Sampling the Graviton Pole and Deprojecting the Swampland

Guangzhuo Peng a,b,c , Laurentiu Rodina d , Anna Tokareva a,f,e , Yongjun Xu a,b,c · 2026

Read Sampling the Graviton Pole and Deprojecting the Swampland by Guangzhuo Peng a,b,c , Laurentiu Rodina d , Anna Tokareva a,f,e , Yongjun Xu a,b,c (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-15235.txt.

Introduction

Peng and colleagues build a primal bootstrap method for effective field theories with a graviton pole. Using finite-resolution sampling instead of smearing, with direct control over subtraction counts, they reproduce known projective bounds in six or more dimensions and tighten them in five. The method also imposes linearized unitarity directly and opens access to extremal spectra. Applied to crossing-symmetric dispersion relations, it yields new non-projective bounds fixing the overall scale of couplings, showing the cutoff cannot sit far above the Planck scale.

Catalog record

CREATORGuangzhuo Peng a,b,c , Laurentiu Rodina d , Anna Tokareva a,f,e , Yongjun Xu a,b,c
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE85829
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.15235

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sampling the Graviton Pole and Deprojecting the Swampland Guangzhuo Peng a,b,c , Laurentiu Rodina d , Anna Tokareva a,f,e , Yongjun Xu a,b,c Abstract We develop a primal bootstrap framework for effective field theories in the presence of a graviton pole, based on finite-resolution sampling rather than smearing, while also allowing direct control over the number of subtractions. We show that this approach reproduces the known projective bounds obtained from smearing in D ≥ 6 D{\geq}6 , while yielding slightly stronger bounds in D = 5 D{=}5 . This method also makes it straightforward to impose linearized unitarity directly and provides an access to the extremal spectra. Applying the method to crossing-symmetric dispersion relations, we derive new non-projective bounds that fix the overall scale of the EFT couplings. In D = 5 D{=}5 , for example, we find that M M P ≲ 7.8 \frac{M}{M_{\rm P}}{\lesssim}7.8 , showing that the EFT cutoff cannot be taken parametrically larger than the Planck scale. At the extremal values of the couplings, the spectra exhibit a surprising structure: for projective bounds, they exhibit peaks around quadratic Regge-like trajectories, while for the non-projective bounds they form sharp quadratic bands. In the latter case, the leading coefficients further display an inverse-quadratic dependence on the band number. 1 Introduction Effective field theory (EFT) provides the natural language for describing fundamental physics at accessible energies. In this framework, physical observables are organized as an expansion in energies and momenta divided by a characteristic ultraviolet scale M . Locality, relativistic causality, unitarity, and symmetry principles ensure that this expansion is predictive and systematically improvable. Locality implies that the dynamics can be encoded in a local action built from a finite set of degrees of freedom, while dimensional analysis organizes the EFT into a hierarchy of higher-derivative operators. Each operator is accompanied by an a priori independent Wilson coefficient, encoding information about ultraviolet physics. A central question is therefore: which values of Wilson coefficients are compatible with fundamental principles? Dispersive arguments provide powerful and model-independent answers. Under mild assumptions of analyticity, unitarity, and locality, forward dispersion relations imply positivity constraints on broad classes of Wilson coefficients 2 . Incorporating crossing symmetry further strengthens these results, leading to two-sided bounds consistent with dimensional analysis and largely independent of the ultraviolet completion 93 ; 35 . This program has by now yielded a broad range of constraints on consistent EFTs across many settings—from chiral Lagrangians and scalar EFTs to gauge theories, gravitational EFTs, SMEFT, and scalar-tensor systems—using a correspondingly diverse set of tools, including dispersive positivity bounds, crossing-symmetric sum rules, dual and primal bootstrap methods, positive geometries or moment-problem formulations 86 ; 85 ; 78 ; 71 ; 88 ; 18 ; 65 ; 17 ; 21 ; 5 ; 47 ; 48 ; 46 ; 97 ; 6 ; 92 ; 73 ; 33 ; 50 ; 25 ; 72 ; 31 ; 90 ; 9 ; 64 ; 57 ; 62 ; 53 ; 20 ; 63 ; 67 ; 41 ; 69 ; 79 ; 99 ; 38 ; 80 ; 45 ; 68 ; 24 ; 74 ; 44 ; 1 ; 7 ; 98 ; 54 ; 76 ; 89 ; 34 ; 32 ; 96 ; 23 ; 14 ; 49 ; 19 ; 100 ; 27 ; 16 ; 58 ; 55 . Once dynamical gravity is included, these questions take on a qualitatively different character. Broad swampland considerations suggest that not every apparently consistent low-energy EFT can arise from quantum gravity 94 ; 81 ; 29 ; 82 ; 95 . More concretely, ideas such as the Weak Gravity Conjecture 10 and the Completeness Hypothesis 13 ; 12 ; 87 point toward the expectation that gravity places sharp and intrinsically nontrivial constraints on the spectrum and interactions of any effective theory. From this perspective, the S-matrix bootstrap provides a particularly natural framework: it allows one to formulate these questions directly in terms of general consistency conditions—analyticity, unitarity, crossing symmetry, and causality—without committing to a specific microscopic UV completion. In this sense, bounding gravitational EFT data from the S-matrix is not merely a technical exercise, but a concrete and model-independent route toward characterizing the boundary between the Landscape and the Swampland. However, with gravity, the standard dispersive analysis encounters a new technical obstruction. Forward scattering amplitudes are dominated by t -channel graviton exchange, leading to infrared singularities that invalidate the standard positivity arguments based on fixed- t dispersion relations. In Ref. 33 this problem was overcome by reformulating the dispersion relations in terms of smearing over wavepackets localized in impact-parameter space. While conceptually powerful, the smearing approach is not well suited to implementing linearized unitarity beyond positivity alone. Linearized unitarity is a pointwise constraint in partial-wave space, 0\leq\rho_{J}(s)\leq 2, whereas smearing introduces nonlocal correlations that obscure this linear structure and complicate the numerical implementation. This limitation is closely tied to the geometry of EFT coupling space. With positivity alone, the constraints are homogeneous in the spectral density and define a projective convex cone—the EFT-hedron—so that only ratios of Wilson coefficients are bounded 8 ; 42 . Once the upper bound \rho_{J}(s)\leq 2 is imposed, this scaling is broken and the cone is deprojected into a bounded, non-projective region 43 ; 41 . In the presence of gravity this deprojection is especially significant, because the gravitational coupling itself is a physical parameter that cannot be scaled away. Motivated by these observations, we develop an alternative primal bootstrap framework that can overcome the gravitational pole, based on sampling the functional constraints at finite kinematic resolution. This perspective allows us to impose positivity and linearized unitarity in a direct and numerically tractable way, and to derive absolute, non-projective bounds in gravitational EFTs. A further intrinsic advantage of the primal approach is that it automatically returns the extremal spectra. Our implementation differs from the ” \rho primal bootstrap” of 57 , which effectively assumes improved UV behavior and, correspondingly, a zero-subtraction dispersion relation. By contrast, in our approach the number of subtractions is an explicit input and can be controlled exactly. Concretely, we start from the fixed- t , k=2 improved sum rules of Refs. 33 , which relate the low-energy EFT data to an integral over the UV spectral density. Schematically, they take the form \mathrm{IR}_{k=2}(t)=\mathrm{UV}_{k=2}(t), (1) namely \displaystyle\frac{8\pi G}{-t}+2g_{2}-g_{3}t \displaystyle=\left\langle\frac{(2s^{\prime}+t)\,P_{J}\!\left(1+\frac{2t}{s^{\prime}}\right)}{s^{\prime}(s^{\prime}+t)^{2}}-\frac{t^{2}}{(s^{\prime})^{3}}\left(\frac{(4s^{\prime}+3t)\,P_{J}(1)}{(s^{\prime}+t)^{2}}+\frac{4t\,P_{J}^{\prime}(1)}{(s^{\prime})^{2}-t^{2}}\right)\right\rangle (2) \displaystyle\equiv\left\langle C^{\mathrm{improved}}_{2,t}[s^{\prime},t,J]\right\rangle, where \bigl\langle\cdots\bigr\rangle\equiv\sum_{J=0}^{\infty}n_{J}^{(D)}\int_{M^{2}}^{\infty}\frac{\mathrm{d}s^{\prime}}{\pi}\,{s^{\prime}}^{\frac{2-D}{2}}\,\rho_{J}(s^{\prime})\,(\cdots). (3) Our strategy is then simply to impose this dispersive relation at a finite set of kinematic points t_{i}\in(-1,0) , \mathrm{IR}_{2}(t_{i})=\mathrm{UV}_{2}(t_{i})\,,\qquad i=1,\dots,N_{t}, (4) thereby turning the continuous bootstrap constraint into a finite system suitable for the primal optimization problem. These are manifestly necessary conditions. In the limit of sufficiently dense sampling, one expects this procedure to converge, producing robust and optimal bounds that are equivalent to smearing. Given the resulting set of N_{t} equations, we solve the constraints using a primal bootstrap approach 41 . The basic idea is to discretize the dispersive energy integral into N_{\mu} points, truncate the spin sum to J_{\textrm{max}} , and treat the resulting finite collection of spectral densities as optimization variables. Positivity or linearized unitarity can then be imposed directly as linear constraints, and higher- k sum rules or null constraints can be incorporated simply by

Read the complete text