Status of the hadronic light-by-light contribution to the muon g − 2 g-2 and holographic QCD predictions
\firstname Anton \lastname Rebhan \fnsep, \firstname Luigi \lastname Cappiello \fnsep \firstname Josef \lastname Leutgeb \fnsep, \firstname Jonas \lastname Mager \fnsep · 2026
Read Status of the hadronic light-by-light contribution to the muon g − 2 g-2 and holographic QCD predictions by \firstname Anton \lastname Rebhan \fnsep, \firstname Luigi \lastname Cappiello \fnsep \firstname Josef \lastname Leutgeb \fnsep, \firstname Jonas \lastname Mager \fnsep (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-14891.txt.
Introduction
Rebhan, Cappiello, Leutgeb, and Mager review the hadronic light-by-light contribution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment, against holographic QCD. Holographic models had predicted larger axial-vector contributions and short-distance effects than the 2020 White Paper. A new holographic prediction gives tensor mesons a significant short-distance role beyond Melnikov-Vainshtein. Matching the symmetric longitudinal constraint, predicted tensor-meson form factors agree with singly virtual data. Yet they differ from the traditional quark-model ansatz. They add a sizable positive contribution that could explain lattice versus data-driven tension.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | \firstname Anton \lastname Rebhan \fnsep, \firstname Luigi \lastname Cappiello \fnsep \firstname Josef \lastname Leutgeb \fnsep, \firstname Jonas \lastname Mager \fnsep |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25554 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.14891
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Status of the hadronic light-by-light contribution to the muon g − 2 g-2 and holographic QCD predictions \firstname Anton \lastname Rebhan \fnsep, \firstname Luigi \lastname Cappiello \fnsep \firstname Josef \lastname Leutgeb \fnsep, \firstname Jonas \lastname Mager \fnsep Abstract We review the recent progress made with regard to the hadronic light-by-light (HLbL) contribution to the Standard Model prediction of the muon anomalous magnetic moment and how well this compares with predictions from holographic QCD models, which had predicted larger contributions from axial vector mesons and short-distance constraints than the White Paper of 2020. A new holographic prediction concerns tensor-meson contributions, which in holographic QCD play a significant role in short-distance constraints beyond the Melnikov-Vainshtein constraint. When matching also the symmetric longitudinal short-distance constraint, the resulting prediction for the tensor-meson transition form factors agree well with available singly virtual data, but lead to different results than the traditional quark-model ansatz and a sizable positive contribution that could explain the remaining current tension between lattice and data-driven results for the HLbL contribution. 1 Introduction With the successful completion of the Muon g-2 Experiment at the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory in June 2025, the magnetic anomaly a_{\upmu}=(g-2)_{\upmu}/2 is now known with a precision of 124ppb when all available experimental data are combined, namely Muong-2:2025xyk a_{\upmu}^{\text{exp}}=116\,592\,071.5(14.5)\times 10^{-11}\,. (1) Shortly before, the international Muon g-2 Theory Initiative has released an update Aliberti:2025beg (WP25) of the Standard Model (SM) prediction. In contrast to the WP20 result Aoyama:2020ynm the new one completely agrees with the experimental value within errors, owing to the exclusive use of lattice-QCD evaluations of the hadronic vacuum polarization (HVP) as new experimental data on