Revisiting Ca II Activity Indices in FGK Stars: Systematic Biases in Infrared Triplet Measurements Facilities: LAMOST ( 20 ) iSpec ( 14 ; 16 ) , Astropy ( 9 ; 7 ; 8 ) , NumPy ( 30 ) , Matplotlib ( 36 ) , Scipy ( 67 )

Xiaozhen Yang, Xiaoting Fu, Mingjie Jian, Jingkun Zhao, Hailong Yuan, Zhongrui Bai, Mengxin Wang, Yiqiao Dong, Mingkuan Yang, Ziyue Jiang, Qian Liu, Ganyu Li, Haotong Zhang · 2026

Read Revisiting Ca II Activity Indices in FGK Stars: Systematic Biases in Infrared Triplet Measurements Facilities: LAMOST ( 20 ) iSpec ( 14 ; 16 ) , Astropy ( 9 ; 7 ; 8 ) , NumPy ( 30 ) , Matplotlib ( 36 ) , Scipy ( 67 ) by Xiaozhen Yang, Xiaoting Fu, Mingjie Jian, Jingkun Zhao, Hailong Yuan, Zhongrui Bai, Mengxin Wang, Yiqiao Dong, Mingkuan Yang, Ziyue Jiang, Qian Liu, Ganyu Li, Haotong Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-14642.txt.

Introduction

Yang's team of thirteen probes negative calcium-two infrared triplet indices in solar-like FGK stars from LAMOST, MaStar, and XSL. Observational effects add scatter but miss the bias. The bias arises because surface models lack outer layers, whose heat rise adds triplet opacity, darkening cores past model shapes. Stronger source-function boost in H-and-K lines makes their cores appear in emission more often, and raising small-scale velocity partly offsets it. Indices from other build setups show steady offsets yet strong linear links, so cross-matching works.

Catalog record

CREATORXiaozhen Yang, Xiaoting Fu, Mingjie Jian, Jingkun Zhao, Hailong Yuan, Zhongrui Bai, Mengxin Wang, Yiqiao Dong, Mingkuan Yang, Ziyue Jiang, Qian Liu, Ganyu Li, Haotong Zhang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70808
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.14642

