Recurrence Time for Finite Quantum Systems
Chaitanya Gupta, Anthony J. Short · 2026
Read Recurrence Time for Finite Quantum Systems by Chaitanya Gupta, Anthony J. Short (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-14995.txt.
Introduction
Gupta and Short study recurrence time for finite quantum systems. Recurrence time means the time for all time-evolved states to return close to their initial configuration, with at least one state deviating significantly meanwhile. For finite-dimensional systems evolving unitarily, they bound recurrence time for continuous and discrete time using Dirichlet's approximation theorem. They relate bounding recurrence time to approximating differences of real numbers by rationals, and prove a mathematical result on the latter giving tighter bounds.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chaitanya Gupta, Anthony J. Short |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40053 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.14995
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Recurrence Time for Finite Quantum Systems Chaitanya Gupta, Anthony J. Short Abstract We study the time it takes for all states of a finite quantum system to return simultaneously to their original configuration. In particular, we define the recurrence time for a quantum system to be the time at which all time-evolved states are close to their initial configuration, and at least one state has deviated significantly during this interval. Considering finite-dimensional quantum systems evolving unitarily, we find bounds on this notion of recurrence time, for continuous time and discrete time, by using Dirichlet’s approximation theorem. We show how the problem of finding a bound on recurrence time can be related to approximating the difference of real numbers by rationals. We present a mathematical result on the latter, which we then use to obtain tighter bounds on recurrence time. I Introduction How long does it take for a quantum system to come back to its original state? The Poincaré recurrence theorem proves that any classical bounded system will eventually return arbitrarily close to its initial state, and an analogous result applies to quantum systems evolving via a time-independent Hamiltonian with a discrete spectrum 4 ; 10 ; 8 . Interestingly, it was noted by Wallace 15 that finite dimensional quantum systems obey a stronger notion of recurrence, in which all states of the system return arbitrarily close to their initial states at the same time . This notion of recurrence is referred to as uniform recurrence. In this paper, we will bound the time for such a uniform recurrence of a quantum system, considering unitary evolution in both continuous time and discrete time (e.g. for a quantum walk or quantum cellular automata 3 ; 5 ). Bounds on the recurrence time for individual states have previously been obtained for continuous time evolution 1 1 1 See also ‘Note Added’ at the end of the paper 2 ; 6 ; 14 . For discrete time evolution, expected recurrence times involving repeated measurements of the time evolved state have also been investigated 7 ; 13 . While we focus on approximate recurrence in this work, 1 studies exact recurrence for Floquet systems. Another interesting work has linked the framework for equilibration and recurrence together 11 . Our approach incorporates both pure and mixed states, and uses the trace distance to quantify the strength of recurrence. To bound the recurrence time, we utilise the simultaneous version of Dirichlet approximation theorem for approximation of real numbers by rationals ( 12 , p. 27) . The theorem states that given any d real numbers \alpha_{1},\alpha_{2},\dots,\alpha_{d} and any integer N>1 , there exists integers q,l_{1},l_{2},\dots,l_{d} such that 1\leq q\leq N^{d} and \absolutevalue{\alpha_i - l_i/q}\leq\frac{1}{qN}\text{ for all }i. (1) Moreover, we include some developments of this approach where we only care about approximating differences between real numbers, which may be of mathematical interest in other situations. The paper is structured as follows. In Section II , we define recurrence time for a quantum system. In Section III , we use the simultaneous version of Dirichlet’s approximation theorem to obtain bounds on recurrence time (for both continuous and discrete time systems). In Section IV , we present a result for approximation of difference of real numbers by difference of rational numbers. These results allow us to obtain better bounds for recurrence time in Section V . We conclude with a discussion in