Simplification Ad Absurdum? Revisiting Gas Flow Modeling for Integrated Energy System Planning
Thomas Klatzer, Yannick Werner, Sonja Wogrin · 2026
Read Simplification Ad Absurdum? Revisiting Gas Flow Modeling for Integrated Energy System Planning by Thomas Klatzer, Yannick Werner, Sonja Wogrin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-14842.txt.
Introduction
Klatzer, Werner, and Wogrin test what simplified gas-flow models cost energy planning. In a power-hydrogen expansion study, simplifying pressure-flow links and gas dynamics produced plans that fared badly under a dynamic model, through poor expansion, running, and unsupplied hydrogen. Plans built on simplified transport and transport-linepack models showed regret above several thousand percent and lacked robustness across demand levels. Steady-state planning softened the damage but left cost savings untapped by missing linepack flexibility. Efficient algorithms for the dynamic model are the promising next step.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Thomas Klatzer, Yannick Werner, Sonja Wogrin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20528 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.14842
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Simplification Ad Absurdum? Revisiting Gas Flow Modeling for Integrated Energy System Planning Thanks: This work is part of the project iKlimEt (FO999910627), which has received funding in the framework of ”Energieforschung”, a research and technology program of the Klima- und Energiefonds. Thomas Klatzer, Yannick Werner, Sonja Wogrin Abstract This paper analyzes the implications of simplified pipeline gas flow models for integrated energy system planning. A case study of an integrated power–hydrogen expansion planning problem shows that simplifying pressure–flow relationships and gas dynamics can lead to expansion plans that incur substantial regret when evaluated under a more realistic dynamic gas flow model – due to suboptimal system expansion, operation, and non-supplied hydrogen. Numerical experiments show that planning under the highly simplified transport and transport-linepack models – commonly used in expansion studies – can result in regret exceeding several thousand percent and yield expansion plans that lack robustness across demand levels. Planning under steady-state conditions partially mitigates these effects, but still leaves significant cost-reduction potential untapped compared to dynamic planning due to neglected linepack flexibility. Developing efficient solution algorithms for the dynamic model is a promising direction for future research. I Introduction The transition towards decarbonized energy systems increasingly emphasizes integrated planning of the power and gas sectors [ EUEnergySystemIntegration2020 ] to support large-scale production of renewable hydrogen [ EURFNBO2023 ] and transmission via pipelines [ EHB2023 ] . Planning of the underlying power–gas infrastructure is commonly supported by integrated energy system optimization models (ESOMs). Within ESOMs, modeling pipeline gas flows is particularly challenging, as gas transport is governed by nonlinear and non-convex pressure–flow relationships and slow dynamics that enable short-term storage via linepack [ Raheli2025 ] . Against this background, pipeline expansion planning – traditionally addressed by the gas systems community – has received increasing attention in the power systems community. Due to differing objectives, however, the problem is treated differently across the two fields. The gas systems community typically focuses on optimal network design and does not explicitly consider coupled decisions on gas production or storage, e.g., [ Andre2013 , Baufume2013 , Borraz-Sanchez2016 ] . Here, steady-state gas flow models are state-of-the-art for expansion planning, while dynamic models are used for operational control [ Koch2015 , Lenz2021 ] . In contrast, the power systems community focuses on integrated expansion of generation, storage, and transmission across power and gas sectors. Gas flow modeling ranges from dynamic [ Zeng2017 ] , to steady-state [ Borraz-Sanchez2016a ] , to highly simplified transport models that approximate linepack [ Bodal2024 , He2021 ] , or omit it entirely [ Zhao2018 , Neumann2023 ] . Due to its computational efficiency, the latter is commonly used in ESOMs such as PyPSA [ Brown2018 ] and LEGO [ Wogrin2022 ] . Systematic comparisons of modeling approaches across different levels of gas flow representation in expansion planning remain scarce. One notable exception is [ Reuss2019 ] , which analyzes pipeline expansion and hydrogen reconversion in a star- and tree-shaped network under a discrete arc-sizing model, comparing steady-state and transport formulations. However, the study relies on exogenous assumptions for power generation and hydrogen production capacities and does not consider dynamic gas flow representations. Overall, a comprehensive comparison of gas flow modeling choices for expansion planning and a systematic evaluation of commonly used simplifications are missing. In this work, we address this gap by analyzing the implications of considering (or omitting) technical gas flow characteristics on the integrated expansion of renewable-powered electrolyzers and hydrogen transmission pipelines. Specifically, our contributions are twofold: (1) We compile and harmonize a range of pipeline gas flow models within a single modeling framework, enabling straightforward comparison across different levels of technical detail – from a dynamic model that captures nonlinear pressure–flow relationships and slow gas dynamics (linepack) to a highly simplified transport model. (2) We conduct in-depth analyses of expansion outcomes for a stylized yet realistic power-hydrogen system and illustrate the implications of planning decision obtained from simplified gas flow models across demand levels when validated under dynamic conditions. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows: Section II details the hydrogen expansion planning problem, subject to different gas flow modeling choices. In Section III , the numerical experiments and results are presented. Finally, Section concludes the paper. II Methodology This section presents the methodology: Subsection II-A introduces the hydrogen expansion planning problem, Subsection II-B the gas flow prerequisites, and Subsections II-C – II-F the gas flow modeling choices for pipeline expansion planning. II-A Hydrogen Expansion Planning Problem We formulate the hydrogen expansion planning (HEP) problem assuming the perspective of a central planner whose objective is to minimize the total annualized investment and operating cost for hydrogen production and transmission via pipelines over one year. Let \mathcal{T} , \mathcal{I} , \mathcal{E} , \mathcal{A} , \mathcal{D} , and \mathcal{C} denote the sets of time steps, nodes, electrolyzers, pipelines, pipeline diameters, and compressors, indexed by t , i , e , a , d , and c , respectively, where the cardinality of \mathcal{T} is denoted by |\mathcal{T}| . Pipelines and compressors connect node pairs i,j\in\mathcal{I} , such that \mathcal{A},\mathcal{C}\subseteq\mathcal{I}\times\mathcal{I} . Electrolyzers are assigned to nodes using the mapping set \mathcal{M}\subseteq\mathcal{E}\times\mathcal{I} , where (e,i)\in\mathcal{M} if electrolyzer e is located at node i . Let x_{e} denote the number of installed electrolyzers, p^{\mathrm{H}}_{t,e} their hydrogen production ( \text{\,}\mathrm{t} ), and p^{\mathrm{Ns}}_{t,i} the non-supplied hydrogen ( \text{\,}\mathrm{t} ). Pipeline expansion with diameter d is represented by x_{a,d} . Pipeline inflows and outflows ( \text{\,}\mathrm{t} ) are denoted by f^{\mathrm{In}}_{t,a} and f^{\mathrm{Out}}_{t,a} , respectively, with the corresponding average gas flow given by f_{t,a} . Compressor inflows and outflows ( \text{\,}\mathrm{t} ) are denoted by f^{\mathrm{In}}_{t,c} and f^{\mathrm{Out}}_{t,c} . Electrolyzer capacity ( \text{\,}\mathrm{MW} ) is given by the time-variant parameter \overline{P}^{\mathrm{E}}_{t,e} , reflecting the availability of renewable electricity, \eta_{e} denotes the hydrogen-per-electricity conversion efficiency, and \overline{X}_{e} the maximum number of electrolyzers. Hydrogen demand ( \text{\,}\mathrm{t} ) is denoted by D^{\mathrm{H}}_{t,i} . Annualized investment costs are denoted by C^{\mathrm{Inv}}_{e} for electrolzyers ( \text{\,}\mathrm{\mbox{€}} ) and C^{\mathrm{Inv}}_{a,d} for pipeline expansion ( \text{\,}\mathrm{\mbox{€}} ) with diameter d . Operating costs comprise electricity costs ( \text{\,}\mathrm{\mbox{€}} ) for hydrogen production C^{\mathrm{E}}_{t,e} and a penalty ( \text{\,}\mathrm{\mbox{€}} ) for non-supplied hydrogen C^{\mathrm{Ns}} . Finally, \Delta denotes the time resolution ( \text{\,}\mathrm{h} ). The HEP problem is formulated as follows: \displaystyle\min \displaystyle\sum_{e\in\mathcal{E}}C^{\mathrm{Inv}}_{e}x_{e}+\sum_{a\in\mathcal{A}}\sum_{d\in\mathcal{D}}C^{\mathrm{Inv}}_{a,d}x_{a,d} \displaystyle+\frac{8760}{\Delta\cdot\mathcal{|T|}}\sum_{t\in\mathcal{T}}\Delta\Big(\sum_{e\in\mathcal{E}}C^{\mathrm{E}}_{t,e}p^{\mathrm{H}}_{t,e}/\eta_{e}+\sum_{i\in\mathcal{I}}C^{\mathrm{Ns}}p^{\mathrm{Ns}}_{t,i}\Big) (1a) s.t. \displaystyle\sum_{a(j,i)\in\mathcal{A}}f^{\mathrm{In}}_{t,a}-\sum_{a(i,j)\in\mathcal{A}}f^{\mathrm{Out}}_{t,a}+\sum_{c(j,i)\in\mathcal{C}}f^{\mathrm{In}}_{t,c} \displaystyle-\sum_{c(i,j)\in\mathcal{C}}f^{\mathrm{Out}}_{t,c}+\sum_{e:(e,i)\in\mathcal{M}}p^{\mathrm{H}}_{t,e}+p^{\mathrm{Ns}}_{t,i}=D^{\mathrm{H}}_{t,i}\quad\forall t,i (1b) \displaystyle 0\leq p^{\mathrm{H}}_{t,e}\leq\eta_{e}\overline{P}^{\mathrm{E}}_{t,e}x_{e}\quad\forall t,e (1c) \displaystyle 0\leq x_{e}\leq\overline{X}_{e}\quad\forall e (1d) \displaystyle x_{a,d}\in\{0,1\}\quad\forall a,d (1e) \displaystyle\sum_{d\in\mathcal{D}}x_{a,d}=1\quad\forall a (1f) \displaystyle\text{gas flow modeling choice}~\eqref{eqn:Dynamic_MINLP}\vee\eqref{eqn:Steady_MINLP}\vee\eqref{eqn:TP_Disc_Flow}\vee\eqref{eqn:TP_Disc_Linepack} (1g) For the HEP problem ( 1 ), the objective function is given by ( 1a ). Constraint ( 1b ) enforces the hydrogen balance, while ( 1c ) limits hydrogen production from electrolyzers to their expanded capacity. The number of installed electrolyzers is constrained by ( 1d ). Pipeline expansion is modeled as a binary decision variable ( 1e ), with at most one diameter selected per pipeline ( 1f ). Gas transmission ( 1g ) in the HEP problem can be modeled at different levels of physical detail and dynamics, which are introduced in the following Subsections, starting with the prerequisites for gas flow modeling. II-B Gas Flow Modeling Prerequisites Following standard assumptions in the literature, e.g., [ Koch2015 , Lenz2021 ] , gas flow