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Revisiting Ca II Activity Indices in FGK Stars: Systematic Biases in Infrared Triplet Measurements Facilities: LAMOST ( 20 ) iSpec ( 14 ; 16 ) , Astropy ( 9 ; 7 ; 8 ) , NumPy ( 30 ) , Matplotlib ( 36 ) , Scipy ( 67 ) Xiaozhen Yang, Xiaoting Fu, Mingjie Jian, Jingkun Zhao, Hailong Yuan, Zhongrui Bai, Mengxin Wang, Yiqiao Dong, Mingkuan Yang, Ziyue Jiang, Qian Liu, Ganyu Li, Haotong Zhang Abstract Synthetic-template subtraction is widely used to measure chromospheric activity in large spectroscopic surveys. However, many solar-like FGK stars show systematically negative Ca II infrared triplet (IRT) residual indices, implying that the observed line cores are deeper than those predicted by parameter-matched templates. We investigate this effect using solar-like stars from LAMOST DR9, MaStar, and XSL DR3, measuring activity indices ( R + R^{+} ) for both the Ca II H&K and IRT lines in a uniform framework. We find that observational effects, including atmospheric-parameter offsets, treatment of the instrumental line-spread function, and propagated measurement uncertainties, contribute to scatter but do not explain the systematic negative bias in R IRT + R^{+}_{\rm IRT} . The results instead suggest that the negative bias most likely arises because photospheric templates underestimate the depth of the IRT cores, likely owing to missing chromospheric structure and, to a lesser extent, NLTE effects. An empirical increase in the adopted microturbulent velocity deepens the synthetic IRT cores and partially mitigates the negative offset. In addition, R + R^{+} values derived from different synthesis configurations show systematic offsets but generally preserve strong linear correlations, indicating that they can be cross-calibrated. These results clarify the origin of negative Ca II IRT residual indices and help interpret template-dependent systematics in chromospheric activity measurements based on synthetic-template subtraction. ] show][email protected] I Introduction In the chromospheres of cool stars, non-radiative heating processes, including magnetic heating, together with reduced radiative cooling, lead to an outward increase in temperature ( 48 ; 23 ) . Under these conditions, chromospheric heating produces emission in the cores of strong spectral lines, such as Ca II H&K, the Ca II infrared triplet (IRT), and Mg II h and k. The strength of this emission reflects the level of chromospheric heating and is therefore widely used as a diagnostic of stellar magnetic activity ( 21 ) . Among these diagnostics, the Ca II H&K and IRT lines are among the most commonly used. In vacuum, their central wavelengths are 3934.78 Å (K), 3969.59 Å (H), and 8500.35 Å, 8544.44 Å, and 8664.52 Å (IRT). These lines form at different atmospheric heights and exhibit different emission strengths. Observations and numerical simulations of the quiet Sun indicate that the line cores of the H&K originate in the upper chromosphere ( 64 ; 13 ) , and the cores of the IRT lines form in the lower chromosphere ( 13 ; 48 ) . Enhanced chromospheric heating leads to stronger line-core emission, with the H&K lines generally showing stronger emission than the IRT ( 46 ; 47 ; 62 ; 56 ) . Large spectroscopic surveys have widely adopted template-subtraction methods to measure chromospheric activity, because the photospheric contribution can be explicitly removed using synthetic spectra matched to the stellar atmospheric parameters ( 4 ; 17 ) . The resulting activity index is defined from the template-subtracted residual core flux and represents the excess chromospheric emission. This strategy is particularly well suited to survey data, for which empirical calibrations such as the R^{\prime}_{\rm HK} index ( 55 ) , derived from the Mount Wilson S_{\rm MW} index ( 69 ; 22 ) , are not always straightforward to apply uniformly across broad ranges of stellar parameters, spectral resolution, and data quality. The rapid development of synthetic spectral libraries has further enabled such measurements for very large stellar samples. However, several survey-based studies have reported negative Ca II IRT activity indices in a significant fraction of stars, which is not expected under standard assumptions. For example, 44 derived IRT activity indices from Gaia DR3 Radial Velocity Spectrometer (RVS) spectra ( 24 ; 25 ) using synthetic MARCS spectra, while 35 measured R^{+}_{\rm IRT} indices from low-resolution spectra in the ninth data release (DR9) of the Large Sky Area Multi-Object Fiber Spectroscopic Telescope (LAMOST; 20 ) using BT-Settl spectra ( 3 ; 2 ) . Both studies reported a substantial number of negative values, suggesting that this phenomenon is not specific to a particular survey and that the observed cores can be systematically deeper than those predicted by parameter-matched synthetic spectra. This mismatch appears to be more pronounced in the IRT lines than in H&K. The mismatch in the IRT line cores reflects a more general limitation in the correspondence between observed spectra and photospheric templates ( 42 ) . Similar concerns have been noted in Gaia RVS analyses, where the IRT cores were avoided in abundance measurements and activity-related spectral discrepancies were recognized as a source of unreliable parametrization ( 57 ) . Understanding the origin of this core discrepancy is therefore important for interpreting survey-based chromospheric diagnostics from large spectroscopic datasets such as LAMOST and Gaia. More broadly, clarifying why the observed and template spectra diverge in the IRT cores can improve the reliability of template-subtraction-based activity measurements, help explain potential biases in abundance analyses based on these lines, and enable more robust use of the IRT lines in large spectroscopic surveys. In this work, we investigate the origin of negative Ca II IRT residual indices derived through template-subtraction methods from both the observational and template perspectives and assess how the adopted synthetic templates affect the resulting activity measurements. Section II introduces the observational samples and synthetic templates. Section III describes the activity-index definitions and measurement procedures. Section IV presents the LAMOST activity indices and introduces the negative IRT phenomenon. Section V examines the contributions of observational systematics and template-related mismatch. Section VI presents an empirical microturbulence-based mitigation. Section VII investigates the dependence of R^{+} on the synthesis configurations and the potential for cross-calibration. Our conclusions are summarized in Section VIII . II Observational Data and Synthetic Templates This section presents the observational samples used in this work, and the synthetic spectra adopted as photospheric templates. The three observational data sets serve complementary purposes: LAMOST DR9 provides the primary large-sample data set for statistical analysis, the SDSS DR17 MaNGA Stellar Library (MaStar; 70 ; 1 ) offers an independent survey-level comparison for assessing potential systematics, and the X-shooter Spectral Library (XSL) DR3 ( 66 ; 65 ) provides higher-resolution spectra for examining observed–template mismatches in line profiles. An overview of the observational data sets is given in Table 1 , and Figure 1 shows the atmospheric-parameter distributions of the selected stars. These overview summaries provide context for the more detailed descriptions in the following subsections. Table 1 : Summary of the observational data sets used in this work Survey/Data Release Spectral Coverage Resolving Power Wavelength Sampling SNR Criterion N (HK / IRT) ( \lambda/\Delta\lambda ) (Å) LAMOST DR9 LRS HK + IRT \sim 1310 (HK), \sim 1910 (IRT) \sim 1 (HK), \sim 2 (IRT) SNR {}_{r}\geq 50 428 253 MaStar SDSS DR17 HK + IRT \sim 1090 (HK), \sim 2010 (IRT) \sim 1 (HK), \sim

Read the complete text