Topologically non-trivial gap function and topology-induced time-reversal symmetry breaking in a superconductor with singular dynamical interaction
Yue Yu, Andrey V. Chubukov · 2026
Read Topologically non-trivial gap function and topology-induced time-reversal symmetry breaking in a superconductor with singular dynamical interaction by Yue Yu, Andrey V. Chubukov (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-14295.txt.
Introduction
Yu and Chubukov show that a repulsive Hubbard-type interaction, cut off at finite range, can select the subleading topologically nontrivial gap solution in a singular-interaction model. In systems studied so far the trivial gap holds the lowest energy, but in some range the added term favors the nontrivial one. A minimal model displays the switch, which must pass through a middle phase with topology-induced time-reversal breaking. The work thus ties unusual pairing to multiple topologically distinct gap functions from a singular frequency-dependent interaction.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yue Yu, Andrey V. Chubukov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44746 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.14295
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Topologically non-trivial gap function and topology-induced time-reversal symmetry breaking in a superconductor with singular dynamical interaction Yue Yu, Andrey V. Chubukov Abstract In many strongly correlated electron systems, non-Fermi liquid behavior and unconventional superconductivity can be viewed as emerging from an effective 4-fermion interaction with a singular frequency dependence. A pairing instability in such a system is qualitatively different from that in a Fermi liquid and generally gives rise to multiple pairing states with topologically distinct gap functions. However, in the systems studied so far, a topologically trivial solution has the lowest energy. Here we show that a repulsive Hubbard-type interaction with a finite cutoff added to a model with a singular dynamical interaction selects, in some parameter range, the theretofore subleading, topologically nontrivial solution. We consider a minimal model that displays this behavior and show that the transformation between the topologically trivial and nontrivial gap functions necessarily occurs via an intermediate phase with topology-induced breaking of time-reversal symmetry. A non-Fermi-liquid behavior and unconventional superconductivity in strongly correlated electron systems, e.g., fermions at the \nu=1/2 Landau level Lee 1989 ; *blok1993 ; Nayak and Wilczek 1994 ; *kim1994 ; Altshuler et al. 1994 , clear and dirty quantum-critical metals Bergeron et al. 2012 ; Raghu et al. 2015 ; Abanov et al. 2001 ; *acs ; *acn ; Metlitski and Sachdev 2010a ; *Max_2010a ; *Max_2011 ; *Max_2015 ; Lee 2018 ; Varma 2020 ; Abanov and Chubukov 2020 ; *Abanov2026 ; Shi et al. 2025 ; Wu et al. 2023 , quantum dots Chowdhury et al. 2022 ; Esterlis and Schmalian 2026 ; *classen2021 ; Wang and Chubukov 2020 ; *wang2020solvable , systems near a Mott phase Georges et al. 1996 ; Simard et al. 2019 ; Capone et al. 2009 ; *Capone2023 ; Malcolms et al. 2024 ; Arovas et al. 2022 , are fascinating issues which have attracted substantial interest in recent years in both condensed-matter and high-energy communities. Previous studies have shown that in many such systems, the interplay and competition between tendencies towards non-Fermi liquid (NFL) and pairing are adequately described by assuming that the dominant interaction between fermions is dynamical Nayak and Wilczek 1994 ; Altshuler et al. 1994 ; Raghu et al. 2015 ; Esterlis and Schmalian 2026 ; Abanov and Chubukov 2020 ; *Abanov2026 ; Pimenov and Chubukov 2022 , with a singular frequency dependence in the infrared limit. This singular interaction gives rise to NFL behavior and mediates pairing out of a NFL in a model-specific non-ordinary s- wave channel. Pairing out of a non-Fermi liquid is not associated with the Cooper logarithm, and for this reason, it is qualitatively different from that mediated by a non-singular interaction in a Fermi liquid. An outcome, relevant to this work, is the existence of a tower of topologically distinct solutions of the gap equation Wu et al. 2021a ; *paper5 ; *paper6 ; Zhang et al. 2022 , in sharp contrast with the conventional BCS/Eliashberg theory in which the