Section VI . II Quantum Recurrence Time Let us first discuss what we mean by recurrence time for an individual state. Suppose we have some initial state and we let it evolve for some time. We consider some small number \epsilon . Now, if for some time t_{\mathrm{r}} , the time evolved state is at most \epsilon distance away from the initial state, we might want to call t_{\mathrm{r}} a recurrence time. However, it might be the case that the state never got farther than \epsilon from its initial state. Thus, we will require that the state has to have evolved more than \epsilon away from the initial state at some time before t_{\mathrm{r}} in order to count as a non-trivial recurrence. In order to define this more formally, consider a Hilbert space \mathcal{H} , with D(\mathcal{H}) the space of all valid density operators on \mathcal{H} . We will use the trace distance as a measure of distance between two states, which quantifies the probability of determining which state you have via the optimal measurement. Given some \rho,\sigma\in D(\mathcal{H}) , the trace distance between them is defined as T(\rho,\sigma)\equiv\tr|\rho-\sigma|/2 . Definition 1 (State Recurrence) . Suppose for some initial state \rho(0)\in\mathfrak{D}(\mathcal{H}) , we have a family of time-evolved states \rho(t)\in\mathfrak{D}(\mathcal{H}) , with t\in\tau , where \tau=\mathbb{R}^{+} (continuous time) or \tau=\mathbb{Z}^{+} (discrete time). We say that the state \rho(0)\in\mathfrak{D}(\mathcal{H}) is \epsilon -recurrent (with 0\leq\epsilon<1 ) at time t\in\tau if T(\rho(t_{\mathrm{r}}),\rho(0))\leq\epsilon, (2) and there exists some t^{\prime}<t (with t^{\prime}\in\tau ) such that T(\rho(t^{\prime}),\rho(0))>\epsilon. (3) The second condition is important for the recurrence to be non-trivial. (Otherwise, we consider the recurrence to be trivial.) This definition is close to the notion of recurrence considered in 4 ; 6 . However, we are interested in a stronger, state-independent notion of recurrence. Definition 2 (System Recurrence) . Suppose for some Hilbert space \mathcal{H} , for every initial state \rho(0)\in\mathfrak{D}(\mathcal{H}) , we have a family of time-evolved states \rho(t)\in D(\mathcal{H}) , with t\in\tau , where either \tau=\mathbb{R}^{+} (continuous time) or \tau=\mathbb{Z}^{+} (discrete time). We say that the system is \epsilon -recurrent (with 0\leq\epsilon<1 ) at time t_{\mathrm{r}}\in\tau if (i) for all \rho(0)\in\mathcal{H} , T(\rho(t_{\mathrm{r}}),\rho(0))\leq\epsilon, (4) and (ii) there exists some state \sigma(0)\in\mathfrak{D}(\mathcal{H}) and some time t^{\prime}\leq t_{\mathrm{r}} (with t^{\prime}\in\tau ) such that T(\sigma(t^{\prime}),\sigma(0))>\epsilon. (5) In other words, for a system to be recurrent at some time, all states must recur trivially or non-trivially with at least one state recurring non-trivially 2 2 2 Note that we do not require all states to recur non-trivially, as some states might be stationary (e.g. energy eigestates for Hamiltonian evolution). . This is close to the notion of uniform recurrence in 15 . We are primarily interested in continuous time Hamiltonian evolution and discrete-time unitary evolution. In these cases, time-evolution preserves the purity of the initial state. Thus, for every initial pure state \ket{\psi(0)} , we can write the time-evolved states as \ket{\psi(t)} . Then, the following lemma follows from the joint convexity of the trace distance (See Appendix A for proof). Lemma 1 . Suppose we have a quantum system (associated with some Hilbert space \mathcal{H} ) where time-evolution is unitary. The quantum system is \epsilon -recurrent at time t_{\mathrm{r}} iff (i) for all pure states \ket{\psi(0)}\in\mathcal{H} , T(\ket{\psi(t_{\mathrm{r}})},\ket{\psi(0)})\leq\epsilon, (6) and (ii) there exists some pure state \ket{\varphi(0)}\in\mathcal{H} and some time t^{\prime}<t_{\mathrm{r}} such that T(\ket{\varphi(t^\prime)},\ket{\varphi(0)})>\epsilon. (7) Here, we have used T(\ket{\psi}\!,\ket{\phi}) as a shorthand for T(\outerproduct{\psi}{\psi}\!,\outerproduct{\phi}{\phi})=\sqrt{1-|\!\innerproduct{\psi}{\phi}\!|^{2}} . Thus, for a system undergoing unitary evolution, we only need to consider pure states when proving system recurrence. More precisely, a unitary quantum system is recurrent at some time iff all pure states recur trivially or non-trivially at that time with at least one pure state recurring non-trivially. III Bounds on Recurrence Time using Dirichlet’s Approximation Theorem III.1 Continuous Time Hamiltonian Evolution We first consider quantum systems where