the hadronic cross-section e^{+}e^{-}\to hadrons are contradicting those employed previously to derive HVP from a dispersion integral. Combined with a new evaluation of the hadronic light-by-light (HLbL) contribution Aliberti:2025beg ; Colangelo:2015ama ; Masjuan:2017tvw ; Colangelo:2017fiz ; Hoferichter:2018kwz ; Eichmann:2019tjk ; Bijnens:2019ghy ; Leutgeb:2019gbz ; Cappiello:2019hwh ; Masjuan:2020jsf ; Bijnens:2020xnl ; Bijnens:2021jqo ; Danilkin:2021icn ; Stamen:2022uqh ; Leutgeb:2022lqw ; Hoferichter:2023tgp ; Hoferichter:2024fsj ; Estrada:2024cfy ; Ludtke:2024ase ; Deineka:2024mzt ; Eichmann:2024glq ; Bijnens:2024jgh ; Hoferichter:2024bae ; Holz:2024diw ; Cappiello:2025fyf ; Mager:2025pvz ; Colangelo:2014qya ; Blum:2019ugy ; Chao:2021tvp ; Chao:2022xzg ; Blum:2023vlm ; Fodor:2024jyn where the theoretical uncertainty could be reduced from 18\times 10^{-11} to 9.9\times 10^{-11} the new SM prediction and the experimental world average no longer show any tension at the current (somewhat lower) level of precision ( 63\times 10^{-11} instead of the 43\times 10^{-11} estimated in the WP20 Aoyama:2020ynm ): \Delta a_{\upmu}\equiv a_{\upmu}^{\text{exp}}-a_{\upmu}^{\text{SM}}=38(63)\times 10^{-11}\,. (2) Table 1 displays the status of the hadronic contributions, which are solely responsible for the final error budget, and their development since WP20. Table 1: Comparison of hadronic contributions according to WP25 Aliberti:2025beg to the corresponding numbers from WP20 Aoyama:2020ynm Hadronic contribution ( \times 10^{11} ) WP25 WP20 HVP LO (lattice) 7132(61) 7116(184) HVP LO ( e^{+}e^{-},\tau ) ↯ 6931(40) HVP NLO ( e^{+}e^{-} ) -99.6(1.3) -98.3(7) HVP NNLO ( e^{+}e^{-} ) 12.4(1) 12.4(1) HLbL (phenomenology) 103.3(8.8) 92(19) HLbL NLO (pheno) 2.6(6) 2(1) HLbL (lattice) 122.5(9.0) 82(35) HLbL (pheno + lattice) 112.6(9.6) 90(17) HVP (LO + NLO + NNLO) 7045(61) 6845(40) HLbL 115.5(9.9) 92(18) The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon will continue to serve as an important tool in the quest for physics beyond the SM, and this tool needs to be sharpened above all by resolving the current contradictions between different experiments and lattice simulations for HVP. There is reasonable hope that a substantially improved SM prediction will become available in due course. The second most important theoretical error from HLbL scattering appears to be sufficiently under control already, but it is not much below the experimental error and thus will need further work as well eventually. In fact, the current White Paper result for the HLbL contribution involves a scale factor of 1.5 due to a certain tension between analytic and lattice approaches; hence, a correspondingly smaller HLbL error could be obtained by resolving this issue. In this contribution, we shall review the progress that has been achieved between WP20 and WP25 regarding the HLbL contributions, with a special emphasis on checks on the data-driven approach that have been provided by holographic QCD (hQCD) models. The long-standing open issue on the size of contributions from axial-vector mesons in single exchange diagrams like Fig. 1 and related short-distance constraints (SDCs) has now been tackled by the dispersive approach Hoferichter:2024bae in remarkable agreement with the previous holographic QCD results of Leutgeb:2022lqw . Ref. Hoferichter:2024bae has also revisited the question of tensor-meson contributions with the conclusion that they have been underestimated in previous evaluations Danilkin:2016hnh , and moreover that they contributed with a negative sign. In both, Hoferichter:2024bae and Danilkin:2016hnh , a simple quark model had been assumed. However, in the recent hQCD study by