gap equation has a single solution. A solution \Delta_{n} has n zeros along the Matsubara axis, where \Delta_{n}(\omega_{m}) can be set as real by proper choice of the U(1) gauge, or, equivalently, n by 2\pi phase slips of the phase of complex \Delta_{n}(\omega) along the real axis. In more general terms, each zero of \Delta(z) in the upper (causal) half-plane of z=\omega^{\prime}+i\omega_{m} can be identified as a dynamical vortex as the phase of a complex \Delta(z) varies by 2\pi under an anticlockwise rotation around each such point. These vortices are global objects and their effects can be detected by time-dependent phase-sensitive Josephson interferometry Wolf 2012 and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy Vekhter and Varma 2003 ; Kordyuk et al. 2005 . The topological distinction between the gap functions with different n arises because a vortex cannot be created or annihilated within the causal plane; it may enter or leave the causal plane only from its boundaries, which are the real frequency axis and infinity. 1 1 1 In some models, such as the \gamma -model of metallic quantum criticality with \gamma>1 , the behavior is even more complex, as even the gap function \Delta_{0} with no nodes on the Matsubara axis still possesses dynamical vortices in the upper half-plane of complex frequency. For the models studied so far, e.g. \gamma -models of metallic quantum criticality Abanov and Chubukov 2020 ; *Abanov2026 (and Yukawa-SYK models of quantum dots Esterlis and Schmalian 2026 ; *classen2021 ; Wang and Chubukov 2020 ; *wang2020solvable ), the topologically trivial solution n=0 is the ground state, while solutions with n>0 are saddle points in the space of system parameters Zhang et al. 2022 . Given that other solutions are present, it is highly desirable to find the conditions under which a topologically non-trivial solution is the ground state. Figure 1: Schematic phase diagram for the model with an effective attraction mediated by a dynamical boson with \chi(\Omega_{m})=1/(|\Omega_{m}|^{\gamma}+M^{\gamma}) (the \gamma -model) with additional Hubbard-type repulsion V with a hard energy cutoff E_{V} . The \gamma -model without V has either a single solution for the superconducting gap (as in BCS theory) for M>M_{c} or two solutions for M\leq M_{c} (and more solutions for smaller M , which we don’t consider here). The plots are for different values of M around M_{c} on the (E_{V},V) plane. The numbers 0,1,2 specify the number of dynamical vortices of the gap function in the causal (upper) half-plane of frequency. For M>M_{c} , when there is only one solution for the gap in the pure \gamma -model, there is a parameter range with no superconductivity (labeled as “normal”). For M=M_{c}-0^{+} , when the second solution for the gap in the \gamma -model emerges, this range shrinks to a line ending at point A . For smaller M , superconductivity with a finite gap \Delta(\omega) exists everywhere in (E_{V},V) plane and breaks TRS in some range of E_{V} and V . The phase diagram at M=0 neglects other solutions for the gap function in the \gamma -model. Blue solid lines are a second-order phase transition to the time-reversal symmetry-breaking (TRSB) phase. Black solid lines are second-order superconducting transitions. Red dashed lines are topological phase transitions between phases with 2 and 1 vortices in the causal half-plane. Magenta dotted lines are topological phase transitions between phases with 0 and 2 vortices. In this paper, we report on our findings on such conditions. We consider for definiteness the \gamma -model of quantum criticality, in which the attractive interaction between fermions is provided by a soft boson with mass M , whose dynamical susceptibility on the Matsubara axis is \chi(\Omega_{m})=1/(|\Omega_{m}|^{\gamma}+M^{\gamma}) , where here and below we measure \Omega_{m} , M , and other energy variables in units of fermion-boson coupling, which is the only energy scale in the \gamma -model. We add to this model a repulsive interaction V with a hard upper cutoff at energy E_{V} (controlled in practice by an external gate) and analyze the phase diagram in the (E_{V},V) plane. The limits E_{V}\gg 1 and E_{V}\ll 1 can be viewed as adiabatic and anti-adiabatic Gastiasoro et al. 2020 , respectively. We use the fact that vortex solutions with n>0 disappear one by one as the bosonic mass M increases,