 135 ; 93 ; 37 ; 94 ; 80 ; 75 . Among these candidates, scalar fields are particularly well motivated and have been studied extensively. They arise naturally in a wide range of theoretical scenarios, including the QCD axion 52 ; 53 ; 103 , axion-like particles 87 from string-theory compactifications 128 ; 12 , and more general scalar-field DM models. If endowed with mass, scalar fields minimally coupled to gravity can form macroscopic self-gravitating structures 77 ; 106 ; 115 . Complex scalar fields can support static, spherically symmetric configurations in which the field oscillates in time, known as boson stars (BSs) 77 ; 106 , while real scalar fields can instead form long-lived oscillating configurations with a nontrivial time-dependent energy-momentum tensor, called oscillatons 115 (see, e.g., Refs. 114 ; 82 ; 131 ; 22 for reviews). Both types of solutions can arise naturally as end states of gravitational collapse 77 ; 106 ; 78 ; 115 ; 96 ; 40 ; 134 and have a maximum mass scaling as M_{\mathrm{max}}\sim M_{\mathrm{pl}}^{2}/\mu , where M_{\mathrm{pl}} is the Planck mass and \mu is the scalar-field mass. Consequently, depending on the scalar mass, these objects can span a wide range of masses and play very different cosmological roles. Ultralight scalar fields with masses in the range \mu\sim 10^{-22}-10^{-20}\,\mathrm{eV} , often referred to as “fuzzy” DM, have de Broglie wavelengths on astrophysical scales and can therefore modify halo structure on kiloparsec scales, potentially alleviating some of the small-scale tensions of collisionless cold-DM phenomenology 69 ; 71 ; 72 . The corresponding solitonic halo cores 112 ; 130 are mathematically related to self-gravitating bosonic configurations, but they are typically much less compact and much larger than relativistic compact stars. At the same time, axion and axion-like scenarios, as well as string-inspired “axiverse” constructions, motivate a much broader mass range of scalar fields. For heavier scalars, such as \mu\sim 10^{-10}-10^{-16}\,\mathrm{eV} , the associated self-gravitating configurations can span masses from solar to supermassive scales. In addition, modifying the scalar self-interaction potential can further enlarge the allowed ranges of mass and compactness, enabling configurations that behave as exotic compact objects (ECOs) or, in some regimes, as black-hole (BH) mimickers 33 ; 85 ; 127 ; 57 ; 132 . The mergers of such objects can produce strong GW signals that may be detectable by current and future GW observatories, and these signals may be distinguishable from standard BH or neutron-star (NS) mergers through their characteristic features. Motivated by these properties, BS-BS binary mergers have been extensively investigated in numerical relativity, including head-on collisions 16 ; 100 ; 44 ; 88 ; 34 ; 68 ; 74 ; 110 ; 58 ; 13 ; 123 ; 83 ; 61 ; 25 ; 63 and orbital inspirals 99 ; 88 ; 101 ; 20 ; 21 ; 111 ; 19 ; 49 ; 121 ; 122 for both equal- 100 ; 99 ; 44 ; 88 ; 34 ; 101 ; 20 ; 21 ; 111 ; 68 ; 74 ; 110 ; 49 ; 121 ; 13 ; 83 ; 61 ; 25 ; 63 and unequal-mass 16 ; 19 ; 58 ; 122 ; 123 binaries. These studies have revealed rich phenomenology, including waveform degeneracies with BH binaries and the imprint of tidal deformability. Furthermore, other ECO mergers have also been studied, such as oscillaton 67 ; 133 and Proca-star (vector cousins of BSs) 109 ; 32 ; 31 ; 107 binaries. From an astrophysical perspective, if BSs, fuzzy-DM cores, or other scalar-field configurations populate the Universe, their coexistence with BHs and their inevitable interactions are highly probable. In this context, the nonlinear dynamics of scalar fields coupled to BHs—including scalar-field accretion 108 ; 70 ; 46 ; 35 ; 27 ; 26 , scalarization 98 ; 124 ; 136 ; 55 ; 42 ; 66 , descalarization 125 ; 41 , superradiance 28 ; 14 ; 84 , dynamical friction 129 ; 24 , and dynamical transition processes 92 ; 43 ; 138 ; 137 —have been widely explored in various strongly gravitating systems, revealing rich time-evolution behaviors and phase structures. It is therefore also crucial to understand the dynamics and GW signatures of mixed BS-BH binary mergers for interpreting future observations and constraining the existence of such objects. Compared with BS-BS binaries, BS-BH binaries remain significantly less explored. Ref. 45 presented the first fully relativistic simulations of head-on collisions between oscillatons (axion stars, ASs) and BHs/NSs, finding that in the AS-BH case the remaining scalar cloud after merger can be enhanced by decreasing the compactness of the AS and increasing the BH spin. For BS-BH binaries, Refs. 36 ; 139 studied piercing collisions, focusing on the large-mass-ratio regime, in which a small BH pierces a much larger BS. They found that the scalar field is almost entirely accreted by the BH for both mini and solitonic BSs. In addition, a small fraction of the scalar field survives outside the BH horizon and forms a long-lived quasi-bound state comoving with the BH, i.e., a “gravitational atom”. However, as discussed above, BS masses can span a wide