the present authors Cappiello:2025fyf ; Mager:2025pvz even larger and positive contributions have been obtained, which in fact could resolve the current tension between the analytic and lattice results on HLbL. Figure 1: Hadronic light-by-light scattering contribution to a_{\upmu} from single meson exchange In the following, we review the holographic results for single-meson exchange contributions and the resulting short-distance behavior of the HLbL amplitude obtained in Leutgeb:2022lqw ; Cappiello:2025fyf ; Mager:2025pvz . Besides the crucial role of the infinite tower of axial-vector mesons in hQCD, also the one of tensor mesons turns out to play a significant role. Finally we compare the numerical predictions of hQCD models with the current data-driven results of Hoferichter:2018dmo ; Hoferichter:2018kwz ; Ludtke:2024ase ; Holz:2024lom ; Hoferichter:2024bae ; Holz:2024diw . 2 Holographic QCD models and SDCs The hQCD models considered in Leutgeb:2022lqw ; Cappiello:2025fyf ; Mager:2025pvz and in the WP25 Aliberti:2025beg are minimal hard-wall (HW) models Erlich:2005qh ; Katz:2007tf , 1 1 1 The alternative soft-wall (SW) model Karch:2006pv and its extension studied in Colangelo:2023een ; Colangelo:2024xfh have been discarded in the WP25 due to the problems discussed in Leutgeb:2025jmv . where correlation functions of left and right-handed quark currents are described holographically by five-dimensional flavor gauge fields with Yang-Mills action \displaystyle S_{\mathrm{YM}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\frac{1}{4g_{5}^{2}}\int d^{4}x\int_{0}^{z_{0}}dz\sqrt{g}\,g^{PR}g^{QS} (3) \displaystyle\times\;\text{tr}\left(\mathcal{F}^{\mathrm{L}}_{PQ}\mathcal{F}^{\mathrm{L}}_{RS}+\mathcal{F}^{\mathrm{R}}_{PQ}\mathcal{F}^{\mathrm{R}}_{RS}\right), where P,Q,R,S=0,\dots,3,z and \mathcal{F}_{MN}=\partial_{M}\mathcal{B}_{N}-\partial_{N}\mathcal{B}_{M}-i[\mathcal{B}_{M},\mathcal{B}_{N}] , in an AdS background geometry with metric ds^{2}=z^{-2}(\eta_{\mu\nu}dx^{\mu}dx^{\nu}-dz^{2}), (4) conformal boundary at z=0 , and a sharp cutoff at z=z_{0}\sim\Lambda^{-1}_{\mathrm{QCD}} . Flavor anomalies are encoded by the Chern-Simons action S_{\rm CS}=S_{\rm CS}^{\mathrm{L}}-S_{\rm CS}^{\mathrm{R}} with (in differential form notation) S_{\mathrm{CS}}^{\mathrm{L,R}}=\frac{N_{c}}{24\pi^{2}}\int\text{tr}\left(\mathcal{B}\mathcal{F}^{2}-\frac{i}{2}\mathcal{B}^{3}\mathcal{F}-\frac{1}{10}\mathcal{B}^{5}\right)^{\mathrm{L,R}}. (5) The U(1)_{A} anomaly was studied in two different implementations, the Katz-Schwartz model Katz:2007tf in Leutgeb:2022lqw and an implementation through a scalar-extended Chern-Simons action involving so-called superconnections in Leutgeb:2024rfs . Scalar and pseudoscalar quark bilinear operators are dual to a bifundamental scalar field X_{ij} with action S_{X}=\int d^{4}x\int_{0}^{z_{0}}dz\,\sqrt{g}\;\text{tr}\left(|DX|^{2}-M_{X}^{2}|X|^{2}\right), (6) where D_{M}X=\partial_{M}X-i\mathcal{B}_{M}^{\mathrm{L}}X+iX\mathcal{B}_{M}^{\mathrm{R}} and M_{X}^{2}=-3 as dictated by the scaling dimension of q\bar{q} . The vacuum solutions in AdS, X(z)=\frac{1}{2}(M_{q}z+\Sigma\,z^{3}), encode the quark mass matrix M_{q} and the chiral condensate \Sigma . Together with the Witten-Veneziano mass term associated with the U(1)_{A} anomaly this permits to model the nonet of pseudoscalars with good agreement with regard to their spectrum as well as their two-photon couplings Leutgeb:2022lqw ; Leutgeb:2024rfs . In this setup, the pseudoscalars \eta and \eta^{\prime} appear in mixture with a pseudoscalar glueball state. 2.1 SDCs on TFFs Vector meson dominance (VMD) is naturally implemented in hQCD, with an infinite tower of (degenerate) \rho,\omega,\Phi mesons.